Braudel and "history from below"
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-01-16Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
Philip Il of Spain Fernand historian died late Braudel, the greatest of recent decades, last year aged 83.
His masterpiece, 'The Mediterranean and the Mediterranean World in the Age of Philip II' portrayed the development of a capitalist international economy in the 16th century.
On the face of it the subject matter of the book is conventional enough: the events surrounding the naval battle of Lepanto in 1571 when Spain established itself as the major power in the Mediterranean by defeating Turkey. And indeed the final part of the second volume of "The Mediterranean' chronicles the diplomacy and the personalities, the politicking and the war manoevures.
But the heart of the book is elsewhere. Braudel spells it out in his more recent book 'Civilisation and Capitalism 15th-18th Centuries':
"I navigated mentally through these 50 years [around 1571]...Then I moved on the history of the Mediterranean in the 17th and 18th centuries, thinking that I would feel lost...
*But I quickly discovered that I was on familiar territory...even in 1750. The basic distances, routes, delays, production, merchandise and stopping places — everything or almost everything had same...
• The olive oil of Apulia was, by the 18th century, being exported to northern Europe through Trieste, Ancona, Naples and Ferrara, and much less was going to Venice: this was a significant change, but did it matter their olive groves?', peasants in very much to the Braudel, in contrast to most earlier historians, was centrally concerned with "the peasants in their olive groves"
Thus "The Mediterranean' starts not with the projects of the King of Spain but with the mass of the people — how numerous they were, where they lived, how they lived, what work they did, what they ate...
It moves on to the "distances, routes, delays, production, merchandise and stopping places" It charts the trade routes of the 16th century Mediterranean, and the comings and goings of its busiest centre, Venice. It goes on to build up a picture of the economic paths connecting Spain's new empire in South America — founded in the early years of the 16th century — to metropolitan Spain and thence to the most advanced centres of capitalism, like Antwerp.
It was these economic patterns of the 16th century that generated the basic division of metropolitan centres and Third World still acute today.
In "Civilisation and Capitalism Braudel spells out his approach with a theory of three 'levels' There is 'material civilisation' - 'The Structures of Everyday Life' , as the title to volume 1 of •Civilisation and Capitalism' puts it: the chapter headings are Daily Bread, Food and Drink, Houses, Clothes and Fashion, Sources of Energy, The Spread of Technology, Money, Towns and Cities.
Then there is the market economy'. And rising above that there is 'capitalism' For Braudel 'capitalism' has two distinctive features - centrality and fluidity. It is the multinationals of today, or the merchants of the great trade centres of the late Middle Ages like Venice or Amsterdam.
''The chief privilege of capitalism, today as in the past, remains the ability to choose... — to choose because it is at the centre (the capital) and because it is large-scale liquid wealth.
By no means all market economy is capitalism, in Braudel's view — for many traders have no large central accumulation of wealth. And "capitalism has been potentially visible since the dawn of history..." wherever there is large-scale trading and the use of money.
Braudel's concept of capitalism is thus a bit different from the usual Marxist one, though perhaps not quite as different as it would seem. Braudel also goes on a different tack from Marxists in his emphasis on "structures of long duration" — like the olive groves of the Mediterranean.
One of Braudel's main ideas is that different levels of history have different tempos, and his choise is to focus on the slowchanging levels rather than the day-to-day turbulence of high Yet to see Braudel as an alternative theorist of history is largely to miss the point. His books are like pictures made up of thousands of dots of colour, rather than working blueprints, drawn in stark, clear lines.
'The Mediterranean' was written when Braudel was a prisoner of war in Germany and published in 1949. I find it better than 'Civilisation and Capitalism', written when Braudel was already famous and rather overloaded with passages where the celebrated professor muses, digresses, or scatters subtle allusions and cryptic speculations. • Yet both are eye-openers for anyone taught at school that history is lists of kings and queens and battles and treaties. Both are now available as Fontana paperbacks: "The Mediterranean' in two volumes at £5.95 each, and 'Civilisation and Capitalism' in three volumes at £9.95 each.