[Socialist t Organiser no. 260. 13 February 1986…]
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-02-13Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
Socialist t Organiser no. 260. 13 February 1986 Page 8 anguage shows, in effect, that this is the case. When you ask yourself why the national and local trade union leaders were ]ble to undermine Liverpoo] Council's support among the manual trades, you have noenere shown how a crucial role in this has been played by the Communist Party and its fellow travellers, who in addition provided the structure for the fake "Labour Left that was organised to attack them in the Labour Party, The accusations -of "semigangsterism politics' , and the further to •cosa nostras, references 'much of the wrongs of the Braddock era show that this language is not accidental.
The picture does not improve when we turn to your 'agenda' when you call for the removal of two of the main targets of the Japitalist media - Derek Hatton and Sam Bond. Nor can the responsibility for the use of this language rest with your contributor alone. The Editorial repeats accusations that Militant 'runs Liverpool as though the tendency were a criminai brotherhood and Liverpool 1920s Chicago.
Whatever the resuits of Kinnock's enquiry, it is plain that these comrades have already been tried and found guilty in your eyes. At a time when the canitalist press - the sole foundation for these accusations - is whipping up an atmosphere of witch-hunt to near hysteria, these remarks can inly add up to gross irresponsibdity on your part, as well as a sectarian animosity that well oversteps the mark of legitimate polemic, Your similiar behaviour at the tume of the adoption of Mildred Gordon as parliamentary candidate for lan Mikardo's old constituency shows that this sort of hing is fast becoming a habit. Fingering your political opponents whilst they are under attack in the vellow press is not, we submit, a becuming activity for socialists and we urge you to Hatton: defended What is the truth of the matter? Has Militant's policy in Liverpool been scandalously bureaucratic or hasn't it?
Comrades Richardson and Bornstein do not address this question. Yet it cannot be washed away by floods of rhetoric about the vileness of Neil Kinnock or of the Communist Party.
Socialist Organiser has argued consistently that the appointment of Sam Bond was a clumsy piece of arrogance, that Derek Hatton's Flash Harry performance is at the very least counterproductive, and that Militant's 'machine politics" in the Liverpool campaign seriously undermined mass mobilisation.
Either we were wrong or we were right.
The truth cannot be made the first casualty of a war against the witch-hunt. In fact, telling lies about how good Militant's record is in Liverpool is counter-productive even in terms of fighting the witchhunt. It won't convince anyone.
Either we expressed ourselves badly, or the comrades have not read the paper very attentively, but for sure their quote from our editorial misrepresents its drift.
The editorial started by stating 'the case for the prosecution' in order then to show where it falls down. It's a common method of argument - and a better one than the method of ex-cathedra declamations, used by some left groups apparently more to impress themselves with their own r-r-revolutionary fervour than to convince anyone.
We're not even sure what the comrades are talking about in relation to Mildred Gordon. We welcomed Mildred Gordon's selection; we've made no criticisms of her like those we have made of Militant; and in any case she is not being witch-hunted