Liverpool: a bad charge sheet and a bad reply
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-02-06Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
allegations - Socialist Organiser no.259 6 February 1986 Page 9
Martin
The Labour Party National Executive's inquiry into Liverpool District Labour Party is an outrageously unjust procedure for
several reasons.
In the first place, it is not an inquiry. If it were an inquiry, why suspend the District Labour Party?
It has no precise terms of reference as a proper inquiry should have.
In reality, it is a disciplinary tribunal, only with a back-tofront procedure. First the District Party is found guilty and sentenced to suspension; then the tribunal gets underway, but with no provision for cross-examination of witnesses or open hearings; and the end result, so it seems, will be the formulation of charges and the naming of individual defendants'!
Worse: the bulk of the NEC have already made it clear that they regard 'Militant' as guilty regardless of what evidence comes to the inquiry.
Kinnock has long been committed to a witch-hunt against Militant. Before the Liverpool crisis blew up last autumn, the witch-hunt was slowly and piecemeal Proceeding Liverpool Council's attempt to confront the Tory government angered Kinnock; their bungling of that attempt (the redundancy notices to the council workers, and so on gave him a chance to isolate Militant and hit them when they were down. So Kinnock and his allies set up the inquiry.
Rules
If there are allegations that the District Labour Party breaks party rules, then they should be spelled out and the DLP should have a chance to put its case to an unprejudiced hearing. If there are allegations against individuals, then again elementary justice demands that they be given notice of the charges and a chance to be heard without the case being judged in advance.
None of this, it seems, bothers the Merseyside Labour Coordinating Committee or the two papers, Tribune and Chartist, which have published its evidence to the NEC inquiry.
Very restrained and reasonable in tone, the submission points the way to expulsions without actually daring to argue for them. It's rather like a pacifist handing over a loaded gun to an executioner while declaring that he abhors all violence but the person in the firing line has not behaved quite as they should.
The submission has three sections: District Labour Party democracy, selection of councillors and allegations of intimidation and corruption by Militant supporters. The first two sections end with lists of proposals - proposals which can be debated one way or another, but in any case are relevant to the complaints made.
The third (and more explosive) section carries no such proposals. Instead it ends as follows:
...Any measures undertaken by the NEC must be capable of gaining the consent of non-Militant members.. At the moment large scale expulsions fail to meet that criteria. However we recognise the right of the NECto take action against individuals on the basis of breaches of the party constitution and rules..." (emphasis added).
Wrong
So "large scale" expulsions would be wrong "at the moment" - not because they are unjust, but because local Labour Party members would resent them! By implication "small scale" expulsions are all right now, and "large scale" expulsions will be all right later, when the party has been softened up sufficientiy individuals"" who should be acted against "on the basis of breaches of the party...rules"? If the LCC thinks there is a case for expelling particular individuals, then why does it not name them and spell out the charges? If not, then they should shut up. LIVERPOOL unity is The sliminess of the LCC, however, is unfortunately not the end of the story. Militant's 4-page reply to the LCC in its issue of 31 January will have dismayed many left wingers in the Labour Party. And we have a right to complain: for the witchhunt is already hitting many left-wingers besides Militant, and an inept self-defence by Militant Will endanger many more of us on the left of the party.
A large part of Militant's reply is a denunciation of the LCC's miserable line on Labour local authorities' fight against the Tory government.
(The LCC now call the left Labour councils' concerted defiance in spring 1985 a "lemming syndrome"!)
That the LCC are fake-lefts and hypocrites besides, however, doesn't prove that everything they say is untrue. Not everything that social-democrats (or Tories, for that matter) say against Stalinism is untrue. A lot of what assorted witch-hunters and right-wingers had been
saying for years WRP has recently to be true.
Labour activists know this. And if the left is to defend itself
against the born-again-Kinnockite witch-hunters, we'll need to do more than denounce their general politics. We'll need to convince middle-of-the-road Labour" members on specific Militant scarcely even tries to do this. It does answer some specific charges quite well, but on the whole it simply denounces middle-of-the-road opinion rather than seeking to convince.
Indeed, Militant's general response to the witch-hunt has not been to seek any broad front in defence of democratic rights, but simply to stage their own rallies and fund-raising. They evidently believe that they are so strong that the witch-hunt cannot hurt them.
This attitude should cause concern to many rank-and-file Militant supporters. If Militant's editors respond to the accusations about Liverpool with nothing more than ballyhoo and bluster, then many Labour activists with no 'crime" beyond sympathy for Militant's ideas risk guilt by association.
'Perspective'
They should reflect. Militant can appear each week only thanks to the self-sacrifice and dedication of its sellers. It should therefore give them a fair chance to express their views in its pages when they disagree with the editors. Does it? Or do the editors have the attitude that the 'correct Marxist perspective' was laid down many years ago main role is to stress how well reality is matching up to that perspective?
Now the running of the paper is a private matter between the editors and the sellers. But what happens when the same top-down approach is applied to the running of a District Labour Party?
Labour MPs and parliamentary candidates who support Militant, like Dave Nellist, Terry Fields, and Pat Wall, take pride in their slogan 'A workers' MP on a workers' wage'. What do they think of Derek Hatton's Flash Harry act (on £20,000 a year according to Hatton's own figures) which has given so much grist to the right-wing mills? Why don't they insist that Militant's editors either get Hatton to sue the 'World In Action' TV programme, which made detailed allegations against him, or dissociate themselves from Hatton?
The whole of the left fought against the expulsion of Militant's editors from the Labour Party. To this day Ted Grant and Peter Taaffe still carry party membership cards issued to them by Islington South CLP in defiance of the official witchhunt decision.
Now a new witch-hunt threatens both rank-and-file Militant supporters and other left-wingers. We have a right to demand that Militant co-operates with the rest of the left, deals straightforwardly with any genuine allegations, and puts its own house in order. HOW THE DISTRICT LABOUR PARTY WORKS The LCC says that the District Labour Party is swamped by trade union delegates who are not very accountable to their branches; that the DLP delegates are often effectively by-passed by the DLP executive or officers on the one hand, or DLP aggregates which are more like rallies on the other; that the DLP runs activities and campaigns which are properly the province of constituencies and wards; and that there is no list of DLP delegates available for checkMilitant replies that there is a list available for checking at all meetings. There are aggregates, but decisive votes are by DLP delegates' credentials. The DLP's wide range of trade union delegates and of activities has been essential for the sort of campaign that Liverpool has run.
The LCC does not make any precise allegation that the DLP has broken party rules.
The case that does stand to be answered, however, is that Militant has run the DLP using many of the standard methods of the Labour Party right wing. SELECTION OF COUNCILLORS People nominated as Labour council candidates have to be approved for the 'panel' before their names can go forward for ¡election contests in the wards. This is standard procedure throughout the Labour Party. Usually approval is automatic unless candidates have some ipecial blot on their records.
The LCC says that in Liver›ool Militant's control of the DLP s used to exclude political opponints from the panel. It names five ases.
Militant could make a strong eply to the LCC by basing themelves on the need for the DLP, ince having democratically lecided to confront the Tory overnment, to make sure its olicy was carried out.
There would be nothing demoratic about a right-wing minority of Labour councillors basing hemselves on 'accountability' to ight wing wards in order to hwart the Liverpool Labour arty line of no cuts and no rent ises or big rate rises. The LCC learly wants to make the council abour group independent from he DLP (as most council Labour roups are).
However, Militant do not reply that way. On the excluded B a man my bat hand ases are way back" and very few people remember the rcumstances": the other two ere excluded "not for ideologicI reasons" but because they were ot "strong candidates"
AMMANY HALL POLITICS he LCC's general case is that ontrol of the council machine as been used to reward supporTS of Militant and penalise pponents.
*According to the LCC, the eputy chair of the council eduition council appoints sabbatical fficers for student unions in iverpool's Further Education elleges. "None has ever been ected by any student body... ley are in effect full-time organers for Militant paid for on the tes." Militant flatly denies this. They were • elected by the urther Education Federation, hich comprises delegates directelected by all students from each student union .
*The LCC says that the council security force set up si ince 1983 "gives rise to genuine f ears of a private 'army' some of wh Close members appear to be appoir ited on the basis of political or so icial patronage". It offers, however, detailed or precise allegations.
*The LCC says that some 1 garcolony' after working throug deners were moved to a le iper council Day of Action in 19 84.
Militant says that the were moved because other tr lers were moved because outer trade ade unionists refused to work rith them, and thatthe cause of it was the gardeners scabbing on a str ike against the previous Libe eral administration in 1983.
*The LCC says that lead council trade unionists who ‹ threatened with vitamia tir agree with Militant have The allegations on this SCC however, are vague.
*The LCC makes two alle gations of physical attacks. Militi ant replies that in one case the atta ick was by "a passer-by who had connection whatsoever with.
Militant"; in the other it v "six of one and half-a-dozen the other"; the case. come court and both people WI bound over.
*The LCC makes more gene allegations about abuse, thre and the presence of the coun security force at DLP meetin Militant replies that "heckling a barracking has been no grea than ... in other meetings of t labour and trade union mo ment."
For sure the LCC does make any allegations specific a and serious enough to warrant NI disciplinary action. Many left-wingers in Liverpool do find th DLP meetings are run in a w better calculated to rally Mi tant's ranks on a football-f basis than to allow calm debat But a 'cure' by NEC interventil could be worse than the diseasel 'A PARTY WITHIN A PARTY" The LCC concludes by chargi! that Militant has an organisi political machine, 'a party with a party' Piously it protests that contrast "Neither Merseyside LC nor any genuine pressure group the party exercise political disc pline over its own membership"
Oh yes? In the Labour studel organisation, the LCC's co-thin ers, the 'Democratic Left', ope ate a Stalinist discipline and level of bureaucratic manipulatio that puts all the LCC's allegatiot about Liverpool in the shade.
In any tense political confli within the Lahour Party caba and caucuses are formed. Th right wing onces are often funde from outside (NATO, for exampl funds a pro-NATO group). To ba organised factions means, effect, to allow only one factio - the established leadership.
It might be better if the statu of organised factions in th Labour Party were rationalised for example by returning to th system under which the Britis! Socialist Party (forerunner of th Communist Party) and the Inde pendent Labour Party wer explicitly recognised as affiliater 'parties within the party.
But for sure, if Militant can bi witch-hunted for having somi organisation, then every local lef caucus in the country is potential ly at risk. So is the LCC, if ever i falls out with Neil Kinnock!
Scan page 10
Review