Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Power and Style Resclute

Socialist Organiser no. 257, 23 January 1986 · scan p. 3 · about 470 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 3

News International's new plant at Wapping, complete with barbed wire fences, security cameras sending trucks out of the plant at picket-busting speeds. Photo: Roger Hutchings, Network.

Mrs Thatcher behaves badly towards her colleagues in the Cabinet. She is not interested in their opinions. She sees the Cabinet as a rubber stamp.

Many people, including many Tories loyal to what Thatcher represents politically, are convinced that these criticisms of Thatcher's style of leadership are true. Beyond Heseltine's revelations, we have historical evidence: Thatcher has ditched

most of those in the Cabinet who have erred from her set course.

But it is not merely a question of style. If it was, then the problem could be solved by getting a new Prime Minister who is nicer to his or her colleauges.

There more serious Elected No one is elected to the position of Prime Minister. The leader of the majority party simply assumes the post — or if there is no majority party then the Queen chooses. Then the Prime Minister has arbitrary powers to select and dismiss the members of the Cabinet.

Tony Benn, "The case for constitutional premiership' argues: "The Prime Minister [has] the power to appoint and dismiss Ministers without any constitutional requirement to get these changes approved by Parliament.. Prime Ministers also appoint permanent secretaries, ambassadors, chiefs of staff, the heads of the security services...This list exludes the Prime Minister's role in choosing...judges...complete personal control of the conduct of government business...A Prime Minister may secure the adherence of the UK to treaties which bind the UK Parliament without any requirement of the formal ratification of Parliament.

In short the Prime Minister has presidential powers without being elected and without the check and balanced that can accompany elected presidents. Thatcher's attitude towards "her' Cabinet is merely a relatively extreme exploitation of an undemocratic structure that exists under all British governments.

It exists under Labour governments too, which should worry us much more.

Neil Kinnock's attitude towards the Labour Party, its activists and its conference decisions, is merely foreshadowing how he intends to act as Prime Minister.

Parliamentary democracy is a very limited form of democracy.

We have no real control over our representatives in between irregular elections, and Parliament has very little control over the Cabinet.

And real power in society resides outside of Parliament. Governments make policy - but and a high speed ramp for in conjunction with and enormously constrained by the bosses and bankers. Day-to-day decisions in the running of the economy are made far away from any form of democratic control.

And the corridors of political power, too, are staffed by huge numbers of unelected people permanent civil servants, chief of police, army top brass.

The labour movement need to set out to replace this present extremely limited democracy with completely new democratic structures.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 257

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →