Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Why We Walked Out

Socialist Organiser no. 265, 3 April 1986 · scan pp. 1–2 · about 2,271 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 1 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 1

The Party leadership are going down a road which they think will lead them to victory at the next election, but as far as I'm concerned is more likely to have the opposite effect.

People around the country are becoming increasingly confused. The leadership is handing the Tories and the Alliance a present on a plate which they will continue to use to have a go at Labour. Obviously they will be saying, well you've dealt with 12, but what about the other 5,000 Militant claim to have? What about the Militant MPs? What about supporters of other left-wing papers? It will so confuse people that it can only have a disastrous effect on the Labour Party.

Subversives

I reckon that as it goes on it will go from bad to worse with Tony Benn, Dennis Skinner and myself becoming possible targets for expulsion as subversives and "saboteurs" , the word used of us by the leader.

What's behind all this? It's as clear as daylight as far as I'm concerned. It's the view that struggles like Liverpool, Lambeth and the miners, with left-wing leaderships, will lose us the election. I believe the NEC has been conned into believing that we've got to eliminate, beginning with Militant, the identified hard leftthat the press call us.

So they begin with Militant who are particularly identified Balance with Liverpool. But it won't stop there.

SDP It might win back a few people who are intending to vote for the SDP, but in the process it's going to totally disorientate the Party and the membership. Party activists are becoming increasingly disillusioned both by this episode and the way in which Labour National Party policies are being renounced one by one. Union of I think the Party membership is so desperate to win the next election that there is a feeling that whether we like it or not conference we have to keep our heads down in order to get Thatcher out. What they don't realise is that if we end up with SDP policies, those voters who are now disillusioned with Thatcher won't vote for us, but for the SDP.

Continued on page 2 Pri nt Eric Heffer. Photo: Ian Swindale.

Sri Lanki

Scan page 2

The Labour Party has now circulated all members with summaries of the majority and minority reports of the inquiry into Liverpool Distrct Labour party.

The covering letter Irom general secretary Larry Whitty says "There can be no doubt that there was widespread abuse of the Party's Constitution". . But the majority report is hardly convincing.

Its allegations are*The District Labour Party took decisions on matters normally the province of Constituency parties and Labour Groups, *In late 1985 "due in part to understandable pressure of events" the DLP operated through aggregate meetings rather than||normal delegate meetings.

*"There widespread impression that certain From page 1 At the NEC I moved a resolution which asked for the full statement by the Judge - his judgement and his comments - to be in front of us to look at and consider. All we were given was a summary of the statement and we argued that that wasn't good enough. We should have the whole statement. Having looked at it we should decide whether we could proceed and how to proceed to ensure that there was proper natural justice. We lost that vote by 20-9.

Tony Benn moved another resolution that the charges should be withdrawn until they had been properly written out. We lost that 20-9 and Felicity Dowing was brought in.

She had a sheet, already written out, there's no argument about that. But you'd have to be a genius to understand what it meant, Then the chair tried to take her through the charges. Felicity said she would need time to read through them before she could comment on any of them and the chair said she could have a few minutes.

Eric Clarke then said "Well, I've had enough of this, we've already had enough of this nonsense before" and he got up and we all walked out.

The 12 had all received a letter which listed charges A, B, C and so on with brief written comments by the side. But none of them had a specific charge sheet saying that this charge has been made by someone else against you. It was very unclear. We took the view that what was happening could have been interpreted as contempt of court.

We were told that for the prosecution the general secretary April aalist Organiser no.265 60% CO jobs have been allocated on the basis of faction. " But the report states that "the Investigation Team are not in a position to judge the accuracy" of this impression That's all. Not much oi a charge sheet! One item in it, the District Labour Party deciding municipal policy raiher than the council Labour Group, is positively to the credit of Liverpool Many rght-wing Labour Groups have systematically defied local Labour Party policy, and even expelled councillors for supporting Labour policy and yet they get no NEC 'inquiries"

The minority report from the inquiry, signed by Audrey Wise and Margaret Beckett, criticises the running of the DLP and makes proposals for improvements; but rejects any talk of expulsions. would, on each occasion give the evidence and then withdraw.

After the court judgement the 12 had to be allowed to bring in witnesses. Previously they'd been told no witnesses, only a friend. How could we have dealt with a situation where the defendants wanted to produce witnesses to give evidence who were still in Liverpool? It was ridiculous, The next NEC meeting is on April 18. We are told that on the agenda will appear the Standing Orders of the NEC. They want to change the quorum. It's basically an attempt to move the goal posts. If they can't win by the rules as they are, they'll change the rules.

I've never accepted the idea of democratic centralism because what happens is that it ends up all centralism and not very much democracy. The Labour Party has ostensibly been against democratic centralism. But in practice what is happening is increasing centralism.

I've had no complaints from local Party members about our walk-out.

One of the inquiry's decisions was to set up a coordinating committee on a temporary basis until the Party was restored. That committee was to be made up of delegates from constituency parties, socialist societies, and trade unions where the union general secretaries were to arrange for representatives to be sent.

The first meeting of this committee was held on Thursday night (27th) and with the Liverpool 12 not having been expelled, as no doubt some people had expected, they re-elected Mulhearn as chair and passed a resolution congratulating and supporting the seven NEC members who walked out. 1986 Page MANAGEMENT at the Telegraph have gone in for the kill.

They are demanding 'substantial" redundancies, but won't say exactly how many from the workforce of 3300.

Andrew Knight, chief executive of the Telegraph group, has described the attack as "a survival plan and a viability plan". Central On April Fool's Day, press magnate Robert Maxwell set up two new companies - one for publishing the Scottish Daily Record and the Sunday Mail, and one for printing these titles But such a shoddy manoeuvre will fool no-one: it has clearly been Robert Maxwell's intention all along to follow in Rupert Murdoch's footsteps.

By setting up two new and separate companies, solidarity action between journalists and printworkers, once employed, but now sacked, by the Record and Mail becomes illegal. So, too, does any action by victimised exemployees of Maxwell against his new companies.

Both SOGAT and NUJ have consistently fallen over backwards to try to open up negotiations with Maxwell to try to find a "compromise which could end the present dispute in which neither the Record nor the Mail have been published since the weekend of 8-9 March.

At the beginning of last week SOGAT agreed to talks on "negotiable and voluntary redundancies" and also gave a commitment not to attempt to "influence the editorial content of the papers" in the mistaken belief that this would lead to an opening of negotiations and the dropping of legal action against SOGAT by Maxwell.

Similarly, the NUJ has also placed great stress on its concern for the resumption of negotiations, even going so far as to appeal to Neil Kinnock to act as a mediator in the dispute, whilst at the same time maintaining the strike action and picketing by its members at Maxwell's Anderston Quay plant in Glasgow.

But Maxwell has responded to such calls for negotiations with repeated kicks in the teeth.

The legal proceedings against SOGAT have not been dropped. On the contrary, last Wednesday (26 March) Maxwell won a lurther injunction in the High Court on the basis of SOGAT members respecting NUJ picket lines at Anderstor Quay And a new conto this is a proposed move printing operations to a 1 mou docklands plant at West Ferry on the Isle of Dogs.

Management

If Telegraph management are to be resisted successfully, then the battle to save jobs at the tempt action against SOGAT will be initiated by Maxwell on April 8, the start of the new law term.

Maxwell's response to the NUJ's appeal for negotiations has been a stream of abuse. The union has been described by Maxwell as "Lions led by donkeys" and NUJ officials have been accused of "misleading their members, vilifying their publisher, and carrying on a campaign of lies and insults"

Even before the establishment of the two new companies, all 230 journalists at Anderston Quay had been sacked and invited to re-apply for employment through a private PO Box number. The NUJ called for a boycott of this ploy by Maxwell, who pledged that any journalist expelled from the NUJ would nevertheless be re-employed by himself.

The News International facsimile plant at kinning Park (Glasgow), where the Scottish and North of England editions of the Sun are printed remains the scene of round-the-clock picketing, but only on a token basis.

Ten weeks of such picketing has made no impact on the scabs. The response to the pickets has largely been one of indifference though some EETPU members "justify' working in the plant by claiming it was a "green field site" , while NUJ members have sought to put the blame for the situation on SOGAT's failure to respect NUT picket lines in Fleet paper needs to be linked all-round fight to save jobs Fleet Street.

The possibility exists to do this as Telegraph SOGAT chapels have been among the best at mobilising their members for the Wapping pickets.

At the close of last week, Anderston Quay management offered the NUJ talks on the basis of a series of non-negotiable preconditions and a return to work formula which included scrapping of the journalists' four day week.

When the NUJ put forward alternative proposals, management rejected them and declared that the talks had irretrievably broken down".

Maxwell tollowed this up by threatening the indefinite suspension of the publication of the Record and Mail and the transfer of the bulk of the printing operations from Glasgow to Manchester. A day later all Anderston Quay employees were sent yet another redundancy note in the post and 'invited' to re-apply for a job at Maxwell's new companies.

Maxwell is engaged in a classic union-busting operation. He has declared his readiness to employ Street two years ago.

Demonstrations outside the Kinning Park plant are organised by SOGAT once a week. Held at teatime on a Thursday to coincide with the start of a shift at the plant, such demonstrations have unfortunately attracted decreasing numbers.

The first, nearly a month ago, attracted a thousand trade unionists. Last week, only 200 turned up.

SOGAT's main gambit in the dispute is to push ahead with the boycott of News International publications and to appeal, as an OUT MAXWELL!

Robert Maxwell has followed Rupert Murdoch and stuck up barbed wire round his Anderston Quay printworks.

Only a few weeks ago Maxwell was denouncing Murdoch as "unBritish" and comparing Fortress Wapping to a concentration camp.

Maxwell should be thrown out of the Labour Party! And out of his union ASTMS! non-NUJ members as journalists, as well as having stated that he is "giving urgent consideration to ending the closed shop agreement with SOGAT". And Maxwell's latest letter to employees states that the new companies will only employ staff whose unions have "no quarrel" with the company, or those who reapply for their old jobs in breach of union instructions.

This provides an opportunity for victimisation of trade union militants and for using the Tory anti-union laws against trade union opposition.

The latest turn of events at Anderston Quay underlines once more the need to link up the disputes against Maxwell and Murdoch. Failure to do so will mean defeat not just for the thousands of print union members London and Glasgow but also a defeat for the trade union movement as a whole. alternative, tor consumers to putchase Scottish newspapers, such as the currently non-ex mant Daily Record.

Whilst the boycott campaign has had some impact, and also helped get across the issues in this dispute, in itself it is insufficient to defeat Murdoch.

The narrow streets around Kinning Park plant make it, like Wapping, a prime site for pıcketing. Mass picketing timed to coincide with the transportation of the papers out of the plant needs. to be organised if the dispute is not to stagnate.

----- pull-quotes -----

sheet the G

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 265

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →