How Not to Unite Irish Worker
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-02-06Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
A working class democratic programme is needed to create unity The Workers' Party, Republicans, have th their policies, argues that aim.
Despite being very weak in Northern Ireland, the Workers' Party (WP) is now running neck and neck with the Irish Labour Party in the South.
The WP got 4.8% of the vote nine constituencies where it stood on 23 January, and only 1.6% in the Northern local council elections of May 1985. But in Dublin it already outpolis Labour.
For some on the left the WP merits mention only as an example of sell-out and betrayal of national politics. For others the WP slogan on 23 January - Workers Unite' - will have seemed a valiant voice of sanity. What is the truth?
The WP is a product of the split in the Irish Republican movement of December 1969January 1970. Since then it has changed its name (from Official Sinn Fein) - and its politics.
After the fiasco of its 1956-62 military campaign, the Republican movement turned towards political reassessment. It made something of a "left turn" towards the trade unions, housing campaigns, and small farmer and civil liberties agitation. Less emphasis was placed on the question of "physical force"
Link-up
This turn was considerably influenced by Stalinists. Roy tical education officer and gained a place on the Army Council of the IRA. The idea was also floated of a link-up with the Souther Irish Communist Party Many Republicans resented these political shifts, and the divisions came to a head in 1969.
The "Ireland Today" document of that year proposed dropping the policy of abstention on principle from Irish and British Parliaments. And the IRA was virtually non-existent in the fighting in Belfast and Derry in the summer of 1969.
When the December 1969 IRA convention and the January 1970 previously the Official e slogan Workers Unite'. But Stan Crooke, will not achieve Sinn Fein Ard Fheis (national conference) voted to adopt "Ireland Today" , the movement split with the more 'traditionalist' elements establishing what is now Sinn Fein/IRA.
Early Official Republican (WP) publications stressed that Wolfe Tone's organisation of "United Irishmen" was a "non-sectarian, democratic organisation" which "formulated a theory of Irish nationhood which was based on substituting the common name of Irishmen for Catholic, Protestant and Dissenter" This meant making inroads into the Protestant working class if a united Ireland were to be achieved.
As Cathal Goulding put it in 1971: * There can be no Ireland in Wolfe Tone's sense without the - Protestant working class. They must be reached. We believe we are on the right road."
The Provisionals, on the other hand, were criticised for having broken with the basic tenets of Tone: "They have rejected Tone's concept of Irish nationhood, preferring instead a sort of two-nations theory or even four-nations theory of nationhood. They have rejected the concept of building a new Irish nation through the elimination of sectarian divisions...
*The Provisionals are narrowly sectarian organisation whose concept of nationality cannot go beyond religious categories...Fundamentally a Catholic defence force, the Provisionals are incapable of progressive political thinking and substitute sloganising for political awareness."
The Officials/WP stressed their allegiance to the working class Republicanism of James Connolly.
Despite what they say about the Provisionals' military elitism' the Officials maintained a military campaign against the British Army until May 1972.
In 1974 the Officials split, with many of their more militarilyinclined members, especially in Derry, hiving off to form the Irish Republican Socialist Party (IRSP) and Irish National Liberation Army (INLA). A new and very bloody military campaign by the Officials followed against the IRSP.
Today the WP denies having any military wing, though journalists have speculated that an armed section of some sort still exists secretly.
The IRSP in 1974 was rather to the left of the Officials, and saw itself as more socialist and less militarist than the Provisionals. Today the Provisionals regard the IRSP/INLA as reckless, wild, and short-sighted militarists. The Officiais/WP have evolved in a different direction.
'Legal Marxists'
In Tsarist Russia around the end of the 19th century, there was a whole intellectual and political current known as 'Legal Marxism' . For decades the dominant radical politics in Russia had been populism — its aims an utopian peasant socialism, its method spectacular They liken hunger-striker Bobby Sands to the Nazi pimp Horst Wessel who died in a street brawl, and pledge the WP to "rescue the Irish revolutionary tradition from the bloody grip of fascist and ultraleftist interpretations".
The WP remains Stalinist. At its 1982 national conference, WP General Secretary Sean Garland successfully opposed a resolution in support of Solidarnos on the grounds that martial law was necessary to prevent the country ending up *in the hands of imperialism".
But it criticises the official Irish CP as not being dourly Marxist enough.
'We will make dramatic change in the social order it we exercise vigilance - revolutionary vigilance...Fashionable, trendy issues which divide the working class should be avoided like the plague...
Something like Militant, the WP insists that bread-andbutter working-class issues must be central.
Thus, speaking at the 1980 WP national conference, Sean Garland stressed that it was "imperative that we seize every opportunity, that we seek out every contact, in working class organisations all over the country and start building a broad working class front on common issues.
But its day-to-day policies and practices hardly live up to the rhetoric. The WP's economic policies are no more than lukewarm reformism.
The WP holds rigidly to the Stalinist theory of 'stages' , and insists in doctrinaire fashion that substantial capitalist development in Ireland is a necessary stage before socialism can be achieved - and therefore to be supported.
Vehemently denouncing traditional Irish economic nationalism, the WP hails multinational investment as progressive.
"Any serious study of the Irish economy is...a serious condemnation of Irish private enterprise...They have had every chance to prove themselves and failed time and time again...The general effect of foreign companies has been, on the whole, beneficial to the Irish economy.
"Foreign industry means a progressive industrial base, explicit imperialist control and a vast workforce which in times of crisis is open instantly to the argument for state socialism rather than feudal and reactionary appeals of the "Buy Irish" nature.
In the North, the WP has called for the establishment of an All Party Jobs Forum (where "the different parties could put forward their own proposals in both formal session and in sectoral working groups held over a limited period of one or tw months") and tri-partite planning council involving representation from the government, employers and trade unionists.
This vehement 'realism" guides the WP on other issues.
In the early '80s they provided the crucial votes in the (Southern Irish Parliament needed by the Irish-Tory Fianna Fail to stay in power in the hung Parliament. WP leader Tomas MacGiolla justified this by claiming that "the electorate wanted a government, they gave Fianna Fail a slight edge and put sufficient WP TDs (Irish MPs) in the Dail to keep a clear check on them."
In the trade union movement, the WP became an increasingly conservative influence.
Stages
It still advocates a 32county socialist Republic, but via a tortuous series of 'stages', of which the first is the democratisation of Northern Ireland, within the framework of a divided Ireland.
So for now they are committed to the Six County unit. They advocate a devolved Assembly and a Bill of Rights.
When James Prior, then Northern Ireland secretary of state, launched his plans for a new Northern Irish Assembly in 1982, the WP backed him to the hilt: "Mr Prior must not only receive encouragement but unequivocal support from all those parties who believe in the democratic process."
It supports the London-Dublin agreement but opposes powersharing in the name of" Six County democracy.
According to a WP pamphlet of 1985, lan Paisley's Democratic Unionist Party has "a better grasp of the democratic political needs of Northern Ireland than any of the other parties excluding the WP" ", whilst the Official Unionist Party is praised for "their reasoned opposition to Direct Rule and their commitment to a Bill of Rights"
The WP gives the RUC "only qualified (!) support" and regards it as superior to the only possible alternative: "the policing of West Belfast by the Provos and INLA who are, when analysed, fascist-type organisations.
The WP's political development is significant in many ways.
Irish Republicanism has traditionally defined revolutionary politics by physical-force methods rather than by a social programme. The result, again and again, is that Republican groups who seek more effective tactics than traditional militarism rapidly collapse into abject reformism. In this respect the WP is the latest in a long line of groups which also includes the South's major parties, Fine Gael and Fianna Fail.
The fact that the WP (and, though less so, the Irish Militant) have been the most successful left-wing groups ir. Southern Ireland in recent years is also instructive. The current impasse in the Six Counties is not generating pan-Catholic solidarity but giving strength to politics which represent a hysterical negation of the national struggle.
A working class democratic programme recognising the rights of Ireland's Protestant minority is necessary not only to create Catholic-Protestant workers' unity but even to create NorthSouth unity among Catholic workers.
The WP's commitment to working class unity is not to be condemned: What is to be condemned is that the political logic which it pursues in pursuit of such unity is consistently right wing and accommodationist, which is both bad enough in itself and also of no benefit in achieving working class unity or a socialist society.