[Ly withdrew. First the Greek army had to…]
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-01-30Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
Ly withdrew.
First the Greek army had to be dealt with. In an indication of things to come, Churchill used the conflict between the Royalist and Metaxist officers who were extremely reluctant to fight the Germans in North Africa and the rank and file who were anxious to fight, to isolate the republican officers and break up and disband militant anti-fascist army units.
After two mutinies, a lot of manoeuvring and finally a clear threat to turn British guns on the anti-fascist units of the Greek army, thousands of Greek soldiers, many of whom had escaped from occupied Greece in order to enlist in the fight against Germany, now found themselves in British prison camps in the Middle East. The Metaxist officers and the purged remnants of the army were reorganised into a new Brigade and sent to fight on the Rimini front.
On 8 September, Italy surrendered. In Greece, the Germans and ELAS were locked in a desperate race to be the first to disarm Italian units. Woodhouse was instructed to ensure that ELAS got as little as possible, and proposed that the weapons be shared out between the resistance groups. But ELAS had On 18 April 1944, in an effort to increase its pressure on the bourgeois politicians, EAM established a provisional government - PEEA - in the liberated areas. Because KKE's policy was to build a broad-based movement and to avoid frightening away the bourgeoisie, the resistance struggle had been prevented from taking on a class-struggle character. No KKE propaganda was allowed to circulate in ELAS or EAM and members of the KKE were even instructed to conceal their membership.
Nevertheless Woodhouse himselt gives testimony to the achievements of ELAS in liberated Greece:
"Having acquired control of almost the whole country, except the principal communications used by the Germans, they had given it things it had never known before. Communications in the mountains, by wireless, courier and telephone, have never been so good before or since; even motor roads were mended and used by EAMELAS. Their communications, including wireless, extended as far as Crete and Samos, where guerillas were already in the its provisional government to the verdict of a million Greeks, Churchill was appointing his own Prime Minister for Greece. His choice was George Papandreou - father of the present prime minister of Greece, who was regarded as being on the social-democratic wing of liberal bourgeois republicanism. Papandreou had remained in Athens after the occupation and Sarafis had tried to persuade him to join EAM. But he decided his future lay elsewhere and was lifted by the British and taken to Cairo from where he notified Churchill of his own view of the needs of post-war Greece:
"For the first time in History there is an absolute identification of Greek and British interests...Today, a new antagonism is taking shape. Two world-wide ideologies are being born: PanSlavic Communism and Anglo-Saxon Liberalism...
In the next phase of World History every nation, even our present enemies after Italian Fascism and Hitlerian PanGermanism have been suppressed, will be natural allies of Anglo-Saxon Liberalism in its struggle against Pan-Slavic Communism.Greece and Turkey are destined to be allies of the British, as they are natural opponents of
Scan page 9
Michele Carlisle, who wrote the conference report in Socialist Organiser, replies.
Colin Adkins clearly finds difficulty in understanding the position of Socialist Students in NOLS (SSIN) on South Africa.
"Unlike yours," he writes, "our support for the ANC... is unconditional." Unlike ours? What does he mean?
Colin's understanding of what is meant by 'support for the ANC' is very revealing: he complains that SSIN is "not willing to follow the line of the ANC"
He cannot imagine how we can support anyone while maintaining our own right to think. This is not surprising. As the founder of a Morning Star Supporters Group at Essex University, Colin must be used to accepting a line from above, without thinking, without questions.
Someone like Colin, notorious for the Stalin t-shirts he likes to wear, will have long since given up any attempt to think for himself.
For our part, we are not prepared blindly to "follow line" of anybody, no matter how heroic they are, or how just their cause.
But Colin is being extremely dishonest. He confuses and lumps together a number of different issues. We will have to spell them out.
Implicitly, Colin objects that we have no right to disagree with the ANC - we are living in Britain, mostly white, and should not the ANChow to conduct their own struggle.
Colin can argue this because for him the ANC, and the ANC alone, is "the national liberation movement of the South African Of course, the ANC is the major, and most well-known political force in the liberation movement. But it is not the only one. Unfortunately for Colin Adkins, it is not only SSIN who will not merely "follow the line" of the ANC. There are plenty of people racial trade unions have differences with the ANC over these issues, and others - like the question of workers' control, whether or not to support Solidarnose, and so on.
Most of the trade unions have chosen not to work through the United Democratic Front.
But Colin and his comrades in read with interest your report on the recent NUS Conference and wish to take the opportunity to answer some of the points raised within it.
On the South Africa debate, with the political dishonesty worthy of Socialist Organiser, you sought to claim that Socialist Students in NOLS argued for solidarity with all forces fighting apartheid. In reality, your 'support' saw little role for these forces except under the leadership of the "collective strength black workers.
NOLS contended that this analysis, if put into practice, would narrow the existing struggle.
The duplicity of your support for the ANC is shown by the fact that at YS Summer Camp one of your supporters (our emphasis) would narrow existing struggle"
So Colin objects to what he supposes to be our analysis and counterposes a different analysis. But if SSIN is wrong to have our opinion about South Africa, what gives Colin the right to have an analysis?
In fact, Colin doesn't merely "follow the line" of the ANC because it is virtuous to do so. He agrees with it. And he doesn't agree with those in. South Africa was claiming that the ANC was a thoroughly bourgeois nationalist organisation. Unlike yours, support for the ANC, as the national liberation movement of the South African people is unconditional. The only redeeming fact of your contribution to the debate was Simon Pottinger's honest speech, stating quite clearly that SSIN was not willing to follow the line of the ANC.
Areas
On the Areas debate, SSIN as the main protagonists in deteating our motion, should be ot serious concern for your supporters. Our plan would have contributed in developing all areas, not just those in the metropolitan areas, such as ManANC, UDF, BCM, the independent unions like COSATU. We say: support them whether we agree with everything they say or not.
Colin Adkins and the Democratic Left say: support only those forces who in our opinion have the correct political line. i.e. the line of the ANC.
Steve Biko But what about members of the Black Consciousness Movechester and Tyne Tees areas. This would have assisted NUS in developing its alliances with the trade union movement and Labour local authorities; SSIN's proposal maintained the status quo and effectively turned its back on a developed and professional area's network, capable of running local campaigns, and developing the FE section.
Such a position will have a negative effect on NOLS' ability to secure the youth vote for Labour, all for the political expediency of SSIN maintaining its control over two areas.
In conclusion, the only point I agree with is that SSIN has now become a left opposition in NUS. Whether this position is justified in view of the fact that your candidates can only muster a few votes at the last NOLS consupport or not?
The Democratic Left are criminally sectarian - picking and choosing who to support. SSIN rejects and condemns their posturing Incidentally SSIN does not have a position on whether or not the ANC is "bourgeois nationalist" Most of us, as far as I know, don't think that is an accurate description. Even if it was, we would still support them against Botha, because their cause is one we ference is open to argumen However, this does highligh your contempt for democratic structures of NOLS and reveals your opportunism when you are prepared to ali yourselves with Liberals Euro-Communists to defeat policy positions.
Consensus
NOLS strategy within NUS has shifted the political consensus substantially leftwards. In leftist posturing. A task we will set to with renewed vigour at the Easter conference.
Yours in comradeship.
COLIN ADKINS NOLS National Committee He alleges that we aligned ourselves with Liberals and Eurocommunists to defeat NOLS policy. This is nonsense. SSIN policy on Areas was passed through Durham University last May - five months before anyone else started to discuss it.
Liberals and Eurocommunists later came to agree with us. But that is hardly our fault: we can't speak for them. It was our policy.
What was the issue? The Democratic Left wanted to centralise NUS areas. They say this presented no threat to the autonomy of the areas.
Yet Colin claims our policy was motivated by "the political expediency of SSIN maintaining control over two areas" . That 'control' is represented by the fact that people in Manchester and Tyne Tees Areas support SSIN. In other words, it represents precisely the areas' autonomyChoose If SSIN would "lose control' of two areas, that could only be because those areas had lost their autonomy. In other words, local colleges would no longer control their own areas - they could no longer choose whether or not ta vote for SSIN people.
The Democratic Left's propos als would have given NUS Exec utive control over the allocation of a development fund. Our plan also centres on helping less devel oped areas, by developing poli tical confidence and guaranteeing a level of funding. Bureaucratic juggling is no substitute for that!
And our plan was not only for jibe would have it. Nor was our policy supported only by metropolitan areas: Kent, Sussex Devon and Somerset, North York shire, Stoke and the North West outside of Manchester and Liverpool) also backed it.
And Colin's claim that have harmed "NOLS's ability to secure the youth vote fo Labour" is a bit rich: he organised against our proposal that NUS call for a Labour vote!
We are glad that Colin accepts that we are the left opposition to the Democratic Left in NUS: to the Democratic Left, not to NOLS.
SSIN doesn't run against NOLS. Where we do run we prevent an electoral challenge to NOLS from the left.
And the Democratic Left choose always to leave a full-time post open for the 'Liberals and Eurocommunists. This year, the NUS treasurer is a Liberal. Unless Colin is intending to do away with this time-honoured tradition he should stop carping.
Colin's dark mutterings that he intends to 'expose our left posturing' are frankly amusing The Democratic Left recently turned down the opportunity to debate with SSIN at Sussex University Labour Club, saying "debates are not the priority in the current period' tend toe do tather badly in debates Democratic Left with SSIN, exposing their own lack of ideas rather than us. But
----- pull-quotes -----
KILL MREHEI NOT LANE
turn this has placed new respon- sibilities on us to expose your