A Family Affair
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-02-20Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 6
The following story went the rounds of the nomenklatura (the USSR elite) in the '70s.
One day the mother of a Central Committee official, who lived in a collective farm, came to visit him. She was shown his luxurious Moscow apartment and his dacha and was given excellent kremliovka meals. Unexpectedly she wanted to go home as quickly as possible.
"What's the matter, Mother?" her son asked. "It's lovely here; why don't you want to stay?"
"Yes, it's certainly lovely here", the old woman replied, "but it's dangerous. Suppose the reds come?"
Michael Voslensky, 'Nomenklatura: Anatomy of the Soviet ruling class' Red Army into a strategic buffer-zone between capitalist Western Europe and the Soviet Union. In practice, this meant maintaining capitalist structures in those countries while at the same time ensuring USSR domination of social and political life.
The FDGB was the tusing into a single organisation of the revived organisations of the different trade union formations (Social Democratic, Communist, Christian and Liberal) which had existed prior to Hitler.
The stated goals of the FDGB •were anything but revolutionary. It pursued collective bargaining and system of social insurance, welfare and protective legislation. Above all, it was committed to rebuilding the enterprises destroyed by the war and participating "economic reconstruction" - on a capitalist basis.
Works councils had been set up spontaneously by workers in the closing days of the war. They were centres of resistance to both capitalism and Stalinist encroachment. Elections to
Scan page 7
the working class ITTING REAL 'ADE UNIONS German workers rose in revolt in such councils were banned in the East in 1947. The councils themselves were banned the following year (they had been suppressed immediately in the West) - and replaced by trade union committees staffed by compliant members of the FDGB.
Propping up capitalism on the one side, the FDGB provided assistance to Stalinism on the other. Key positions in the FDGB were in the hands of members of the old Moscow-loyal German Communist Party (KPD).
Fusion
The fusion of the preHitler trade union formations into a single centralised union also paved the way for the fusion of the KPD and the Social Democratic Party (German equivalent of the Labour Party, not the SP).
Although Stalinist pressure played a large part in this fusion, many workers naively welcomed it as a step to stronger and more united workers' organisation. They would be tragically disappointed. East Berlin in 1953 The FDGB was heavily under the control of the Stalinists who, through the USSR army, were the effective state power.
It permitted the dismantiing and shipping off to the USSR of substantial sections of German industry as "reparations" . This especially hit factories taken over by workers at the time of the collapse of fascism and now being run by the workers themselves.
Stalin changed policy in 1947. His aLECITIOLO to appease imperialism by leaving- capitalism intact in the Soviet-occupied region were, by this time, clearly unsuccessful. The writing was on the wall and it spelt 'Cold War' , though there was always the danger that it might hot up.
Structures
The capitalist structures of Eastern European countries were abolished and replaced by those which characterise the Soviet union. The governments of coalition with bourgeois parties were dissolved and replaced by one-party stalinist regimes. All forms and degrees of independent organisation, however limited, were crushed.
Role
What of the FDGB? The statutes adopted at its third congress, in 1950, capressly acknowledged the leading role of the SED (German Communist Party) and thereby also acknowledged that its own role was to be no more than a transmission belt carrying the decisions of the SED into the workforce.
There are elections, after a fashion, in the FDGB, but there is no democracy. The ballot paper in workplace and district electíons is a list of names drawn up by the current office-bearers in conjunction with the union officials one step up in the bureaucracy above them and with the local SED leadership. Putting forward an alternative rank and file slate of candidates is impossible.
And the nominal right of removal of union functionaries who breach union statutes or no longer enjoy the confidence of their members" is in practice non-existent. Any dismissal of officials from office takes place as a result of decisions by the layer of the bureaucracy above them, sanctioned after the event by the appropriate union body.
After bowing down before the "vanguard role"' of the SED, the statutes of the 1950 Congress went on to outline the basic functions of the FDGB. Given priority were:
Plans Mobilisation of all workers, manual and white collar ..for the fulfillment and fulfillment in advance of the economic (five-year) plans, for the consolidation of labour discipline, for the development of competition and the activists' movement, and for the formation of labour brigades...
"Working out practical methods for increasing the productivity of labour, for the improvement of quality, for lowering the overheads, and for raising the viability of the people's factories.
"Fulfillment of obligations arising out of the factory collective agreements"
Passing reference is made to improving working conditions and living standards. But the message is unmistakeable: the role of the FDGB is to raise productivity through maintaining discipline in the workforce.
Subsequent FDGB documents spelled out in more detail how productivity might be raised and costs cut. Whipping up competition - with the adjective occasionally thrown in - between workers was of central importance:
*The trade unions are responsible for the organisation and development of competition as the principal method of raising labour productivity. The leading bodies of the industrial unions thus have full responsibility for the competition-movement and the activists' movement." (FDGB document, 1951).
As a way of reducing costs the FDGB came up with the idea of deducting money from the wage-packets of its members should they fail to meet the 'norms':
"Insofar as those •with "personal' or "brigade accounts' (i.e. bonuses introduced in 1951 based on the amount of raw materials used in production) use up more than the established norm through their own fault, then deductions are to be made from their wages, corresponding to the extent to which the norm has been exceeded. Such deductions, however, may not exceed 10% of the wage" . (Resolution of FDGB national executive, 1951).
Norms
When higher norms of production were introduced, FDGB greeted this "step forwards towards socialism" and took to task factory-managers who failed to squeeze the workers sufficiently.
"The establishment of technically based labour norms is a principal precondition for the application of a wages system based on achievement...Industrial unions must take pains to ensure that workplace managements fulfill their legal duty - elaboration of technically based norms, and creation of the preconditions for their planned increase, in line with the tasks laid down by the (five-year) plan." (FDGB document, 1951).
The . role of the FDGB extended beyond the workplace itself into the leisure activities of its members.
A night out at the movies? The FDGB would organise it for you: "Once a month a culturally valuable and contemporary film of German, Russian or popular-democratic origin must be shown in the workplace. "But," the FDGB warned, "there is no place for reactionary or kitsch films in the workplace" given that 'in all spheres of cultural work there must be a more energetic struggle than hitherto against formalism and all forms of American cultural barbarism." (FDGB document, 1951).
Theatre
In theatre, too, the FDGB made its presence felt: "The proportion of workers in the Volksbuhne (People's Stage) is to be raised from 30% to 60% ...The audience at premiere performances is to be so composed that 60% are factory workers, especially activists.. Wherever possible premiere performances should be held in large factories." (ibid).
The FDGB prescribed recommended reading for its members: "The importance of ideological work demands a planned use of written propaganda material. This must ...spread the teachings of Starin in the trade unions. (FDGB national execytive resolution, 1951).
The FDGB also arranged evening classes. Themes included: "Economic Plan and Wage Labour (The teachings of Lenin and Stalin on the principle of achievement)": "Learning from the Soviet Union Means Learning to be Victorious! (The teachings of Lenin and Stalin on socialist competition and the Stakhanov moment)" and so on.
The FDGB also laid a Stalinist hand on sporting activities. "A further task of the workplace sports association is encouraging workers to win the sports achievement award Ready for Work and for the Defence of Freedom...
"In its meetings the workplace sports association... should also discuss social questions, especially the concepts of peace between peoples, the unity of Germany, and the struggle for peace and the five-year plan". (FDGB document, 1951).
The FDGB does not unite workers but helps atomise them. Even in the mass demonstrations organised by the FDGB the workers remain atomised: such demonstrations are not the expression of a collective solidarity but stage-managed events organised through the FDGB by the ruling bureaucratic elite, which depends for its very existence on the atomisation of the working class.