COSATU By Clive Bradley
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-03-27Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
The formation of the Congress of South African Trade Unions (COSATU) at the beginning of December 1985 was the single most important event in the history of the liberation movement in South Africa. The existence of a democratic workers' movement makes possible a revolution that destroys not only apartheid, but capitalism as well. And the resolutions we reprint in this week's Socialist Organiser (see centre pages) indicate the developing socialist ideas of this workers' movement.
COSATU has stressed that it is a political force, a part of the liberation movement. For many years, many of the non-racial unions have kept their distance from overtly political campaigning. They argued that it was necessary to strengthen shop-floor union organisation first.
That view, often criticised from different standpoints as 'economistic' › is no longer tenable. The intensification of the struggle against apartheid, the revolt in the townships, the State of Emergency (recently officially ended), have all forced the unions to take on a political role.
Workers' control
Unions from different traditions came together to form COSATU. The largest non-racial federation since 1979, the Federation of South African Trade Unions (FOSATU) was central to the union-unity talks that led up to the foundation of Congress.
FOSATU had developed some distinctive positions, in trade union matters, and (if only embryonically) on political questions. FOSATU stressed working class democracy and workers' control both within. the unions themselves and, as an objective, in the workplaces; it was FOSATU that most thoroughly rationalised the 'economistic' perspective of building up union organisation as a priority above political campaigning.
But FOSATU developed a perspective of creating an independent working class movement which necessarily would participate in the political struggle. It stressed the importance of maintaining the organisational and political independence of the workers from political movements that may not represent workers' interests.
From within FOSATU, profound and vital debates have emer= ged on the nature of the future South Africa, on workers' control, on the character of the Freedom Charter, and so on. FOSATU members have been associated with the idea of a Workers' Charter' to express working class demands.
In sharp counterposition to the South African Communist Party, which dominates the ANC, FOSATU stressed its support for workers' movements in Eastern Europe.
FOSĄTU's positions were by no means developed Marxist ones, and there was a strong syndicalist bias 264.
to them, but they did, and do, re present nascent working class politics.
A second current involved in COSATU is that associated with the United Democratic Front (UDF) -the broad anti-apartheid coalition that more or less identifies with the exiled ANC tradition.
These unions, principally the South African Allied Workers Union (SAAWU), have tended to organise on a broad, communitywide level, distinct from FOSATU's (and now COSATU's) concentration on industrial unions. Part of the agreement that created COSATU entailed the reorganisation of general unions into industrial unions.
The third, and more diffuse strand in COSATU, is unions that were affiliated neither to the UDF or to FOSATU. These include the huge National Union of Mineworkers (NUM), which split from the moderate Council of Unions of South Africa (CUSA) because (the NUM said the federation was dragging its heels over trade union unity. Other 'independents' are the Commercial, Catering and Allied Workers' Union (CCAWUSA), and the General Workers' Union (GWU).
These 'independents' do not form a single bloc politically. Some are syndicalist-inclined; others are closer to the UDF.
So within COSATU there are different strands. Of course the formation of COSATU was made possible by a relative comingtogether of these strands; and it would be false to suppose that there are, at the moment, explosive tensions within the new federation. But it would be equally false to suppose that all debate has come to an abrupt end, and that COSATU is politically all of one piece.
Many of the central concerns of the old FOSATU current are dominant within COSATU. Industrial ment strong, industry-wide, democratic unions, is COSATU's chosen form of organisation: one of its chief slogans is 'one industry, one union'. • The emphasis on the distinct organisation of the workers is equally prominent. Barayi, who is from an ANC background, responded to the claim that COSATU is a front for the ANC quite clearly:
*We have no links with any organisation It must be clearly stated that COSATU, as a workers organisation, will put the interests of workers first." (Congress News, page 9).
Nevertheless, the pro-UDF forces within COSATU seem to be politically in the ascendant.
COSATU has met with SACTU and the ANC in exile and issued a joint statement. Each organisation stated its own role in the struggle separately. But a key passage states: .. the fundamental problem facing our country, the question of political power, cannot be resolved without the full participation of the ANC, Which is regarded by the majority of the people of South Africa as the overall leader and genuine representative.
When the newspaper, the 'Sowetan' said there were conflicts within COSATU over the joint meeting, COSATU, alleging bias, organised a boycott of the paper.
A further indication of proUDF positions can be taken from decisions of the NUM conference earlier this year. The election of Nelson Mandela as honorary president was widely reported. Equally significant was NUM's decision to forge links with Arthur Scargill's Stalinist International Miners' Organisation.
NUM, like COSATU as a whole, has voiced the determination to *link up with community organisations' and the political struggle. But if they do so on the political programme of the UDF - which is what it is likely to mean in practice - there is a big danger of the independent workers' voice being submerged.
The formation of COSATU has also, of course, forced a more positive attitude towards the working class on the ANC. Not so long ago, the unions were condemned by the ANC and SACTU as 'economistic and worse; now the ANC and SACTU are anxious to prove that they are the driving force in COSATU - and have been the driving force in the unions all along...
There are still some sizeable black workers' unions outside COSATU. The two federations which lean towards Black Consciousness - the moderate CUSA and the more militant AZACTU have remained outside. AZACTU fears that 'non-racialism' can be an ideological cover for 'white liberalism'. In its place they propose 'antiThis is a semantic and sectarian argument; and unity between COSATU and other federations will probably depend upon a big shift in the hard-line Black Consciousness position. For the present the fact that CUSA and AZACTU are out means that a number of political militants who are often to the left of the ANC are outside the main union organisation, and the UDF/ ANC influence is that much less challenged.
All of this takes place against a backdrop of growing workers struggles.
South Africa is in the middle of a deep recession. Since 1982 over 100,000 jobs have been lost in the metal industry alone. The mining industries are the only ones to have escaped the effects of this recession and that is one factor behind the browth of the NUM.
Longer strikes
Yet despite the recession, unemployment and defeats for localised workers' struggles, the combativity of the working class is increasing. In 1985, 239,816 workers were involed in strike action, as against 182,000 in 1984. In January 1986 alone, 385,000 working days were lost.
Strikes are getting longer and more bitter. Experts expect 'protracted trials of strength to be the norm of the future. And increasingly, new tactics are being adopted: factory occupations are spreading.
There is a growing politicisation of industrial relations. Economic demands are featuring less centrally, and wildcat strikes against racial incidents' are more common.
Strikes have had to take on a more political character: both the major disputes of 1985, the miners' strike in September and the Sarmcol BTR strike that still goes on, were supplemented with consumer boycotts taking on broader political issues - opposition to the State of Emergency.
This will be the pattern of the future. The workers' struggle and the general struggle for freedom are, and will increasingly be in practice, inseparable.
Collaboration between the unions and community-based groups is vital in this. Both the building up of democratic, community-based organisation, and the unionisation of the vast reserve army of unemployed, will be crucial.
But big political questions remain to be answered. FOSATU's syndicalist bias has resulted in a political vacuum that can only be filled, at the moment, by the UDF. If the workers' movement is left to the control and unchallenged influence of the UDF, the result, for certain, will be that the workers do not see the fruits of the revolution that will depend for its victory upon their power, The creation of a new, independent working class poutical party must be discussed urgently