Socialism on Sunday
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-02-13Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
Jim Denham reports on Neil Kinnock's "LABOUR'S electoral prospects are brighter than tor many months" , Brian Walden former Labour MP for Birmingham All Saints, sagely informed viewers of last Sunday's Weekend World The government has recently suffered a series of body blows - the Westland fiasco, the BL U-turn, and the sharp rise in unemplovment have all set the government reeling (or 'wheeling' even). But Labour is not home and dry.
Is the Party still committed to traditional socialism' or can it improve its image to appeal to the new middle class who, as we all know, now hold the key to electoral success?
One man above all others, should know the answers to all these questions. Guess who he is.
Well, there is a familiarlooking figure sitting facing the Bauhaus chair at the other end of the studio. Yes folks, no-one is better placed to provide the answers than Neil Kinnock!
Just think, some people are foolish enough not to watch television at 12 noon on Sundays. They do other things, like stay in bed head off to the pub.
However, they'd learn a lot from watching Weekend World. Already I've learned that the government has been having a rough time lately, Labour doesn't know where it's going, white collar workers are important, and Neil Kinnock is leader of the Labour Party, During the commercial break, Neil had presumably pulled his chair up to where Brian was sitting and the show got down to business eyeball to eyeball. Brian said he wasn't going to ask Neil about issues like Militant, Wapping, Westland, or details of Labour policy.
No. Weekend World viewers are interested in much more profound questions. What sort of government does Neil want to form? What sort or an arithmetic parity can imposed.
"Equality of opportunity does not necessarily mean equality of outcome. These ideas - ideas of fairness, efficiency and decency need not contradict the principle of individual treedom.
"In fact they enhance that principle and can make it a reality for many people who do not presently enjoy real individual freedom"
Brian obviously liked what he heard. "You're vewy, vewy clear on that: you didn't list equality of outcome. Your society would still allow a great deal of diversity"
Neil answered yes.
Just in case anyone should think Brian was giving Neil an easy ride so tar, he suddenly demonstrated that the cosy chatter until now had just been a ruse to lull our Leader into a false sense of security.
Without warning Brian launched into a bold and altogether unexpected line of attack. "So, Neil, you no longer stand by that old communist , Slogan: For each according to his, er..
Neil came to Brian's rescue. "You mean *From each according to his ability, to each according to his needs"? Actually, that's not a bad rough guide and there are people in the Conservative Party who'd agree with that. It just means fairness"
Brian was by now ecstatic. "We're getting on swimmingly. We've cleared up lots of doubts viewers have!"
But here the discussion really got down to the nitty gritty and covered all sorts of previously uncharted terrain.
Contradiction
Brian asked Neil if there was a contradiction between an emphasis on production and 'old-fashioned socialist values which emphasise redistribution.
Neil insisted that there need be no contradiction. Labour favoured improved technology and more investment. It could even learn a thing or two from the Japanese. We must rebuild our productive base and redistribution of wealth can play a supportive role in this.
"Followed by income tax"? asked Brian, with just a hint of deep personal concern.
Neil assured him that only the top 5% income bracket had anything to fear on this score. And they are all so rich that they won't notice a bit of extra taxation anyway. Certainly people like Brian would be OK.
Brian had one last remaining worry. "Some people might say: We know Kinnock. He's a left-wing socialist. This is all vewy weasonable, but once he's in power he'll change his tune. What ismil get is wed ware socialorganiser no 260- 15 February 1956 Pace Kinnock: 'Equality? No, just a "Then they'd be daft", replied Neil. "They should take more water with it"
Brian seemed satisfied with this. And I was certainly convinced, Brian showed he knows a bit about history by talking about certain similarities between Neil and Franklin Roosevelt. Our Leader looked well pleased with the comparision. "But Franklin D was no socialist", objected Brian.
"Yes, but the basic common sense of what he said and his basic values would be shared by socialists. Agreeing to a New Deal is only part of it. What makes democratic socialism distinctive is....
Wegwettable
«Wegwettably, Mr Kinnock I must stop you there" , said Brian, and he looked as though he did regret it. The two of them could have chatted away all afternoon quite happily. Brian might even have been persuaded to rejoin the Labour Party and play a real part in implementing Neil's New Deal. ¡ fair chance in the market place. great thinkers of our time discussing such profound issues. Thank God they didn't discuss Militant, Wapping, or even Westland. And they didn't get bogged down in too much detail about how unemployment would be dealt with, or whether or not privatised services would be renationalised, or whether a deal would be done with the Alliance, or what socialism is.
Our old Leon might have said, 'Between the minimum and the maximum programme no bridge existed. And indeed social democracy has no need of such a bridge since the word socialism is only used for holiday speechifying'.
I think next Sunday TIl stay in bed, or go down the pub. Happily Weekend World finishes at 1pm, so there was still time to get there and ponder the significance of what I had just heard.
How I pitied the poor ignorant rabble who had nob bothered to stay in and listen to Brian and Neil.
----- pull-quotes -----
and Brian Walden's effort to keep Sunday special