Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Builda Fight Against Fowler

Socialist Organiser no. 257, 23 January 1986 · scan p. 2 · about 1,131 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 2 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 2

Stan Crooke reports on the fight against Fowler's Socialist Organiser no. 257. January 23 1986 Page 2 Lal Party ORGANI Under Whose Flag?': class poli tics or bloc 60p plus postage from 214 Sickert Court, London N1 2SY Trotskyists t working-class socialism or Third World nationalism? LIBERTY Under whose flag? Several hundred delegates will be attending the National Campaign Against Socialist Security Cuts (NCASSC) conterence in Manchester this Saturday, 25 January.

Since the establishment of the Fowler Reviews of the social security system, and especially since the publication of the Green Paper based upon those reviews, campaigning up and down the country has involved in different areas to different degrees, claimants' groups, unemployed workers' centres, Labour Party branches, trade unionists (especially in DHSS) and a wide range of welfare rights organisations.

Postponements

Such campaigning forced repeated re-writings repeated postponements of the publication of the White Paper (finally published just before the Christmas holidays in order to neutralise the potential for an immediate response to it).

In certain respects the White Paper differs from the earlier Green Paper. The original -proposal to completely abolish State Earnings Related Pensions (SERPS) has been replaced by proposals to cut the scheme by half by the year 2033. The original proposal to cut back rent and rates rebates as income rises at a common rate has been replaced by two separate 'tapers': now the plan is that for each £1 extra income you lose 60p rent rebate and 20p rate rebate.

A balatantly racist presencetest proposed by the Green Paper has also been dropped from the White Paper.

Significant changes have been made in the timing of the proposed cuts. The major changes are now scheduled for April 1988, as opposed to the original date of April 1987. But replacement of universal maternity grants and death grants by loans will go ahead in 1987, as too will social security cuts changes in maternity allowance.

The extent of the Tories' retreat should not be overestimated, and their ability to recover lost ground should not be underestimated either.

In general, the White Paper is broadly the same as the Green Paper. Supplementary Benefit is to be replaced by Income Support, Family Income Supplement is to be replaced by Family Credit, single payments and additional requirements payments are to be scrapped, a new Social Fund for loans is to be set up, all claimants will have to pay 20% of their rates themselves, etc., etc.

Where the Tories have retreated, it has generally been in response to opposition from their own supporters. Many employers, for example, were opposed to abolition of SERPS. And a single 'taper' for rents and rates would have been a hard blow for many owner-occupier pensioners, in whose ranks are to be tound many of the "Tory poor" -But there is no reason for pessimism about the prospects for future campaigning against the social security cuts. The White Paper claims that the proposed changes will result in two million "winners" and "only" four million "losers" but the real figure for losers' is much higher: 7 million families receiving Child Benefit will see its value cut year by year, and all 20 million workers contributing in to pensions will suffer through changes in SERPS.

Building upon achievements to date, future campaigning will therefore need to draw in support from those millions of losers and organise that support in the form of effective and active opposition to the cuts.

The basis of that opposition is joint campaigning locally | by claimants* organisations and trade union/Labour Party bodies. Given the impact of the cuts on students and the plans for campaigning against the cuts by the National Union of Students, university and college student unions should involve themselves also in such local campaigns, and make their resources and facilities available to them.

Such local campaigns will have a particularly important role to play in the national "take up" campaign planned for the March/July period, with the goal of ensuring that claimants put in claims for all benefits to which they are entitled. Such a campaign would also lead to the DHSS being so overwhelmed by claims that it would be unable to reorganise itself to administer the changed social security system proposed by the White Paper.

Gallant It will also fall to the local campaigns to exploit the May local council elections as a way of building the campaign against Fowler - demanding of council candidates what their attitude is to the proposed cuts and, more importantly, what they, and the organisations they represent, intend doing to fight them.

The Labour Party needs to get its act together in opposition to the proposed cuts. The Labour Campaign Against Social Security Cuts is launching its campaign at the close of January, but this seems • to involve no more than getting each Constituency Labour Party to sign a petition (yes — another petition) against the cuts.

Labour Party branches and CLPs should be involved in local campaigning. Labour controlled district Councils should refuse to retrain their staff for the changes in payment of Housing Benefit (not due for implementation until after the next General Election). And Labour MPs should carry out organised parliamentary disruption instead of engaging in polite debates and point-scoring.

In the unions there is still a need for basic education about the universal impact of the White Paper's proposed cuts. Most people stille them s effecting ed and pensioners — but in fact they will hit everybody in society with the exception of its wealthiest, who will benefit from the tax cuts which the social security cuts are meant to finance.

There is an even bigger need for a more active response from unions with members in the DHSS - the Civil and Public Servants Association and the Society of Civil and Public Servants. Though both have been heavily involved in NCASSC and the "Action for Benefits" campaign, there has not been the consistent campaigning required to make strike action against the cuts a realistic possibility in the immediate future.

Tenants' associations can also play a particularly important role in the campaigning against the cuts by building towards a mass refusal by claimant-tenants to pay the 20% of the rates they are meant to pay out of their own pockets. Tenants' associations should also demand of local authorities that no retaliatory action is taken against tenants who refuse to pay that 20%.

Above all, there is the need for claimants, trade unionists and Labour Party members to get together to draw up alternative proposals for an extended and democratised social security system. Although this has been a constant theme in discussion about the Fowler Reviews, there has been little or no movement towards actually beginning to draw up such an alternative set of proposals.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 257

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →