Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

We Need a Rank and File Movement

Socialist Organiser no. 265, 3 April 1986 · scan p. 3 · about 1,247 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 3

Angry print workers at Wapping. Photo: Andrew Moore. IN JUST a couple of months, a series of major blows have been struck against trade unionism in the print.

* Rupert Murdoch has sacked 6000 trade unionists and set up scab operations behind barbed wire at Fortress Wapping.

* Robert Maxwell has sacked the workforce on the Daily Record and Sunday Mail three times, and is now setting up two new companies to run operations behind barbed wire at Anderston Quay, Glasgow. 230 journalists remain sacked.

* At the Daily Mirror Maxwell has succeeded in cutting the workforce by 2000 through 'voluntary' redundancies without a fight.

* And as we go to press it looks like the print unions will join the NUJ in accepting job cuts of one-third and major changes in working practices at the Express.

How has this happened?

The print bosses have certainly chosen their time well. These attacks come in the wake of the defeat of the miners' strike, at a time when the militancy and willingness to fight of workers is not at its highest.

This has been magnified by the effects of slump and the fear of unemployment, creating a climate in which workers are prepared to sell their jobs rather than risk everything in battles they fear they may be able to win.

This demoralisation is obviously a very real factor but its effects could have been limited if the leaders of the print unions had properly prepared for the attacks that they could see coming.

The strategy of the print union leaders is the product of the 'new realism'.

Throughout last year Dean and Dubbins stuck their heads in the sand, refusing to recognise what was happening around them, even going along with the fiction that Rupert Murdochreally wanted to produce a new paper, The London Post, at Wapping.

On the eve of Murdoch's mass sackings they were plead. ing with him to negotiate, and offering a deal which Dubbins described as "the best deal offered to any Fleet Street employer ever". It included flexibility of labour, binding arbitration and a promise to outlaw unofficial action.

The special January issue

MO

SOGAT Journal led withBrenda Dean's 'message for Murdoch': "We'll fight - or negotiate"

The print unions had strategy to deal with the in duction of new technolo For SOGAT, the need 'adapt' was coupled with attempt to use the issue poach NGA members.

atary They had will to oppose voluntary redundancies, always looking to postpone a confrontation, and thereby weakening themselves for the time when confrontation proved unavoidable.

And they have desperately tried to stop the dispute spreading. The clearest example is the refusal to link the disputes against Murdoch and Maxwell in Scotland. But that is only an example. As the News International dispute was beginning, SOGAT refussed to fight the sacking, as a result of a fight to defend union organisation, of the deputy FoC in the Mirror machine chapel.

And so they have avoided calling for print-industry-wide action, never mind more general solidarity. Instead they have modelled themselves on the Times dispute of 1978, which was on after a war of attrition, with the strikers sustained by print union levies and 'casual' jobs on other papers.

Rank and file pressure has shifted Dean's and Dubbins's emphasis a bit. But the essential strategy is no different. They are still reluctant to organise effective mass pickets at Wapping. Protest marches are held in completely different parts of London.

And Brenda Dean has written to Jack Taylor of the Yorkshire miners, urging them to ignore requests to build mass pickets at Wapping.

Conflicts

Neil Kinnock, of course, has supported the "softly, softly approach, urging printworkers to avoid any action -i.e. mass picketing with its necessary conflicts with the police - that might bring adverse publicity.

All of this is based upon supposed lessons of the miners' defeat. A policy of confrontation, and all that it entails, are judged to have been proven not to work. Mass pickets, open defiance of the anti-union laws, appeals for solidarity - especially over the heads of the leaders of other unions - are all considered to be dangerous tactics. 'Public opinion' is the prime target.

The miners, so tney argue, did not carry "public opinion" with them: they were seen to be 'extremists" ', and so they were defeated.

Keeping within the law is viewed as particularly crucial. And the NA's bitter experience of the 1983 Stockport Messenger defeat gives extra force to this view within the print unions.

Lessons

So the union leaders have tried to skirt around the issue and avoid unlawful action as far as they can (although the whole dispute is technically unlawful), by not pushing for mass pickets and so on.

But this strategy is based upon drawing the wrong lessons from the miners' defeatand from the Stockport Messenger. It contradicts what Dean and Dubbins themselves say about the significance and implications of the print dispute. And it will not ensure victory.

Fundamental

The fundamental cause of the miners' defeat was the failure of the trade union leaders to mobilise their members in solidarity. A clear lead from the trade union - and Labour Party leaders could have made a huge difference, giving confidence to layers of the trade union movement whose support for the miners was never more than passive.

And the clear lesson of this is that we need to build a rank and file movement in the trade unions. Such a movement would not be able to mobilise the millions of trade unionists simply regardless of the actions of trade union leaders; but it would be able to act as a militant force and pole of attraction having an effect on the actions of the leaders, as well as the confidence of wide sections of workers.

Certainly, a rank and file movement across the trade unions would be able to develop solidarity action independently, up to a point, of trade union leaders. And such a militant, active movement would form a springboard towards transforming the union structures themselves.

And the building of such a movement will depend upon rank-and-file initiatives, including in the current print dispute, Appeals by Dean and Dubbins for direct solidarity would help to develop such solidarity. If, as they say, the print dispute is crucial for the future of trade unionism, they ought to be making such calls.

But control over the dispute itself needs to be put into the hands of the rank and file. There have been independent rank-and-file initiatives: the SOGAT London District Council organised picket of Wapping was a big step forward, for example. These need to be expanded And the rank and file needs to work out the tactics and policies that will win the current strike and prepare for future battles.

This means that action must be spread across the print industry. All national newspapers must be pulled out in solidarity. A rank and file committee of FoCs and MoCs from all the newspapers should run the strike.

Pressure must be stepped up for boycotts by SOGAT members, and activists should visit all SOGAT members to get the arguments across.

Rank and file organisation now needs to be linked to the development of workers' control over the media industry. Newspapers and other media should be taken out of the hands of press barons like Murdoch and Maxwell, and put under democratic control.

Socialıst Organiser no.265 3 April 1986 Page 3

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 265

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →