Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Contempt breeds familiarity

Socialist Organiser no. 256, 16 January 1986 · scan p. 10 · about 561 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

No-one ever denounced bureaucrats more sharply than Joseph Stalin. No-one ever had more contempt for "trade' than the upper classes of mid-19th century England, the bustling 'workshop of the No-one has ever had more strident things to say against imperialism and for the freedom of subject nations than the ruling class of the United States.

The success of 'Yes, Minister', and now its sequel, 'Yes Prime Minister' , has something of the same flavour about it.

What the TV series says -humorously, but nonetheless unmistakably — is that parliamentary democracy is in large part a sham. The will of the people, refracted through elected politicians, is a very weak thing compared to the inertia of the unelected civil service chiefs.

The first 'Yes, Prime Minister' programme, last week, showed the new premier deciding to scrap Trident in favour of non-nuclear defence - and being cajoled, bullied and manoeuvred into dropping his decision. Finally the prime minister trades off indefinite postponement of a debate on Trident in return for the civil servants providing a cook to do his lunch.

The style is comic, and very well done too. But Colin Foster reviews 'Yes Prime Minister' surely it's black comedy? And grim black comedy, too, for those who tell us that the Westminster system is the highest form of democracy imaginable?

Yet the advertisements for 'Yes, Prime Minister' can have Margaret Thatcher saying how much she enjoys the programme. And in India, where civil service inertia is even less of a light-hearted matter than it is in Britain, 'Yes, Minister' has apparently been a huge success. Its viewers are mainly the elite who own TVs - many of them civil servants themselves.

The answer to the riddle, 1 think, is this: what Yes, Minister' tells us is that some politicians are vain, bumbling fools, and some top civil servants are blinkered obscurantists. But - so the hidden message runs - these politicians and these civil servants are so bumbling and blinkered that really we know that in any serious matter more sensible people would prevail.

For Margaret Thatcher, no doubt, the programme is so enjoyable because it tells her that she is not like the stereotype politician: she does not allow herself to be pushed around by civil servants.

Criticism is disarmed by being exaggerated into caricature. Contempt breeds familiarity.

Neal Ascherson in the Observer recently developed a similar theory about the appeal of the Mirror and the Sun. These papers are so mindless that they practically caricature themselves - and thus make themselves safe to read, even reassuring, for people who might otherwise tear being manipulated by the media.

There is something of the same business - alongside other, often more important, elements, to be sure - in history's more serious examples of apparent self-denunciation by ruling elites.

Victorian contempt for brummagem industrialism, for example, could both console capitalists who felt superior to the caricature vulgar money-maker, and reassure gullible workers that the traditional aristocracy would keep the new profiteers in line.

The message is this: 'Yes. we know our system is bad. But we're realistic people. We know all systems are bad Ours isn't as bad as all that. In fact it's the least bad of them' Such is the message of the more cynical and devious defenders both of capitalism and of Stalinism. Paul Eddington (centre) as Jim Hacker

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 256

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →