["Crude communism is only the culmination... of this…]
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-01-16Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
"Crude communism is only the culmination... of this levellingdown proceeding from the preconceived minimum... How little this annulment of private property is really an appropriation is in fact proved by the abstract negation of the entire world of culture and civilisation, the regression to the unnatural simplicity of the poor and undemanding man who has not only failed to go beyond private property, but has not - Karl Marx, writing about the doctrinaires of early 19th century Europe who sought communism before and without a working-class movement, and thus arrived at a programme of 'barracks communism' imposed from above.
Socialist Organiser no.256 16 January 1985 Page 9 Martin Thomas reviews a new of Pol Pot's reign of terror Between 1975 and 1979 Cambodia was transformed into one big slave labour camp.
Everyone, regardless of age or condition, was forced to march into the countryside and to work on the land from 6 am to 5 pm (or sometimes 8 pm) under military supervision. No personal property was allowed, every. one had to wear the same black uniform, and only minimal nourishment was doled out at communal meals.
Some one and a half million people — one-fifth of the population — died from the hardships or in the repeated vast political purges before the regime was overthrown by a Vietnamese invasion in 1979.
Yet the installation of this regime — its military victory over the US-backed Lon Nol government in April 1975 — had been welcomed by most people on the left as a liberation. All these horrors were carried out in the name of democracy, equality, collectivism and liberation. Why and how?
Atrocious
Unlike previous societies which have generated atrocious regimes — Germany or the USSR in the 1930s, Chile in the early 1970s - Cambodia was not torn by acute social tensions. It was overwhelmingly a society of small self-sufficient peasants. There were no hio landlarre enter nut in vig sanvius. The land is fertile. The peasants were poor, and often harassed by money-lenders, but they had a relatively secure and stable life.
into this society there was introduced a peculiar version of the 'combined and uneven development' which Leon Trotsky described as a pattern in the Third World. Elsewhere modern industry came in alongside the peasant economy. Not in Cambodia. But in the 1940s a thin layer of Cambodian youth were introduced to Western education - to ideas, prospects, ambitions far removed from the static society of the Cambodian countryside.
Like middle-class groups in many other Third World countries, they set out to change their society - from above, by the use of state power. The Sihanouk (1941-70) and Lon Nol (1970-9) governments attempted to modernise, but floundered in corruption. Meanwhile, especially after the US invasion in 1970, Cambodian society was pulverised. By 1975 half the population were refugees from US bombing raids. ihe Pol Pot regime of 1975-9 came lo power as ine nnal, most nén tn athan Caat ae = ed drastic attempt to make Cambodia a dynamic nation: A small group of ultra-nationalists were able to rule the war-shattered, bewildered people, and remould society according to doctrine.
Ben Kiernan's book builds up a detailed picture of how this nappened. Kiernan has studied Illasses 01 cocuments in the as a man. 1L -Khmer language and interviewed many refugees, and his account will probably be definitive, though the huge accumulation of detail is sometimes confusing.
In 1949 the first major group of Khmer students to study abroad arrived in Paris. Most of them lived in the same student hostel, and most had been to school together in Cambodia, at Circle' over the included most of the future leaders of the 'Khmer Rouge' - Pol Pot himself. leno Sarv. Rath a vE 4867613 Samouenn, Hou Youn, Thiounn Mumm and his brothers Thioeunn, Prasith and Chum, Touch Phoeun, Khieu Samphan, Khieu Ponnary (who married Pol Pot) and her sister Khieu Thirith (who married leng Sary). Most were from well off backgrounds: the Thiounn family was closely connected to royalty, Pol Pot had spent much of his childhood in the raval haucehald lenn Sar'c family were landowners, Khieu Samphan's father was a judge and so was the Khieu sisters'.
But whatever their origins -Hou Youn came from a peasant family, and Hu Nim, another future Khmer Rouge leader who was at school with the rest but did not go to Paris, from a poor peasant background — these men and women were culturally separated from Cambodian society by an enormous gulf. They seem to have developed ambivalent attitudes, ultranationalist and probably resentful of foreigners who scorned Cambodia as an insignificant backwater, yet impatiently hostile to many of the habits and customs of the Cambodian Some of their distance from the people can be gauged trom the fact that Khieu Ponnary was the first Khmer woman ever to get the equivalent of A-levels.
Over the 1950s they returned to Cambodia. A Communist party of sorts existed there, but it was weak; radical political activity, like such industry as there was (chiefly rubber planAbove: knmer kouge troops.
tations), was dominated by Vietnamese and Chinese living in Cambodia rather than ethnic Khmers. (The only recorded Trotskyist activity in Cambodia, in 1938, also depended on the Vietnamese community in Phnom Penh).
In 1954, as part of the Geneva settlement that arranged France's withdrawal from its former colonies in Indochina, the Cambodian revolutionaries were constrained to accept Prince Sihanouk. The Frenchtrained militants resented this, yet even reached it".
but Sihanouk, envisioning himself as an enlightened despot, set out to co-opt them. Hou Youn, Hu Nim and Khieu Samphan became ministers in Sihanouk governments; others of the Paris group got good and influential jobs in teaching and journalism.
Khieu Thirith described the situation in the 1950s like this: "Back at home we faced opposition from Sihanouk who was in power at that time...However, Sihanouk gave me official employment in a government high school...
*He even asked me to become member of the National Assembly. However, as our Party advised against it, 1 politely refused the offer. I knew Sihanouk very well, and both our families were in acquaintance with each other"
Kiernan comments: 'Hardly a case that bears out her husband leng Sary's claim of "life-and-death struggle' Kight: rol rot.
Similarly, when her sister Khieu Ponnary married Pol Pot on Bastille Day 1956, two officials of the Phnom Penh municipal government arranged for the couple to obtain a nice block of land...The two officials were...a former member of the 'Marxist Circle' in Paris...and Bonnary's cousin. later a leading member of the Lon Nol regime"
In 1960 the Paris group -"twenty or so educated an confident young militants, concentrated in the capital" , as Kiernan puts it — gained control of the "Workers' Party of Kampuchea"
Sihanok gave them kicks as well as halfpence. And Kiernan argues: "the veterans lof Cambodian Stalinism - militants oriented to Vietnam, with their longer political experience, were...more able to cope with their rejection by the regime.
'The youthful militants were less able to withstand either the temptations offered by their relative proximity to power or the resultant disappointment with Sihanouk's refusal to allow them complete authority and to modernise the country as they saw fit.
•Thus their attitudes hardened, whereas the veterans tended to roll with the punches, as people ot peasant origin often have to do"
In 1967 the revolutionaries finally abandoned the capital and started guerilla war against Sihanouk. The Chinese Cultural Revolution seems to have played some role in inspiring them, though Kiernan argues that a detailed influence is hard to demonstrate.
A breakthrough for them came in March 1970, when Lon Nol ousted Sihanouk. Lon Nol turned out to be nothing but a corrupt tool of the US, but his regime attracted some who saw it as an instrument for modernisation free of Sihanouk's whims — Keng Vannsak, a former member of the Paris Marxist Circle, and Bunchhan Mul, an uncle of the Thinunn all uncie brothers.
Pol Pot's group quickly formed an alliance of convenience with Sihanouk under the auspices of the Chinese government. (Both Sihanouk and Pol Pot happened to be in Beijing at the time of the coup).
US invasion
In April 1970 the US invaded Cambodia. and more and more ALAVA Y the Khmer Rouge were able to present themselves as the banner-bearers of the national cause. In 1977 they described their strategy retrospectively as follows:
"Concretely, we did not rely on the forces of the workers...In concrete fact there were only the peasants. Therefore we did not copy anyone"
Initially the Khmer Rouge social programme was moderate and well-supported: rice land over five hectares (a big holding by Cambodian standards) was redistributed to poor peasants. But in 1973, having won a strong military position, the Khmer Rouge launched what they called their 'Democratic Revolution' (Perhaps in order to stress their independence, the Pol Pot group never described their state, their party or their revolution as communist or socialist, but instead as 'democratic' After April 1975 the USSR and East German embassies were forcibly shut down and communications were cut with China).
Traditional multi-coloured clothing was banned and people were forced to wear black uniforms. "Land was to be collectivised...and the produce of the peasants' labour was to be confiscated by the authorities. In some cases, regulations concerning the destruction of religion and family life and enforced communal eating were also implemented...
"Kratie la town] was evacuated. There was to be 'no more trading, mortgaging, labourexchanging or buying on credit'. A 'state' mononnlv was decreed over rice, salt, fuel, cloth and petrol. Without petrol, private owners of trucks, boats, tractors and...motorcycles 'disappeared'; the state took over their equipment...
"Private ownership of land and of the means of production was also abolished."
Hanoi-aligned revolutionaries were also killed, to eliminate nolitinal nanncitinn mumas praluar upposiul, The collapse of the Lon Nol regime in April 1975 led to the extension of this programme to the whole country. Kiernan cites a Khmer Rouge commissar's summary of their programme:
'1. Evacuate people from all towns.
2. Abolish all markets.
3. Abolish Lon Nol currency, and withhold the revolutionary currency that has been printed.
4. Detrock all Buddhist monks and put them to work growing rice. . 5. Execute all leaders of the Lon Nol regime.
6. Establish high-level cooperatives throughout the country. with communal eating.
7. Expel the entire Vretnamese minority population.
8. Dispatch troops to the borders, particularly the Vietnamese border"
Hou Yuon, Hu Nim and Touch Phoeun were executed for opposing this programme, and within days the people of Carabodia were engulfed in a nigtemare.
Ben Kieran. 'How Pol Por Came to Power': Verso £9.95.