Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

[mat husband does rather in 1945. after all…]

Socialist Organiser no. 265, 3 April 1986 · scan pp. 10–11 · about 852 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

mat husband does rather in 1945. after all. Something is missing is missing at the heart of "Plenty"

Author David Hare seems to relish putting the boot into post-war Britain. His heroine, Susan Traherne, played by Meryl Streep, is at war with that society, and the words he puts into her mouth are cutting. The script is articulate and, at times, funny.

But he offers no alternative to Susan's reactions to the period - her rage, her later madness.

Solutions

Hare is a supposed left-winger. Yet the "solutions" on show here - despair and self-absorption - are hardly useful formulae for the transformation of a sick society.

The film opens and closes with scenes of the young Susan in France. The first shows her on dangerous SOE (undercover) work. In the final scene, she is gold and hopeful on a photogenic French hilltop after the defeat of the Nazis. Neither scene reveals any reasons for her involvement in the work of the Resistance. It's just a given - there is no clue to her ideals, her politics, her hopes, In other scenes, she speaks of having lived very intensely then. She never shows any reasoned political or idealistic stance that might explain her work.

In post-war Britain, she refuses to find anything to match her wartime expenBelinda Weaver reviews the film 'Plenty', now on general release.

ence. She gets ludicrously trivial jobs, tries and fails to get pregnant, marries a diplomat, changes her hairstyle -but she's grimly determined not to enjoy any of it.

She's also hell-bent on making sure no-one else is having a good time. She's good and angry, and her tongue becomes her weapon. She hardly lets up. The whole of post-war life and politics, even the Suez crisis, just becomes one big conspiracy against her finer feelings.

These finer feelings prevent her from taking any action against the "conspiracy". She is too high-minded to get involved in the grubby world of politics. But sadly, this leaves the way clear for the bad guys who don't mind dirtying, their paws. And Hare doesn't spare us some noxious examples here - one Foreign Office official is almost too coid and machinelike - he seems to have been bureaucratised from hirth.

Part of the film's failure must lie with Streep. She carries off the rudeness and the insults. But she can't show the frustration and the torment within the character, the reasons behind the barbs. She's chilling.

Charles Dance mat husband does rather better. His outbursts of exasperated love are convincing, although at times he seems almost superhumanly patient.

But because he's a diplomat, that is, "tainted" , Hare has to show him as blinkered and limited and conventional as well.

Only Tracey Ullmann, as Susan's friend, is allowed to be warm and positive. After all, she's working class. Bui Ullmann is given nothing to do beyond be warm and supportive (endlessly) to Susan. There's no scope for the character.

John Gielgud seems to be having a lot of fun with his fairly minor role. He gets some of the funniest lines to say.

Despair

The film is poisoned by despair, and by negativism. Even Lazar (Sam Neill), the lover Susan met during the war, returns only to disappoint. He too suffers from betrayed idealism - he confides that he "gave in" to "wife - suburbia - corporation" • Gave in trom what? Hare doesn't deign to say.

Did Susan and Lazar want to fight fascism? Stop the war? Or did they just want to have the romance of living dangerously, Hemingway's "walking hand in hand with life and death"? If they did sincerely want to stop war, why didn't they get involved in politics? War hardly ended 1945, after all.

Hare may feel that he doesn't need to spell things out. He possibly assumes that nis audience share a general political idealism which would applaud fighting the Nazis in groups like the SOE or the French Resistance as a. model of heroic behaviour. But many strands made up that movement - anti-fascists, socialists, patriots. By not spelling out Susan's particular motivation, her later can abstentionism.

Blurred Hare purposely keeps the issues blurred. Post-war British society is really a backdrop - it's not in focus, not part ot the story. If he brought in real issues, hed have to deal with them, develop a specific response. By leaving Susan's ideals unclear, he can avoid showing exactly how they were betrayed, and by whom.

The film ends up in a blind alley. No-one working on it seems to have known how to end it, so it peters out by going back to the youthful Susan on her hill, to underline in the most heavy-handed way how far she has travelled from her early hopes.

But Susan's hopes have a desire for a better society. In this context, Susan's revolt is really just the plaintive cry, "Life is dull".

Scan page 11

The strike has been declar ed official by the AUER and has received strong sug

----- pull-quotes -----

been shown only as a desire to live more intensely, not as

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 265

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →