Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

The Left, Israel

Socialist Organiser no. 266, 10 April 1986 · scan p. 4 · about 940 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 4

ly depenaent on capnag a suvmos ALD Dalu vu a ed population, on one side, and on the roll-history-backwards position. The other a society in which the white position is inseparable from Arab population are an exploiting caste revanchism and Arab chauvinism. submergence and helotry of a numer- that Gerry Healy's WRP was rabidly Whatever similarity ( in political- reason for this - to which Healy added military techniques there may be paranoia and the mercenary desire to between South Africa and Israel they earn Arab petrodollars - was the are radically different societies. Israel WRP's support for the destruction of was given its character by the Zionists' the Jewish state of Israel by its Arab resolute refusal to exploit Arab labour neighbour states, a psotiion which the and their drive instead to replace it. Healyite WRP and the present one Whatever one thinks of the left Zionist share with much of the left. it was the opposite of that mass the left is - though repudiating the exploitation on which modern South paranoıd ravings of a Gerry Healy -Africa was built. The exploitation of impucitly antı-semitic. will now. Arab labour from the occupied terri- substantiate and justify what I said tories since 1967 has not fundamental- about the broader "Marxist' and Trotly altered the character of Israel in this skyist' left. The news coe dadar Arl 81900) From 'Socialist This Se Organiser to morning • Thatcher & Reagan denounce it as 'the reactionary Isla-! must fight Two objectives in the slander surrounds Israel is in the grip of a resurgent Islamic fundamentalism which threatens to throw its society and culture back to the Middle Ages. The religious barbarians who rule Iran leave socialist observers little room for pretence about the consequences of resurgent Islam when it has the whip hand.

Yet socialists - or at any rate most orthodox' Trotskyists - are surprisingly reluctant even to fundamentally criticise the Islamic states and brand them as reactionary. Some of them -and not only Healy's WRP - sometimes accept some of their bourgeoisies into 'our class camp' . Much of Ernest Mandel's 'United Secretariat of the Fourth International' continues to see something "progressive' in Khomeini's Islamic revolution. Where the Iranian oppression of the Kurds is objected to, for example, the press of the section of the USFI led by the US SWP talks about 'errors' and 'mistakes' of the revolutionary regime.

The contrast with the left's attitude to Israel could not be sharper.

It is, as we shall see, often wrapped up in seemingly reasonable proposals like creating a secular democratic state in Palestine, but, put starkly, the far left's programme for Palestine is that 'Israel must be destroyed':

Now this is a unique programme: the destruction of a state and the radical alteration of the population of that state's core area (the pre-1967 Israeli borders). From this everything else follows.

S.Africa

The programme is made to appear not unique by identifying Israel with South Africa. But that is an utterly false comparison of an organic society, made up of all classes and not essentialaunlaiting a ashmarn.

dependent for what they have on the ically much bigger black population. colonists' "Jewish labour only' policy

The WE Ca Spuday Apt

An attack Readers reply torine on the party BBC witch-hurtion Bitter about lies What you can do There is certainly nians. The Zionists wel particularly upset by t role the Labour Hera played in winning t SHE OUT Labour Party to an or cial policy of support f the recognition of t rUV• The fact that smea about me are being fed the Jewish Chronicle' a fairly regular basis su Besis government of f tive in the British labo -movement and press present. respect.

But, whatever about the comparison with South Africa, don't the crimes of Israel brand it as something specially abhorrent and therefore justify the programme of destroying the Zionist state? Doesn't the fate ot the dispossessed Palestinian Arabs make any other programme than the destruction of the Jewish state inadequate if justice is to be done?

Chauvinism The proper socialist answer is no. To answer yes is to take up the goals. of Arab nationalism and chauvinism, but most of the left does answer yes. This is the dominant, all-shaping fact on the far left: that the left supports the destruction of the state of Israel - not merely its defeat in this or that battle where such defeat might be desirable on the issues, but the destruction of the core pre-1967 Jewish area as a territory where the Palestinian Jews can congregate as a compact national mass.

From that everything else follows. It only takes a twist of Gerry Healy paranoia or the touch of the petrodollar to bring up the anti-semitic logic.

Uniquely in the whole world; the left thinks that in the Israeli Jews it confronts a "bad nation' which cannot be reformed or modified, not even by its own proletariat - unless they abandon their national identity and the national territory where most of them were born - and which must be destroyed. In this unique case, unlike all the others created by the complicated and immensely tragic events of the last 40, 60, or even 80 years (and for what people were those years more tragic than for the Jews?) the left takes ctand on a hictorinal ravarcinniot In part one of this article I proved anti-semitic. I asserted that the basic It follows, therefore, that much of

----- pull-quotes -----

The money Programme An attempt to silence the left

case for suspecting -ti hand of the force opposed to the Pales

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 266

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →