[Is it right to make tactical use Is…]
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-03-27Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 3
Is it right to make tactical use Is it right to make tactical use of the courts to defeat, or at of the courts to defeat, or at least beat back the witchhunters in the Labour Party?
Militant supporters have won court injunctions in Stevenage and in South Wales to hold off expulsions. And supporters of Labour Briefing have adopted the same course of action in Exeter.
Court action seems working.
But in the long term it will not work. It violates an essential working class principle, that the capitalist state should not be permitted to interfere in the internal affairs of the labour movement, and so it undermines the struggle to win the labour movement as a whole to socialist ideas.
The class struggle is increasingly shaped by the law. Anti-union laws, and legal restrictions on local authority spending, have proved central to recent battles: the printworkers (in 1983 as well as now, transport workers, and of course the miners; and the LIVERPOOL CITY COUNCI ICTORY JURY püe Toryattsurcharges of Liverpool and Lambeth councillors.
The labour movement has learned some bitter lessons from these experiences. That the state is not neutral; that the courts as well as the police will be used by the bosses against the labour movement; these are recog nised as realities by many labour movement activists.
But not so the movement's leaders, and therefore not so those thousands of workers who look to them to lead. Keeping within the law, holdROS COMMIE E TO THIT CHC Wing onto legality, are the watchwords of labour movement leaders from Neil Kinnock to Brenda Dean.
The left needs to draw on recent lessons and to hammer home the message: the law is the bosses' law; the courts are the bosses' courts. They should be kept out of our movement.
The labour movement, if it is ever to be a force for radical, socialist change, needs to assert and defend its independence from the ruling class and its institutions. That means maintaining and insist- means maintaining and insisting upon the principle that the labour movement decides upon its own affairs, free from state interference.
Reliance, even tactical reliance, on the capitalist courts to mediate in labour movement affairs, undermines the long-term role of socialists to develop independent working class consciousness.
Of course, socialists are not anarchists: we support and advocate legal enforcement for democratic rights; and there is no reason in principle not to make use of the courts against the bosses. In South Africa, trade unions have often scored important victories through skillful use of the courts against their employers.
That is a different issue. But in any event, socialists would not rely upon the state; we rely upon the strength of the working class.
Turning to the courts necessarily undermines a campaign against witch-hunts in the short term, too.
Once the courts are invol- Once the courts are involved, the matter becomes sub judice' *. The right wing and soft left can easily use this as an excuse to suppress discussion: the mobilisation of a campaign becomes correspondingly harder.
And the financial costs for the local party in defending itself in court can be considerable. Hauling the party through the courts' can be a catch-cry for the right wing in deflecting the real issues.
Whatever the short-term successes, the tactic of court action is certain to rebound on the left. The capitalist courts can and do sometimes decide in favour of the working class, or the left; but they are the natural ally of the right.
The more the courts are involved in the labour movement, the worse it is sure to get. The left should be guarding against more court involvement, not preparing the way for it. The number of NUJ who have refused to cross picket lines at Wapping or left News International since the dispute began has now risen to 42. -But over 550 journa ists are still scabbing.
The fact that the numbe scabbing is still so high is to a large extent the fault of the NUJ leadership who ma done very little to al the scabs.
More effective has beem rank and file SOGAT and NGA pressure on Wapping scabs who work shifts on other papers. The Observer was forced to get rid of its scab last week when print union members threatened to stop the presses.
One new recruit at Wapping to the Sun labour staff is Carson Black, former FoC at the Birmingham Post and Mail and a notorious opponent of the NUJ's policy against voluntary redundancies.