Tragedy in space
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-02-06Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
Les The shuttle tragedy was a moving and poignant one for many people, particularly the American public, whose children had been extensively acquainted with Christa McAuliffe, the civilian teacher on the mission.
Despite the fact that many astronauts become right-wing American Dreamers or born-again cretins, and that the Space Programme is mortgaged up to the hilt to the US Department of Defense, many saw Challenger as a symbol of some of the better human aspirations.
The idea of the space shuttle is an elegant one. Instead of expensive equipment being used once and lost, a spacecraft with wings is sent into space by powerful rockets, does its work of scientific experiments, launching satellites, etc., and then descends to Earth like a rather fast glider.
The programme was dogged from the start by cash shortages and in order to attract Pentagon money the original design nad to be modified to allow for putting heavy military payloads into orbit. This led to the need to adapt the propulsion system to carry the extra weight, adding to the time and expense of development already affected by such embarrassing problems as the heat-resistant tiles that kept falling off.
Challenger was larger version of the basic shuttle particularly dedicated to military needs and thus required an even bigger propulsion unit. In the new design, the engines were hotter, necessitating a bigger heat-shield which caused heavier vibrations which damaged the fuel lines and SO on. All three engines (two solidfuel boosters and the main hydrogen-oxygen rocket) were eventually replaced before its first flight.
It had actually never been intended to fly, being planned solely as an Earth-based testbed for future models.
On its first flight, Challenger came within a second of disaster. The solid-fuel boosters were found to have almost burnt through their casing, something which could have sent it out of control.
Mechanical problems dogged other fights, with one mission curtailed after one engine automatically shut down for safety reasons soon after take off.
No-one knows yet what caused the destruction of Challenger, though film released last weekend shows a growing spout of flame from the side of a booster. Why this did not trigger a shut-down of the boosters and an automatic ditching of the main propulsion unit will presumably be discovered.
No safety mechanisms did quent blast, described as having intervene to prevent the subseforce of small nuclear explosion. This happened as the tain fuel tanks were disrupted. releasing the stores of liquid drogen and oxygen. The ensucataciesm hard pressed as it is by alling CUSES. budget cutacks, military pressure and mercial competition from e European rocket, Ariane.
All missions are suspended, ing such military projects as launch of a military reconSocialist Organiser no.259
Science
naisance satellite in September (the US only has one up at the moment and feels somewhat vulnerable as a result) and the launch of an infra-red detector for tracking bombers and cruise missiles. This sort of detector will be essential for the Strategic Defence Initiative (star wars).
Peaceful projects affected include the Hubble space telescope and space-craft to visit Jupiter and to survey the polar regions of the Sun.
The disaster has made space scientists look at some of the alternatives to the American space shuttle. Already, there are moves to go back to once-only rockets to launch satellites and there is questioning about whether humans even need to go into space, with the current state of development of remotecontrolled technology.
The way that civilian Christa McAuliffe was allowed onto Challenger can only fuel such questions. It was one of Ronnie Raygun's bright ideas to send a teacher up. It was seized on by a desperate NASA, worried about future funding as mission after mission was delayed by last second computer glitches and adverse weather.
Mini-shuttle
The size of the shuttle appears to be a major problem which could be answered by the European mini-shuttle, Hermes. This 1S a seit-powered, re-usable space vehicle, designed only for those activities requiring human presence. Satellites, etc., would be launched separately.
Hermes could provide a platform for long experiments, ferry crews to orbiting space stations and give access to satellites up to 1300 kms high.
Other possibilities include the European HOTOL (Horizontal Take-off and Landing Plane) and the US hypersonic space plane, both of which use conventional wings and jets to get quite high before rocket motors take over. The massive motors and fuel tanks of the Shuttle would be obsolete.
The possibilities of the space shuttle are manifold. As socialists, we are naturally sympathetic to anything whose purpose is exploration, understanding and peaceful scientific research. Those who saw the shuttle as a part of this process have seen that process subvered by military interests and sacrificed to the prestige of the United States (and its presienquir may also STADIEE thatt nauts" safety was that altar.
Socialists should use this tragedy to expose and combat the military and commercial distortion of science, not to argue Ludd-fasion against space exploration.