Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Solidarnosc and economic policy

Socialist Organiser no. 260, 13 February 1986 · scan p. 8 · about 961 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

is not o was with sume amazement -and not a little shock — that we pened our copy of Socialist Dreaniser dated 5 December to find an article by Bas Hardy, 'Liverpool: The Truth" , which under a pretence of support in effect aided and abetted the witch-hunt against the Liverpool Council whipped up by the capitalist press and now under prosecution by Kinnock and his -fficials.

A careful examination of the draw back from it before it produces consequences for which we feel sure that you would be ashamed.

As one of the writers of this letter was defamed in a book plugging the Braddocks, we feel that we have a right to write to you in this way!

Fraternally.

AL RICHARDSON, SAM BORNSTEIN London Solidarnosc's underground leadership now calls for a market economy. Martin comments.

'Pro-imperialist, Catholic, right wing - they want to restore capitalism'. That was how many left-wingers in the West saw the Polish workers' movement Solidarnose when it flowered in 1980-1.

A new economic programme issued by Solidarnose's underground leadership (the TKK) seems to prove them right. The programme, issued in September 1985 and translated in the bulletin 'Voice of Solidarity, calls for central planning to be abolished and market mechanisms to be made supreme.

In 1980-1, when Solidarnose was in the ascendant, its central theme was workers' control; but now, battered, repressed and hunted, Solidarnose's underground leaders have turned to market economics as a 'realistic" (their term) alternative to bureaucratic mismanagement.

It is not clear how representative the TKK document of thinking in the ranks of Solidarnosc. With the movement forced underground, obviously there is little chance of open discussion.

Certainly some left-wingers in Solidarnosc are clearly opposed to the market-economy policy. In a document which we published in Socialist Organiser of 9 January, the Workers Opposition stated that "The aim of the revolutionary workers' movement. is not the reprivatisation of state property or giving it autonomy but to genuinely socialise But the TKK must rep sent some large body of opinion in Solidarnosc. And that is not surprising.

Many workers in the West, rebelling against the chaos and crueity of the market economy, take the Stalinist states of the East as a model for a, new societv. For workers in Poland. 'nationalised property' and "planning' mean bullying and byzantine mismanagement by the bureaucracy. So the grass looks greener on the other side. They see a Western model as a 'realistic' alternative.

There were always people in Solidarnose favouring a market economy. Their influence is specially strong now, when repression has crushed workers confidence in their ability to win their own alternative of workers control.

So mavbe Solidarnose, or a central section of it, is now advocating the restoration of a capitalist market economy in Poland.

Does that mean that the Western left should support JaruzelStalinist police in Poland class against the workers' movement. Likewise in Poland we should defend Solidarnosc even under pro-Western leadership.

To do otherwise would be to cut the ground from under the feet of Solidarnose left-wingers. For what conclusions are Polish workers likely to come to if they see socialists in the West (even those who say they oppose Stalinism) siding with Jaruzelski in the name of 'nationalised property, while apparently their most vocai support is from Reagan and Thatcher?

From a socialist point of view the Solidarnosc leaders.' new economic programme is utterly contradictory. They advocate that competition should rule: but that would also mean competition between workers, and the break-up of the class solidarity which is the name and banner of their movement.

They advocate that unprotitable enterprises should go bust and profitable ones should keep their gains. They must know that this would create mass unemployment. Would Solidarnose really hail long dole queues. as a victory for economic effic¡ency?

In relation to wages they contradict •their own general approach, arguing:

**Family income should not be allowed to fall below a socially acceptable minimum. We demand the discontinuation of the deliberate policy of depriving the real value of social benes We demand the introduction of indexation and payment of cost-of-living allowances. In this way, a socially acceptable minimum wage, linked to the rate of inflation, would be introduced. We do not agree to the present system of leaving pay compensation to be bargained out industry by industry, a system which favours the strong.

The general rule of letting the market decide would dictate no minimum wage, and bargaining not only industry by industry but job by job. But on this issue, so immediate for workers. the Solidarnosc leaders step back and favour the principle of solidarity rather than the law of the market.

They seem to envisage most enterprises being run as worker cooperatives.

*The effectiveness of any enterprise depends largely on having an enterprising management who bear responsibility for the enterprise's activity and exercise controi over profits. At present in the state sector of the economy, this role could be played only by Employees Coun cils.

Market principles would then mean each group of workers competing ruthlessly against every other. Here again the Solldarnosc leaders recoil.

*In order to strengthen their bargaining position vis-a-vis the central bureaucracy, Employees Councils should be able to torm inter-factory consultative struc tures.

A good demand within an economic programme based on solidarity: but what sense can this make if the market is to rule? The only use that Employees Councils would have for the "consultative structures" under that system would be to cheat and gouge each other and to form cartels.

Unequivocal and unconditional support by Western workers for the rights of Solidarnosc is the best way to help the Polish workers sort out these contradictions and find their way back to a programme based on solidarity and workers" control.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 260

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →