Socialist Worker and
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-01-16Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 2 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 2
Neil Kinnock cannot be fought by staying outside the Labour Party and giving him a clear run. Photo: Andrew Moore.
Denham Two prominent left-wingers and a maverick right-winger have been expelled from Birmingham Sparkbrook Labour Party - Roy Hattersley's constituency.
The expulsions were pushed through by an unholy alliance of 'old guard' rightwingers and one Roger Murray, a former Communist Party member and now a prominent figure in the Labour Coordinating Committee.
The charges against left-wingers Kevin Scally and Amir Khan (a Birmingham City Councillor) stem from their participation in the Channel 4 'Bandung File' programme exposing corrupt practices within Sparkbrook CLP.
Bundle
Kevin Scally appeared in the programme with a bundle of membership applications, all apparently filled in by the same hand, and some giving non-existent addresses.
He had received the applications in his capacity as branch secretary of Sparkhill ward.
For this, he was charged with "bringing the Party into disrepute" . In addition to his participation in the programme, Amir Khan had incurred the wrath of Roy Hattersley's supporters by campaigning for a Black Section in Sparkbrook.
The case of Mohammed Rafique is even more bizarre. A West Midlands County Councillor, Rafique has always sided with the rightwing against the likes of Scally and Khan. But Rafique fell out with Hattersley's supporters when he challenged right-winger John O'Keefe for the nomination as City Council candidate for Sparkbrook. Amidst angry scenes outside the selection meeting, (from which a number of Rafique supporters had been excluded), the County Councillor is alleged to have accused O'Keefe and his supporters of racism. For this too, has been expelled.
Over two-thirds of the total membership of Sparkhill Branch Labour Party, to which Scally and Khan belong, have signed a petition opposing the expulsions.
Birmingham Labour Briefing has held a special public meeting to launch a campaign against the expulsions of Scally and Kahn and also decided to support Rafique's campaign (which he seems to be building among his extensive contacts within the Asian community), despite considerable reservations about his past record.
On 11 December, a 100strong demonstration lobbied the Sparkbrook GMC meeting in protest at Rafique's expulsion.
It seems quite likely that the appeals of Scally and Khan will be successful at regional level. But the Sparkbrook GMC may still refuse to reinstate them. Sparkbrook CLP must be flooded with resolutions demanding the reinstatement of all three expelled members.
The first issue of 'Witch-hunt News' is now available. Sponsored by Labour Left Coordination and the Campaign for Labour Party Democracy, in cooperation with the Campaign Group of MPs, it documents the details of the In addition to the threatened purge in Liverpool, there have been expulsions in Birmingham, Teesside, Sheffield, Exeter, Stevenage, Scotland and many other areas. Not all those victimised have been Militant supporters: supporters of Briefing and individual left activists have also been purged Witch-hunt News is available from: c/o 36 Melbourne Road, London E17. Make cheques payable to Witchhunt News, 20p per copy (includes postage); £1 for ten copies (includes postage). Stan Crooke examines Socialist Worker's response to the witchhunt in the Labour Party and the overtures they are making to Militant Ever since it drifted our of the Labour Party in the late sixties, the Socialist Workers Party has polemicised against socialists joining the Labour Party. Bu now the SWP's main activity is a campaign against socialists being expelled from the Labour Party.
There is a contradiction here. If the witch-hunt is defeated, then socialists will be all the more likely to join and stay in the Labour Party, rather than the SWP. If, on the other hand, large numbers of socialists are expelled or leave the Labour Party in disgust, then some of them might join the SWP. If Labour leftists take the SWP's advice now and leave the Labour Party, then the witch-hunt will triumph by default. If you want to fight the witch-hunt, then you have to stay in the party.
The SWP argues that rightwing control of the Labour Party Is inevitable anyway; what counts is preventing Labour leftists from becoming demoralised and instead recruiting them into a socialist alternative outside the Labour Party (i.e. the SWP).
But the SWP undermine this argument themselves. They claim that they feel obliged to oppose the witch-hunt in the Labour Party because, if successful, it would be a setback for the working class as a whole and lead to a witch-hunt in the unions as well. This is quite correct — and precisely why the fight against right wing control of the Labour Party is not a hopeless irrelevance.
Whether the leti leaves voluntarily or gets booted out, the Labour Party would end up firmly in the handsof the overtly and self-consciously pro-capitalist elements.
Conclusion: the left should stay in and fight every inch of our help because we remind you too much of your past...
"Will the left collapse to the right or to us? I think they'll collapse to the right because all they do is sit around on their backsides instead of getting down to the picket lines.
What lies behind the SWP's apparent about-turn is that they hope to recruit some Militant supporters — not by convincing them politically but by getting them fed up and weary of the fight within the Labour Party.
Conciliatory
Hence the conciliatory approach towards Militant by the SWP over the past twelve months:
*When the black community in Liverpool opposed Militant supporter Samson Bond being parachuted in as race relations adviser, Socialist Worker 912 declared that while Militant may have been mistaken in certain respects, the Black Caucus was "even more mistaken...to create an atmosphere which the Liberals and Tories are trying to exploit."
*SW 941 describea as 'unfortunate" and "a mistake" the voting by Militant supporters in Pollok CLP (Glasgow) for a right wing candidate in the resection contest, as a manoeuvre to carve out the soft-left alternative to the Militant nomination; it directed its main fire at the nonMilitant left for failing to support the Militant nomination.
SW 941 also delivered a stern rebuke to Labour leftists who criticise Militant's politics: "It is at best foolish and at worst gross opportunism for anyone else to denounce Militant in the sectarian language which has been used of late".
*Whereas the SWP pamphlet "Labour Party — Myth and Reality" (1981) attacked Marxists such as Militant, standing in public elections •on a Labour ticket (''They are in a false position from the start...The electors do not know their real views — they have been kidded...they tie one hand behind their backs by sailing under false colours"), a much softer tone has been adopted of late: "These are people who joined the Labour Party because they want to see the lives of working class people improved. Some of them even have a vision of a socialist society. " (SW 964).
*Speaking at this year's SWP conference, Tony Cliff claimed •We've seen a wholesale drift to the right with Militant as the one group that hasn't shifted like this. So, under such conditions, you can't concentrate on the difterences between us and Militant.
The clearest example of the SWP's clumsy efforts to ingratiate themselves with Militant is Liverpool. Last year, the SWP denounced the Militantbacked deal between Liverpool and the Tories as "sold down the Mersey" This year, the SWP has discovered that Liverpool has a "left wing council" (SW 956) or even a "socialist council" (SW 965), which "okay, at the end of the day, was forced into a deal with the Swiss banks" (SW 965).
To be sure, the SWP has not dropped all criticism of Militant's role in the Liverpool debacle.
But there is far less criticism than last year, when Militant actually did better. Nowhere, for example, does the SWP point out that the deal with the Swiss banks had already been fixed up in August, so that Liverpool council's confrontation with the Tories was 50% bluff.
All accusations against Militant's behaviour in Liverpool are denounced as "a concoction of media lies and innuendo" (SW 965) Militant supporters are subject to a "spate of vilific. ation, abuse and organisational attacks." (SW 966).
No mention by the SWP that Militant has left itself wide open to such attacks by the notorious system of patronage it operates in Liverpool. No mention of its insulting attitude towards blacks, voluntary sector workers, white-collar workers and just about anyone else who disagreed with Militant. No mention of the "Hatton Factor" and his unusual holiday in Tangiers, etc., etc.
Cover-up
Socialists must certainly condemn and oppose the NEC inquiry and any subsequent expulsions. But that does not mean lying, swallowing lies or covering up Militant's own breaches of labour movement democracy.
Parading around with their petition and mollycoddling Militant is just the SWP's latest recruitment gimmick. SW 965 let the cat out of the bag when it declared: "By campaigning against the witch-hunt...we can begin to draw together than minority of activists who will be so central in resisting future sell-outs from Kinnock and his friends"
In other words: use the petition to establish a relationship with Militant supporters; don't concentrate on political differences with them; tell them that their only problem is that they're in the Labour Party; and recruit them to the SWP
----- pull-quotes -----
lattersley: ocal purge ocal pur