Healthy Eating
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-04-03Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
Subscribe Readers may have seen press or TV reports on some scientific research which purported to show that potato crisps were about the healthiest food since fresh fruit and vegetables.
The author of the research - Professor Donald Naismith - of Kings College, London, did not actually state this but he certainly implied that the composition of crisps was in line with the recommendations of a report on diet and heart disease from COMA (Committee on the Medical Aspects of Food Policy).
The magazine New Scienrist took Naismith's widely publicised report seriously enough to devote an editorial to its debunking.
The COMA report, amongst others, recommends that fat should only provide about 35% of the calories in one's diet. Carbohydrate, in the form of starch, not sugar, should provide about 54%.
Naismith claims that the composition of the crisp is close to these figures. Thus, fat makes up about 37% and carbohydrate 40% of a crisp. While carbohydrate is a bit low, the fat seems to be about right.
But Naismith is talking about the percentage weight while COMA is talking about percentage calories. Fat is particularly rich in calories and in fact supplies 60% of the calories in crisps. This is nearly twice the COMA recommendation. Similarly, the carbohydrate supplies less than a third of the calories, about half of the COMA recommendations.
Crisps
Lastly, - Naismith tries to show that the fibre content of crisps, at 12%, is better even than wholemeal bread. However, relative to the calories in crisps and bread, the fibre content of crisps is only half that of bread After perpetrating this mind-bending assault on reason, Naismith then has the nerve to criticise "uninstyled nutrition educators" who are "holding to ransom the minds of the British public."
It is the educators, remember, who are trying to alert the public to the dangers of the crisps and sweets that their children shovel down their throats (not to mention the high-saturated fat, skin, bone, gristle and offal sausages and burgers that accompany them). Modern children Get SOCIALIST ORGANISER door by post.
RATES: €8.50 for 6 months. £1 Name.
Address Please send me 6/12 months' sub. I encl To: Socialist Organiser, 214 Sickert Cou Organiser no.265 April 1986
Science
are already displaying the degeneration of blood vessels that their grandparents took a lifetime to acquire.
Of his Naismith modestly says, public is to be educated in healthy eating habits, this is the kind of information they need to assist them" As New Scientist says, "Really?"
Apples
Naismith's report seems to have done quite a lot of damage already. Children I have recently spoken to told me that they had heard that crisps were better for you than apples.
Is it possible that the Prof didn't know what he was doing? That he genuinely confused percentage weight with percentage calories? Who can say?
By the way, the report was prepared for SNACMA. This sounds like an unpleasant secretion but is in fact the Snack, Nut and Crisp Manufacturers Association. Well, just fancy that!
NUCLEAR POWER, THANKS.
The pro-nuclear minority in the Labour Party is becoming more isolated. After the Scottish Labour Party Conference reaffirmed National Conference policy to halt expansion of nuclear power and phase out existing plants. the Southern, South-Western and Midlands regional conferences of the Labour Party have done the same.
The cinema and TV technicians union, ACTT, has also voted for an anti-nuclear power policy.
For a copy of the SERA/ Friends of the Earth/Greenpeace pamphlet outlining. a strategy for phasing out nuclear power, send an s.a.e. to me at Socialist Organiser. Meryl Streep