No change from Zia A GOO
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-01-30Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 6
Martin Thomas looks at the outcome of the poll On 30 December last year General Zia declared that martial law had been lifted in Pakistan. It was an abject lie.
Since martial law was installed in Pakistan in July 1977 it has sought ways and means of stabilising itself. Every attempt possible was made to bury the workers' and peasants' movement under a hail of bullets. No device of state coercion was left unused in order to subdue the resentment of the Pakistani people.
And yet no amount of oppres sion was sufficient to quell the heroic struggle of the people. The dictatorship of General Zia, representing the interests of the imperialists, the bourgeois, the feudal landlords and the upper strata of the middle classes, became even more desperate to stabilise its rule.
At. first this desperation Ali signified by a number of public declarations by General Zia that the holding of general elections was imminent. Needless to say these promises were never carried out. The dictatorship then sought to supplement its military rule with a civilian face and came up with the ruse of a "National Advisory Council' collection of the most reliable supporters of the Zia regime.
The masses refused to be appeased and continued to struggle against the dictatorship. The dictatorship came up with the even more desperate measure of holding a. referendum to seek approval for Zia's policy of Islamisation.
A low turnout at the polls not only supposedly approved this British soldiers in Aden before The immediate background to the current civil war in the People's Democratic Republic of Yemen (PDRY), or South Yemen, is obscure.
The figureheads in the conflict are Ali Nasser Muhamed, president of the Republic, and rebel leader Abdul Fattah Ismail, a former president who was in exile in the USSR until a year ago.
Nasser is backed by Moscow who consider Abdul Fattah to be a dangerous extremist.
But these two figures represent only different factions in the ruling Yemen Socialist Party formerly known as the National Liberation Front. Abdul Fattah, after his return to Yemen, led a minority faction. In the revolt against the Aden government, Abdul Fattah has enlisted the support of tribal leader Colonel Ali Antar.
So somewhat obscure political conflicts are further confused by the mobilisation of tribal loyalties.
South Yemen is the poorest Arab country. It suffered 129 years of British occupation, culminating in a bloody colonial war from 1963 to 1967. Eventually the British were defeated, and South Yemen won its independence. policy but also elected Zia as President.
Zia then continued to combine the posts of Comander-in-Chief, Chief Martial Law Administrator, and unelected President into one. The sham was not complete. The 1973 constitution was amended beyond recognition by presidential decree and elections for national and provincial assemblies were held.
Banned Of course all political parties were banned, rallies and the right of assembly were denied. Not only that, but the candidates had to be Zia's own approved men.
The national and provincial assemblies proved to be compliant supporters of Zia. One of their first acts was to pass the Clive The capital, Aden, had developed under British rule as a service port, having little contact with the surrounding economy. Its economy was linked into British trade (via Suez), with little productive base.
The economy inherited by the NLF was small and weak, worJune 1967.
The revolt, led by middle class guerrillas, was based on the urban workers in Aden and landless labourers and subsistence farmers in the countryside. It went on to break up the rural ruling class - landowners, including Sultans and tribal chiefs - and the urban ruling class, primarily the commercial bourgeoisie and upper sections of the colonial administration.
The revolution in South Yemen was to prove more thorough and radical than any other in the Arab world. Private 'national' capital, already very weak, was subordinated to the state sector, which was increasingly, planned on the Soviet model.
In Egypt, Syria, or Libya, state-run economies had also been introduced, but under the Indemnity Act, which cleared the army of all the crimes committed in its eight years of rule.
Zia feels now that his hand is sufficiently strong to declare a formal lifting of martial law. But the reality is that all of the institutions of the state and 'elected bodies' are now even more firmly under the control of Zia's stooges than at any time during the last eight years of his rule.
The civil judiciary will continue to be supplemented by special tribunals. Political prisoners will not be released, press freedom will not be resumed and all political activities will be banned until 1984.
However even a formal decTaration of the lifting of martial law will result in an intensification of the class struggle to rid the country of martial law and General Zia. control of the existing army or sections of it. In South Yemen the top state officials were not drawn from the army but from the revolutionary movement.
And the PDRY pursued a radical and uncompromising policy in Arab politics; though with little real influence. Both politically and economically, the Republic drew closer to the USSR over the course of the 1970s.
Social reforms of some significance were introduced. There has been significant secularisation, an improvement in the position of women (in employment, for example), and an attempt to control tribal conflicts.
A crisis in the summer of 1978 lies behind the fighting now. A harder line 'Marxist-Leninist' (i.e. pro-Moscow) faction came to power in the NLF, leading to armed clashes in which the president was killed. Tension between Abdul Fattah and Ali Nasser date back to this period. It is not clear how much analogy there is between the present conflict and the Amin/ Karmal clash in Afghanistan or the Coard/Bishop confrontation in Grenada, where 'more-Stalinist-than-Moscow factions tried tor power on 23 January The by-elections in Northern Ireland last Thursday, 23 January, brought in a good result for the London and Dublin governments.
The Unionists are now openly divided over what to do next. Harold McCusker and Peter Robinson say that they will boycott Westminster; other Unionists like John Taylor say they won't.
The London and Dublin governments are beginning moves to set up the Anglo-Irish joint parliamentary body provided for in last November's Thatcher-Fitzgerald deal. According to the Irish Times, they hope that its first meeting might be "before the end of the The Unionists increased their vote over 1983, not surprisingly considering the intense pressure they put on Protestants to turn out. But the increase was smaller than they hoped. They got 420,000 votes in all, not the half million they aimed for. And they lost a seat in Newry and Armagh, The Irish Times reported: *Traditionally a City Hall (Belfast) count is a welter of Unionist triumphalism. Yesterday was different...(There were) nothing like the numbers usually present for City Hall counts...
London and Dublin were most pleased by the shift from Sinn Fein to the SDLP among Catholic voters. In the four seats which both contested, Sinn Fein's score went down 24% and the SDLP's up 19%.
In Newry and Armagh, won by the SDLP from the Official Unionists, tactical voting may have been part of the shift. But there was just as big a shift in Fermanagh and South Tyrone, where Sinn Fein started well ahead of the SDLP, Evidently Catholics saw the Anglo-Irish deal as proof that constitutional nationalism had at last produced some results. Opinion polls indicate that even some 30% of Sinn Fein supporters back the deal.
The by-elections also showed heightened polarisation between the communities in Northern Ireland. The very middle-class Alliance Party, which represents liberal, non-sectarian Unionism, lost votes to the 'Ulster Savs No' candidates. The Workers' Party with the slogan 'Workers Unite' (and strange neo-Stalinist politics), mostly lost votes except where it was the only opposition to the Unionists.
Sinn Fein has talked more and more in recent years about socialism, and not always insincerely; but its election campaign was on a crude Catholic versus Protestant basis.
Softening its initial denunciation of the Anglo-Irish deal, it produced the slogan 'Keep up the Pressure' - which could not conceivably gain the ear of Protestant workers. And it based much of its campaign against the SDLP on the SDLP's refusal to agree an election pact for "overall nationalist interests"
Such a pact could not have had any principled political basis; it would just mean removing politics entirely from the by-elections and turning them into straight Catholic versus Protestant sectarian headcounts.
For a united Ireland to be possible - let alone democratic or socialist - a movement has to be built which can offer the Protestants guarantees their rights in that united Ireland, and which can at least to some extent win Protestant workers away from Paisley. Sinn Fein is not even trying to do that.
What now? The British government hopes that the Unionists will continue to frag. ment, and some of them will take up the Anglo-Irish deal's offer of Six County home rule on a power-sharing basis. The Unionists hope that their agitation will continue after the election campaign and build up to a crescendo which forces London to abandon the deal.
Long way For certain the Unionist campaign will continue: but it looks as if it will take a long time, or assistance from new events, before it comes near shaking the Westminster government. However, it will also be a long way from the first rifts in Unionist solidarity to any participation in the mechanisms of the Anglo-Irish deal.
The deal, moulded by a typical policeman's or bureaucrat's view of the world, has an inbuilt contradiction. It tells the Catholic minority in the Six Counties that their legitimate• demands can be satisfied only by an arrangement involving the other 26 Counties of Ireland; and thus, whatever the personal intentions of Thatcher, it lays down tracks towards a united Ireland. At the same time it can only increase the chief obstacle to a united Ireland - the Protestants' resis. tance. It can only increase their paranoia about being 'sold out' by London and Washington to Dublin tyranny.
What's needed is not a deal between Thatcher and Fitzgerald but a 'deal' between the different sections of the Irish people, to run their country free of the British military presence which has tortured it for centuries.
----- pull-quotes -----
sened by the effects of war and the closing of the Suez Canal in