Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

[THE ELECTRICIANS AND THE TUC As go to…]

Socialist Organiser no. 258, 30 January 1986 · scan p. 2 · about 1,313 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 2 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 2

THE ELECTRICIANS AND THE TUC As go to press the General Council is discussing proposals to si pend the EETPU. Should this right wing union be expelled? Bruce Embers as well as right-wing leaders. Photo; Wendy Mustill. The union-busting operation in the print is not a one-off operation.

It is part of a drive to impose US or Japanese-style "responsible trade unionism" — two or three year legally binding contracts, no-strike clauses, no independent shopfloor organisation — all policed by the trade union officials.

The EETPU has offered itself to employers as the trade union to deal with to get a deal to impose this type of labour relations — not just to Rupert Murdoch and Eddie Shah, but also in particular to US and Japanese firms seeking to set up new plants in Britain. They have other allies in the public sector, such as the UDM, the EMA and small scab unions in the rail and teaching.

The trade union movement must do everything possible to break this development. Expulsion of the EETPU from the TUC is part of this.

The only objection of principle made to this is that it would lead to the creation of a rival union federation to the TUC, thus destroying one of the historic strengths of the British labour movement.

Logic

The whole logic of the EETPU's position points in this direction whether it is expelled from the TUC or decides to make a break at a convenient moment (as would have been the case if the TUC had pressed the issue of state funding for ballots).

The alternative to this split -given the EETPU's total unwillingness to come to a compromise with the TUC - are both unlikely. Firstly, the TUC could allow the EETPU to rampage on with impunity - this would eventually run up against the interests of the other union bureaucrats in maintaining their own organisations. Secondly, the TUC as a whole might move towards the EETPU's view of how to deal with the current weakness of the unions.

This is unlikely given the real conflict of interest in the TUC and from our point of view it would be a major step back= wards.

Now is the time when expulsion of the EETPU can be carried out with maximum posiEETPU's Eric Hammond.

Photo: John Harris.

Organiser no. 258 30 January 1986 Page 2 tive effect and least damage. It would help draw a line between the labour movement as a whole and company unionism. It would allow the TUC and other unions to go on an offensive campaign to win the rank and file of the EETPU. It would do so at a time when the EETPU is isolated from its other potential allies such as the AUEW.

A number of tactical objections have been raised to the EETPU being expelled. Firstly, that it would be an essentially bureaucratic solution to the problem which would allow the TUC leaders to pretend they had done something to assist the print workers and, at the same time would do nothing to break the EETPU rank and file from Hammond.

This would be a valid criticism if expulsion of the EETPU was all we called on the TUC to do to support the print workers.

The TUC must also call for boycott of all papers produced at Wapping and mass picketing. It must use the time given by suspension of the EETPU (as a first step to expulsion) to rally EETPU members opposed to Hammond — the threat of expulsion might make some EETPU members who have hitherto supported the leadership or been passive think again about where Hammond is leading them and rally those already opposed.

The second objection is that expulsion would merely expose the weakness of the TUC and the unions more generally.

As the miners showed, there are times when a battle becomes inevitable even if it is not on the best terrain — a split now would probably be under better conditions than in the future. The whole logic of the situation makes such a split virtually inevitable — Socialist Organiser's current position may otherwise be overtaken by events.

Our demands on the TUC should be:

*Suspension of the EETPU with a short deadline for them to stop work at Wapping.

*Using the period of suspension to try and organise the EETPU rank and file against Hammond.

to win in the print by effective boycotts and mass pickets.

• EETPU includes militant rank and file me ORI In 1972 the TUC was able to suspend 38 unions, including the NGA and the Bakers' Union, for collaboration with the Tory Industrial Relations Act.

Suspending the EETPU now would be different - or certainly expelling it would be different. It would probably launch an alternative TUC into existence.

The EETPU already has links with the UDM and with the mickey-mouse 'no strike' unions in rail and teaching. Maybe not in the short term, but in the medium term, it could hope to pull the EMA (the power engineers' union) and the AUEW out of the TUC with it.

A new right-wing union federation would get huge funds, publicity and patronage from employers, the media and the SDP/Liberal Alliance. The UDM, at present quite isolated apart from its occasional meeting with the EETPU, would get a boost.

The trade union movement is at a low ebb today, after the wholesale destruction of manufacturing jobs in the last six years and the defeat of the miners; and a new right-wing union federation could gain a substantial foothold.

Transfer

The TUC could hit back. Some EETPU members would transfer to TUC unions. But it would not be easy.

In electrical contracting, for example, what would happen? The employers would say that the JIB agreen nent is with the EETPU and the y intend to stick with that. Pro- FUC electricians and file. would face a difficult fight to recognition for a new union.

the main result of a membership war between the TUC and a new right wing federation would be a big increase in non-unionism.

are in a relatively weak state. The EETPU's activities as a maverick right-wing union within the TUC are a serious threat to working class organisation. A new right wing union federation would be a much more serious threat. We are playing with fire. wing union centre is certain to develop anyway (and therefore, so the conclusion runs, best make the inevitable break with the EETPU now).

Hammond says that he does not want to split because the TUC is moving his way. Obviously a shift by the whole TUC to the policies pushed by the EETPU ing a split that gave little comfort to us. But other unions are ments and other sweetheart deals; and expelling the EETPU won't stop that movement. NE We:* but in the low level of working class confidence. And the TUC, within limits, can change that level of confidence. If the TUC organises proper solidarity for the Wapping dispute (and, let's be clear, given the timetables, expulsion of the EETPU can't help the Wapping dispute one bit), then the whole mood in the trade unions can be changed — and the ground can be cut from under Hammond. -That's what we should call on the TUC to do: mobilise to support the print unions. In addition the TUC should go to the ranks of the EETPU, over Hammond's head, and organise the loyal trade unionists — explaining to EETPU members that Hammond is leading them down the road to a split from the TUC. And the TUC should work out a proper concerted strategy for unionising new sites.

Expelling

At the end of such a campaign it might come to expelling the EETPU. But that would be a

----- pull-quotes -----

we go to press the TUC Robinson yes.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 258

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →