The case of Healy's
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-04-03Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
The Zion connection A POWERTUN runs from the so-called left of the "neutrality" between US imperial Labour Party right into the centre of ing to speak for lefts' in the Labour/ Top of the list, we have the most The same organ supported the ZionistTHE WRP split wide open last October, and now there are two organisations calling themselves the WRP.
One, led - perhaps nominally - by Gerry Healy, the dictator of the old organisation for 3½ decades, resumed publishing a daily paper, The Newsline' , at the beginning of February. The second WRP, which seems to contain all the other prominent leaders of the old organisation - the Banda brothers, Cliff Slaughter, Tom Kemp, Bill Hunter, etc. - now published a weekly, the Workers' Press.
The Newsline group is indistinguishable from the WRP of the previous decade except that one more conspirator and enemy is now added to the long list of its devils - 'the Banda-Slaughter clique' . For the Newsline group all the old lunatic certainties - like the dogma that the miners did not suffer defeat in 1985 - remain fixed and the 'dialectical" prophet Healy is still in his place in the firmament.
The Workers Press group is the interesting WRP. For many weeks now they have given over a large proportion of the paper to a free discussion of some of the issues thrown up by their break with Healy. They have a long way to go yet before they will have worked themselves clear of Healyism, and it is not at all obvious that they will arrive at coherent or stable revolutionary socialist politics as a result of their political reappraisals.
The pressure on them, and the temptation, must be to sink into a lowestcommon-denominator of "kitsch-Trotskyism' - that is, "Trotskyist' forms filled with the current, often populist, fashions and enthusiasms of the broader lett.
Those who were prominent leading members of Gerry Healy's WRP still maintain the transparent fiction that "they didn't know' about Healy's misdeeds. On the other hand, it must take a great deal of courage for those of them who spent decades inside Gerry Healy's "machine for maiming militants' even partially to confront their own past Organiser no.265 John O'Mahony discusses the scandalous of Healy's WRP, and the light it sheds on sections of the left. (Part 2 next week).
and set about radically reassessing it.
That they are trying to do that testifies to a continuing devotion to the socialist goals they must have thought they were serving during all their years of moral, intellectual, political and physical thraldom under the unfettered rule of the brutal and sadistic bully Gerry Healy. Old-timers like Bill Hunter, politically eclipsed and silenced for a quarter of a century, now seem to be playing a prominent role.
In a curious way what is happening to them resembles what happened to thinking members of the British Communist Party in 1956-7 after Khrushchev denounced Stalin at the so-called *20th Congress of the CPSU in February 1956 and thereby blew the lid off the Stalinist parties, putting everything up for reassessment. And as a matter of fact some of them went through that experience as CPers in 1956-7 before making their way to a sort of Trotskyism.l The discussion pieces published by Workers' Press have included a letter by SO's editor John O Mahony which asked for clarification on the Workers' Press group's attitude to such things as the libel case the Healyites brought against SO. The Workers Press group itself is now facing a barrage of legal actions by the Healyites - actions designed to drive them out of business.
Issue
One very important issue raised in response to John O'Mahony's letter is the question of the anti-semitism of Healy's WRP. In 1983 SO published an article by John O'Mahony accusing the WRP of blatant anti-semitism, and now Charlie Pottins, a Workers Press supporter and also a prominent member of the Jewish Socialist Group, has re-raised this question in Workers Press.
He accuses O'Mahony of "smearing the Party as 'anti-semites' and even 'pogromists' " (Workers Press, 8.3.86). Such "vicious slanders and incitements" are not "honest polemics" ,he insists.
In fact in 1983 it was Charlie Pottins who wrote the three-page Newsline reply to O'Mahony's SO article, lending his name as a prominent Jewish Socialist Group member to cover for the Healyites' anti-semitism.
Now this is a very important question. It can be easily demonstrated that the Healyite WRP was and is indeed blatantly anti-semitic. But if that were all there was to it, then it might not be worth returning to the subject now.
SATURDAY anti-semitic ravings of Healy's WRP are no more than an extreme and open expression, in (as we shall see) language and forms close to those of traditional anti-semitism, of ideas which are implicit in the fervent 'anti-Zionism', the strident insistence that Israel must be destroyed, common to much of the left.
To go over the edge into more or less explicit anti-semitism the Healyites needed only to add to the common left anti-Zionist demonology their own characteristic paranoia and a mercenary desire to get into step with the most extreme anti-Israeli Arab chauvinism.
While it would be libellous to identify the 'anti-Zionist left with the antisemitism of the Healyites, it nevertheless seems to us that what the Healyites made of the anti-Zionist demonology which they share with much of the left (and until not so long ago with SO too) holds an accurate mirror up to that ideology.
The Newsline editorial reproduced on this page was not just something that can be shrugged off as a peculiarity of Healy's crackpot WRP. On the same day that the editorial appeared, and side by side with it on the same page, Newsline carried an interview with 'Red Ken' Livingstone, then leader of the Greater London Council. In that interview Livingstone - who now considers himself a candidate to become leader of the Labour Party - chattily agreed with the interviewer that, of course, the item in a recent BBC 'Money Programme exposing the distribution of Libyan money to political groups in Britain, and the first place the WRP. had been inspired by 'the Zionists' to discredit the Livingstone was then a joint editor of Labour Herald - a publication set up by Healy's WRP for Ken Livingstone and Ted Knight and 'technically' edited by Steven Miller, a member (according to Workers Press) of the Central Committee of Healy's WRP.
Livingstone did not demur at the anti semitism of the Newsline editorial. SO publicly asked him to say where he stood on it: "What does he think of the editorial? Does he think we should just shrug and accept anti-semitism as a feature of the far left?" (SO 14.4.83).
Livingstone never answered explicitly - but he continued to collaborate with the WRP and appear on its plattorms at public meetings for two years longer. In its own way that was a pretty clear answer.
Such tolerance of Healy's antisemitic ravings tells its own story.
It would be wrong and unfair to hold the Workers Press group responsible for the Healyite editorial (though one still finds some echoes of its ideas in WP -see below). Reflex self-defence, such as Charlie Pottins', is humanly understandable and may prove to have no political significance - even for Pottins himself. The Workers Press group may well choose to cleanse itself of this most filthy part of Healy's legacy too.
I take it up here not to try to brand the Workers Press group with the Healyite editorial but because of the general importance of the issue re-raised by Charlie Pottins.
Though Healy has now gone yet deeper into the isolation of his own political sewer, the question of our attitude to the Jewish state and our political programme for the Middle East -which Healy 'solved" by merging pseudo anti-imperialism with vicarious Arab chauvinism into something close to Hitlerite anti-semitism - remains a major one for the left.
The first part of this article deals with Healy's WRP. The second, next week, will deal with the serious left and Israel.
Workers Press legal defence fund: WRP, 21b Old Town, London SW4 OJT.
Charlie Pottins says it is just a smear to accuse Healy's WRP of anti-semitism.
What are the facts? Healy's WRP did publish undisguised and unmistakable anti-semitic material, as TIl now prove. As well as the particular record of the WRP, I think much that an entire broad spectrum of the revolutionary, Trotsky, lelt says about Israel and 'Zionism' is implicitly anti-semitic. I'll separate the two issues out.
On Saturday 9 April 1983 Newsline's editorial (This Morning') appeared with a small strapline in the top left hand corner "From "Socialist Organiser" to Reagan and Thatcher" followed by the main headline, across the column: "The Zionist Connection"
Strapline
The strapline summed up the editorial's thesis: there is an international Zionist conspiracy stretching from Ronald Reagan's cabinet, through Mrs Thatcher's Downing St, all the way to Socialist Organiser!
The editorial began:
"A powerful Zionist connection runs from the so-called left of the Labour Party right into the centre of this government in Downing St. There is no difficulty whatever in proving this" Evidence? "Mr Stuart Young, a director of the Jewish Chronicle" has been appointed as "youngest ever chairman of the BBC". "He is the brother of Mr David Young, another Thatcher appointee, who is chairman of the Manpower Services Commission... This is the key organisation the Tories are transforming into a 'corporatist front' [Newsline's quotes| to mobilise jobless youth from 14 years upwards into a slave labour body to break trade union wages, safety procedures and working conditions". The TUC and Labour chiefs have accepted "these appointments" of the Zionist Young brothers "without a murmur of protest"
Yes, but what is special about the Young brothers as distinct from any other Tory pigs? Why is it essential to give the job of organising slave labourers to David Young as opposed, say, to Norman Tebbit?!
Following immediately after quote comes Newsline's answer.
*The Tories know they can rely totally upon Zionist imperialism sIc] to produce the most hated reactionarfor use in such filthy work. But the Tories have other goals too. They can turn to their own use the reasonable hatred people will feel against these "Zionist imperialists". , "in order to transform the situation at a later date into a pro-fascist anti-semitic pogrom against all the Jews in general" -There follows a paragraph in bold type intended to illustrate the last point but which is sheer goobledegook. Zionism and Hitler agreed to let rich Jews leave Germany on condition that they become Zionists. Today the Tories "know they have a powerful anti-Semitic trump card up their sleeves, to replay..." Dastardly Zionist imperialists like the Youngs - i.e. politically prominent Jews - are helping them prepare it.
Brothers
In what way do the Young brothers especially represent "Zionist imperialism"?
That's not clear, but in the context the answer can only be that they are Jews and that any Jew in any similar position is necessarily a link in the chain through which Zionist imperialism" interlaces itself with the other imperialisms - which the editorial will later strongly suggest, it guides and may even control.
Newsline continues:
"From the support and advance publicity which the 'Jewish Chronicle' gave the BBC's 'Money Programme' the reactionary Zionist link was clear for all to see [sic]. But it also stretches through Downing St channels right into the White House and President Reagan"
Naturally any Jewish Chronicle interest in an organisation it knows to be funded by Libya is proof positive that the WRP, Libya etc. are victims of an international Zionist conspiracy.
Now the editorial goes off on another tack.
US provocation against Libya "raisesin its sharpest form the central political
Scan page 9
Everyone on the left regards Hitler's massacre of the Jews as the most terrible example of what we are fighting against. Yet many of the WRP's arguments about a Zionist conspiracy' stretching across classes, countries, and radically different political forces, echo the same logic as the Nazi ravings about the 'world Jewish conspiracy'. question". Do "Trotskyists" support Gaddafi? Newsline lies that Socialist Organiser is neutral.
And Socialist Organiser supported *the Zionist-sponsored Money Programme". Now we come to the knot-tying exercise.
"Here" from SO "is unqualifiéd support the work of Thatcher's IOT appointee as chairman of the BBC" who is also a director of British Caledonian Airways eh? and the British Overseas Trade Group for Israel So it is all clear. They needed to put in a Jew as chair of the BBC to get the Libyan gold item into a little early Sunday evening programme! And of course only Jews backed by the Cabinet could organise this attack on the WRP.
Newsline continues: "SO has landed itself right bang in the middle of Thatcher's hand-picked Zionists as an out hinting the WIf ahd the News Line to.
hunting our principled stand against imperialism and in support of the Libyan masses SIC under their leader Muammar Gaddati Gerry Healy obviously thinks Thatcher has set the Jews on him!
Hour
*The question of the hour, we repeat, is the pro-Zionist-policies of the Reagan and Thatcher administrations"
So who is in charge here? Zionism or Washington and London? Which is dog and which tail?
We shall see. But the author has more to reveal. He knows or senses something special about SO that explains how SO fits into the 'Zionist connection' *In the background of the 'Socialist Organiser' one can detect a powerful current of anti-Arab racism - also shared by Reagan and Thatcher. That is the substance of their support for the 'Money Programme' '.." By contrast. Newsline unhesitatingly supports the Libyan and Palestinian people and its leadership" Yes. And against what exactly do they need support? "Against the nuclear war plans of Reagan, Thatcher and the Zionists in their campaign to destroy all national liberation movements in the Middle East. Socialist Organiser has joined the class enemy". We are probably making our own small nuclear device in a cellar somewhere in London as our contribution.
Finally comes the editorial's punchline and finale. "The Zionist connection between these so-called 'lefts' in the Labour Party right through to Thatcher and Reagan's White House is there for all to see in its unprincipled nakedness"
Now the writer of that editorial could be briefly dismissed as a nutcase -albeit an anti-semitic nutcase. Petty personal paranola oozes out of it, interwoven with the grand historical paranoia of the various world Jewish conspiracy theories with which the editorial aligned itself. If a Jew becomes chair of the BBC, then what else can it be but a 'Zionist' conspiracy calling on the aid of the prime minister to fix up for a rather mild item on the WRP to be broadcast on a low-audience early Sunday evening television programme. If the WRP is feeling persecuted, why it must be "the Zionists"
Why was the Money Programme's alleged witch-hunt' the work of 'Zionists? Because a Jew is chair of the BBC? Or did the WRP notice what might be a Jewish name credited for part of it! Or is it because only "Zionists' are concerned with the Middle East? Because only "Zionists' exhibit the sort of "powerful current of anti-Arab racism" that the sensitive and omniscient "one" who wrote the editorial could detect in the background of SO? (There are people with 'a flair' for detecting these things, you know...)
Is it because the Jewish Chronicle showed interest? Interest "in an expose of people it must regard as at least potential pogromists" (to quote what I said in the 1983 SO article.
The Newsline editorial is the work of a writer who feels himself to be surrounded by Jews - Tory "Zionists' Reagan "Zionists" , SO 'Zionists' . Perhaps his buried conscience is troubling him.
But the small-beer paranoia of one who needs to believe that Thatcher had to appoint a Jew chair of the BBC to secure the very tame revelations of the Money Programme should be separated out from the picture of the world which painted. It is a very familiar picture.
The Newsline editorialist theorises along the well-worn paths of classic antisemitism, such as that embodied in the Tsarist secret police forgery The Protocols of the Elders of Zion' (1905) - the book that has rightly been called 'a warrant for genocide' against the Jews of Europe under Hitler.
What the editorial asserts is that there is a world-wide "Zionist' conspiracy linking and bonding people who are politically millions of miles apart - from members of Reagan's government to 'the centre' of Mrs Thatcher's cabinet, the commanding heights of the BBC and all the way through to... the publishers of And what links these seeming polar opposites? 'Zionism' and "Zionist imperialism'. But Zionism here is a transparent code word, and plainly the writer is talking about a conspiracy of Jews - a conspiracy of political opposites who can nevertheless conspire together in the interests of "Zionist imperialism' because they are Jews.
Who are the "Zionists"? For Newsline the Zionists are all Jews who do not accept the proposal to smash and dismantle the Israeli state and to replace it by a Palestinian Arab state in which Jews are promised individual though not national rights - in other words all Jews except a few revolutionary socialists and a few of the ultra-religious.
*The Tories know that they can rely totally upon Zionist imperialism to produce the Neve line in estect dines all Jews as Newsline all Jews as "agents of Zionist imperialism' (or, to put it at the mildest, it assumes the right to so define any hostile Jew it can identify in any place of prominence within the capitalist system).
in this picture Zionist imperialism is no small or secondary power. Israel is not merely what it really is, a mere regional sub-imperialism with special features. "The question of the hour" is not Us imperialism, or the domination of a large part of the world by Stalinist totalitarianism: it is the subservience of the US to 'Zionism', "the pro-Zionist policies of the Reagan and Thatcher administrations", Tentacles "Zionist imperiaiism" must be the very heart of imperialism, whose controlling tentacles reach secretly right into the centre of Mrs Thatcher's cabinet and into Reagan's too.
The Jews, it seems, are now the international janissaries of imperialism and -the logic is inescapable - possibly imperialism itself is only a projection of the Jewish drive for world domination.
Now there are Jews - or if you like "Zionists' - in bourgeois cabinets, perhaps in some politburos still, in the BBC and in SO. The Jews are a people scattered through all segments of society and throughout the world.
Seek evidence that there may be a conspiratorial network of Jews, and you will find it - red Jews and Rothschilds, members of Reagan's and Thatcher's cabinets and writers for SO. These "links' The once Red Ken and future Lord Redken: in 1983 Livingstone rushed to appear in the pages of the daily Newsline, where he reassured Healy's WR that he too thought they were the victims of a "Zionist' conspiracy. are the raw material from which theories about Jewish' or "Zionist' conspiracies can easily be spun.
But - given the vast political gulf separating those linked together in the Newsline editorial - the only possible 'rational' common denominator on which to base such a theory is race (whatever that may be).
For of course not all the "Zionists' are imperialists. Some of them are socialists and call themselves Trotskyists, like SO. They too are part of the conspiracy - and to judge by all the attention we were being given, a very important part of it. This is the proof of the vile racist basic structures and logic embedded in that editorial.
There is a parallel if not identity with Jewish world conspiracy theories popular before World War 2 (and still virulently alive in Eastern Europe). The Hitlerites and other anti-semites used to explain that both communism and finance capital - those seemingly implacable enemies - were really different aspects of a single worid conspiracy, coordinated by the "Elders of Zion' and directed against the German nation, against 'Christian civilisation' , or whatever.
Centre Likewise the Newsline editorial portrayed 'the centre' of Thatcher's government and SO as secretly linked and bonded - against the WRP and the Libyan and Palestinian peoples - by a hidden network of "Zionists' But SO is opposed to Zionism (if that means Israeli chauvinism or Jewish exclusivism)? It supports national rights for the Palestinians? Though contemptous of Gaddafi's claims to socialism, and of much of his hollow anti-imperialism, SO would defend Libya against an imperialist invasion? Why, all that is just a front, a mere sham division of labour among the conspirators.
Didn't the pre-war communists pretend to denounce finance capital and the finance-capital police shoot Line communists in pre-war Germany? It's heard shout the international Jewish conspiracy.
You could object. Isn't the asserted common thread political Zionism? Isn't it a case of making Israel and hostility or friendliness to Israel the measure of all things? Isn't it a matter of starting with the Arab-chauvinist picture of Israel and reading everything off negatively from that?
No: Zionism here is not a political reference. Today "Zionism' commonly means pro-Israeli sentiment of one sort or another. It includes the overwhelming majority of the people of Britain. If political Zionism is the point, then adding a Zionist Jew to the cabinet is to add nothing, as all the cabinet members are Zionists anyway!
There are Zionists and Zionists: there are Zionists and there are Jews. Plainly it is the Jews who are the core conspirators and who make up the special Zionist connections' The implication is inescapably this: that even anti-Zionist Jews like the SO writers the Newsline writer had in mind will have ineradicable loyalties and allegiances more basic than politics. These are the conspirators: some people are congenital "Zionists' whatever their (And such ideas have not all gone with Gerry Healy. In his recent long article on the history of the Fourth International Michael Banda ascribed alleged errors by the movement over Palestine in 1947-8 to the "Zionist proclivities' of Ernest Mandel. What is he talking about? There was no serious dispute in the FI on this question in 1948. Ernest Mandel played no notable part in discussing the position on Pales tine in 1947 or '48. There is no political reason to link Ernest Mandel with Zionism in 1948 or 1986 except by way of the underlying thought that he has a 'Jewish' name, therefore is - or may be, I don't know - a Jew.)
I submit that whatever Charlie Pottins may say, the charge of overt, blatant anti-semitism is one that the Healyite WRP has to answer to, and that one of the clearest examples of it is this editorial. The writer sub-consciously (I assume) found himself pencilling in the outlines of the world view enshrined in the Protocols of Zion theories'. He fills those outlines, to be sure, with fervent though incoherent and false antiimperialism'; but then the Nazis and other anti-semites used to get very angry at the crimes of capitalism - what they called, in scapegoating tashion, Jewish capitalism.
How did the WRP arrive at such a position? There are reasons peculiar to the WRP and reasons which the WRP has in common with many "Trotskyists'.
Though Healy's WRP has gone further into explicit anti-semitism than anyone else on the left - because of its leaders' paranoia and the malignant influence of the petrodollar brand of anti-Zionism, I think that the fundamental cause of this degeneracy is the mistaken position on the Middle East which the Healy WRP and the present one share with much of the left (and until recently with SO). As I'll prove below, much of the left has Arabchauvinist and not working-class politics on the question, though for good anti-imperialist reasons and from the fine impulse to champion the defeated and oppressed Palestinians.
But first let us get out of the way what was specific to Healy's WRP in generating that editorial.
From the mid-'70s or earlier the WRP saw the world and especially the international Trotskyist mainly in terms of police "conspiracies, and the operation of 'agents" and counter-agents.
Vast amounts of money and time were given over to the search for the "conspirators' and 'agents' who were seen as being at the root of all evil in the world, and whose subterranean combats and manoeuvres sometimes seemed in the WRP's eyes to have replaced the struggle of classes as the locomotive of You can find large numbers of individuals in the labour movement who will never be politically rational again after an intensive course by Mr Healy on world history and politics for the last 50 years as a spy-hunt.
Add to this paranoid view of the world Healy's financial links with Gaddafi and Iraq, etc., which put Zionism and anti-Zionism at the centre of world politics because Libyan and Iraqi gold was at the centre of Healy's surInveil, and the scenario virtually writes VIVaL.
There is more to it than that, though. There is the effect of an inbuilt Pabloite' tendency in the WRP to see the world in terms of the struggle of two basic camps.
This view arose first as the basic pattern of a world divided between the Stalinist states and the capitalist. But over the years it has shifted - and not only for the WRP - to mean imperialism and 'anti-imperialism' During the Falklands/Malvinas war most of those calling themselves Trotskyists accepted even the butcher Galtieri who ruled bourgeois (and indeed sub-imperialist) Argentina into 'our class camp' In the view of the world developed by the WRP under the influence of paranoia and petrodollars, the Palestine question came to be seen as the central pivot of this struggle of the two basic imperialist. The Arab bourgeoisies, what- CIDS 1 the imperialist and the antiever their faults' and limitations', were in the 'anti-imperialist' camp - ours.
Now if the Palestine question and "Zionism' is the pivot of this world strug gle between two basic camps, then I suppose it does make a sort of twisted sense to think that within the imperialist countries the "Zionists' ", linked by ineradicable ties to the arch-enemy, the very core of imperialism - Zionist imperialism - are the main enemy, everywhere. As we saw above, the Newsline editorial even defined London and Washington politics by their relation to israel, not the other way round. This was no slip: it tits pertectly into the picture.
In one sense therefore the world view held by the WRP - and not only by the WRP - implies and demands anti-semit-ism. What is remarkable is not the editorial but that the basic Trotskyist and socialist conditioning of Healy has kept open anti-semitism partly at bay, relying on such little mental tricks as the transparent pretence that 'the Zionists' are only a few super-villains and not most Jews.
Scan page 10
Review
----- pull-quotes -----
PAGE 8 The News Line Saturday April 9, 1983 From 'Socialist Thatcher & Reagan Street. There is no difficulty what- recent appointment of Mr Stuart
This April 9, 1983 morning... denounce it as 'the reactionary Isla- The fact is, however, that the explicit
Imperialism on principle, or seek neutral- between US imperialism and