Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Pain, suffering, filth and more pain

Socialist Organiser no. 259, 6 February 1986 · scan p. 10 · Edward Ellis · about 614 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

RE VO LUTI N "REVOLUTION' has been universally panned by the critics. Many have foretold the collapse of Goldcrest Films as a result of it. But if you go to see it expecting scene after scene of ecstatic awfulness, you will be disappointed It really isn't as bad as all that. It's not good, mind you, but I've seen worse.

It is the story of ordinary folk who get caught up in the American War of Independence. Tom Dobb (Al Pacino) is a likeable Dad who gets drawn very reluctantly into fighting the Brits by his more eager son Ned.

Meanwhile Nastassja Kinski plays an aristocratic American The war that won a nation its freedom, a woman her destiny, a young man his independence, and a father his son's love. Edward Ellis reviews the film 'Revolution' who chooses to abandon high society for the revolution, where she finds (albeit very occasionally) Pacino. They are destined to be together.

The Revolution, it has to be said, is a pretty unpleasant affair. There are a lot of loud banging noises, screams, extras falling into the mud, and patients having their legs hacked off without an anaesthetic. Pain, suffering, filth, and more pain - that's this revolutionary war.

The plot is not exactly the most plausible ever written, and PACINO An Epic Adven places the critics undeniably corny.

Pacino tries to keep himself and his son out of trouble. Son Ned starts to resent his Dad, suspecting him of cowardice. Ned is kidnapped. Dad has to go and rescue him and prove that he's brave after all. The reconciliation scene is one of the great moments of big screen cringe.

Further, there is a certain degree of overkill in having more than one joyful reunion between Pacino and Kinski. We start to feel that we've seen this bit before somewhere.

But amidst all this rubbish, 'Revolution' has its charms.

PG The Brits are all unspeakable baddies — upper class twits and sadists. One can't help but wonder if part of the motivation behind the critical hostility is that the English don't like being portrayed in such a poor light.

It does make for somewhat two-dimensional characters. But I suspect that Brit colonials probably were mostly twodimensional fatheads. You don't get to build an empire on which the sun never sets by personal depth and subtlety, after all.

The British authorities in the New World probably were malicious, vicious tyrants: so why not make fun of them?

Donald Sutherland is a particularly nasty Colonel Blimp figure with a very odd accent (like a cross between Irish and South Yorkshire - but I rather enjoyed all the odd accents in the film. For certain 18thcentury New York must have been different from 20th-century Bronx).

Responsible for the savage treatment of Ned, Sutherland of course gets his come-uppance before the revolution is through. Equally in line with cliché, Ned can't just cold-bloodedly kill him.

What does the revolution bring? Freedom, equality... But Pacino loses his boat and his promised plot of land; and he warns the new post-revolutionary authorities that ordinary folk like him haven't fought just for a new set of tyrants to replace the old.

A black man complains that he wants freedom too.

But this half-hearted political message is lost in the climax of the Kinski-Pacino sub-plot. Pacino finds her (yet again) amidst the crowd. And we are left still not quite sure why their destinies are so inextricably bound together when over several years they have only exchanged a handful of words.

Perhaps Kinski is symbolic of the elusiveness of freedom? Who cares. That's Hollywood.

Except in the old days they made them to last.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 259

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →