Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Rainbow alliance or class politics?

Socialist Organiser no. 263, 20 March 1986 · scan pp. 3–4 · about 1,748 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 3

Should socialists support autonomous movements of specially oppressed? What does this support mean? How far does it mean that socialists must take their cue from women's, black or lesbian/gay groups rather than having distinct judgements or (as it is sometimes put) 'imposing' a line?

The working class, Marx said, 1s a class with 'radical chains' . It is a class which, in liberating itself, can liberate the whole of humanity from all forms of exploitation and oppression. Working class rule over society will be merely a step towards the abolition of all classes, the disappearance of institutions of social and political rule by one group of people over another. We will move 'out of the realm of necessity and into the realm of -But the labour movement in Britain is ill-equipped to carry out a struggle for socialism. It is saturated with reactionary prejudices:

national chauvinism, racism, antisemitism, sexism, anti-lesbian and gay bigotry.

These prejudices have historical roots - they did not drop down from the sky, and white, male, heterosexual workers were not born with them. Often they rest on a degree of material privilege. They are based upon, and reinforce, divisions within the working class, not just in Britain, but internationally (and internationally the divisions run far deeper).

The British labour movement has often proved weak and ineffective in fighting for the most basic rights of white, male workers within capitalism. It has proved even less effective in fighting for the interests of the most downtrodden and dispossessed.

It was the Labour Party, for example, that introduced the 1968 immigration laws designed to keep black people out of Britain.

And with a history of such failure it is not surprising that women, black people, lesbians and gay men, have sought to build movements separate from the existing labour movement structures.

It is not surprising, either, that these movements have generated ideologies hostile or skeptical towards organised labour.

Marxists should not dismiss, scorn or simply denounce these movements.

But in and of themselves, these movements are not the answer. The working class seizure of power will not automatically do away with racism, sexism and prejudice; but those systems of oppression cannot be destroyed without the working class seizure of power. They are bound up with capitalist class oppression - even where, as with women's oppression, they predate it.

Our task is to make the labour movement fight for the interests of the working class as a whole, and for a recognition that the liberation of the specially oppressed is part of this fight.

Self-organisation, or what is often called 'autonomy' ', is a necessary part of the fight to unite the working class and equip it ideologically to overthrow capitalism. Autonomous organisation like women's groups, black groups Labour Party black sections, for example - and so on, can be a powerful force in helping to transorm the labour movement, to uarantee that it does fight. It can he a central part of making the abour movement a real force id f working class people. Newham 8 Campaign Many socialists, however, talk and act as if the socialist movement is defined by its support for 'autonomy' and that alone.

The Greater London Council most strikingly has projected a vision of socialist politics that is based upon the drawing together of various different autonomous movements into an 'alliance' of oppressed groups. Socialist Action's 'alliance for socialism' seems to be a variation on this theme.

The working class, from this perspective, is merely one more 'oppressed group' in an alliance with women, black people, lesbian women, gay men, the disabled, the Irish, and so on and so on.

'Positive discrimination' has come to mean the automatic deference by socialists to a representative of an autonomous organisation of the oppressed. The Labour Party Black Sections have recently suspended a black supporter of Socialist Organiser, Keyvan LajevardiKhosh, for backing a candidate for the LPYS place on Labour's NEC against the Black Sections candidate, Kingsley Abrams. Socialist Organiser has been condemned as "racist' for refusing to stand down our own candidate. Supporters of 'International' have gone so far as to walk out of "Youth Fightback" over the issue.

Undemocratic

Chis is a dangerous conception or socialist politics, and for the Black Sections it implies an extremely undemocratic internal regime.

An 'alliance of various different 'autonomous movements' of the , oppressed can never be an alliance for socialism. A success. ful socialist movement will be one with a unified political strategy, common and coherent ideas. It will be the movement of a united working class. Current divisions - based upon race, gender or sexuality -will, to at least a significant degree, have been conquered.

How will they be conquered? By free debate and discussion. If small groups of activists take it upon themselves to speak as 'the voice of women, of blacks, of lesbians and gays, etc., then unity will become impossible. Indeed it will even become impossible for socialists to take their line from the oppressed groups. When Jewish feminists demand that socialists support them as an oppressed group by backing Israel, and Palestinian feminists say that support for the oppressed means opposing Israel, how do we decide?

Unity can only be created by a revolutionary working class movement through free discussion within its ranks - ranks which include women, blacks, lesbians, gays.

Temporary

In contrast, the 'alliance" strategy is based upon the idea that the common interests of different oppressed groups are only ever partial; and therefore the 'alliance' is temporary. If the divisions run as deep as proponents of the 'alliance" suppose, lasting unity around a coherent socialist programme is an impossible dream. Who can or will treate it?

Ind so an 'allance' of this kind an only be a movement for short-term reform: its objectives can only be - better representation, more equality. within capitalism, It is no ccident that the rainbow coalition' idea has been pioneered in the USA by liberal, pro-capitalist politicians like Jesse Jackson. The "alliance' is inescapably reformist.

An alliance based upon continuing divisions imposed by capitalist society, with no perspective for lasting unity beyond the divisions, is a dangerous idea. Its proponents could do worse than to learn from the South African liberation movement: non-racialism is counterposed by all progressive forces to "multi-racialism' - an alliance of different ethnically-based groups. Our future, says COSATU, will be non-racial; and so must be our present practice.

But what, defines a socialist movement is its ideas, its politics. Socialist politics is fundamentally to do with the self-emancipation of the working class.

There can be no autonomous path to liberation'. • Socialism will not be made by 'autonomous movements': it will be made by the working class. The class is not only - or even mainly! - white, male heterosexual workers. But it will not be a multifarious 'alliance", it will be a united working class.

We need to guarantee that the specially oppressed do win representation. We need to make sure that women and black people in particular are brought forward to leadership positions: self-organisation and positive discrimination can be extremely important in seeing to it that the specially oppressed are not ignored But organisational forms and organisational changes /can/only ever supplement political ideas. *hey cannot subsurute for then...

LESSON Parliamentary reform say, is a slow road to a sure one, free from un revolution. In truth been not so much a slower roa one towards a different In today's chaotic capita world, battered by slumps, it worse. The Socialist government in France under Francois Mitterrand has brought not slow progress of any sort, but a gallop to the right.

It tinkered with the system.

That failed, and it turned to full-scale retreat, which has demoralised the working class and emboldened the right wing.

In 1981 it looked like a new dawn. 23 years of unbroken right wing rule were over. France had a Socialist/Communist government, with only miniscule representation from a bourgeois party, for the first time ever.

Now, in 1986, the fascist National Front has some 34 seats in the French parliament. Overall the right has a 55-45 majority over the left. The Communist Party, which despite everything represents the militant core of the French working class, is down below 10% of the poll; the voters have turned away from it, not to anti-Stalinist class-struggle politics, but to the right or into apathy.

The trade unions are in decline:

the CFDT federation has lost quarter of its membership, and the larger and more militant CGT, a third The left government started out in 1981 by nationalising big companies (the state-owned industrial sector was doubled), cutting the work week to 39 hours, and increasing public expenditure. But this policy created a huge trade deficit for France and put its inflation rate way above other Western countries.

The government surrendered to the logic of capitalism. In mid '82 it brought in a wage freeze; in early 83 it started a full-blown austerity programme. It took the axe to basic industries like steel and coal in a way that lan MacGregor would envy.

Now unemployment is 11%, as against 6% when the Left took power. Wages have been kept down. The share of profits in value-added has gone up from 23% in 1983 to 30% in 1985. Public spending has been cut, although the Left has continued France's nuclear weapons programme and sent troops to Chad.

So the right wing is back. And President Mitterrand, instead of leading working class struggle against the right, intends to work with the right-wing government.

The French workers' bitter experience is a warning to us. A labour movement which puts piecemeal reform politicians into power without also preparing for a fight against them, paves the way for its own demoralisation.

Neil Kinnock is scrapping Labour Party policy wholesale. basing himself on a mood that any sort of Labour government would at least be better than the Tories. Maybe. But France shows us that a Kinnock-model Labour government will fail and - unless a strong independent left-wing is built which defends workers' interests against it will lead to something much worse than Thatcher.

We have successfully completed the first stage of our move, and this is the first issue of Socialist Organiser produced from our new offices in South London. Our new phone nums ber is 01-639 7965 and the address is PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA.

Socialist Organiser no. 263 March 20 1986. Page 3

Scan page 4

Silence Taxing us

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 263

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →