Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Anti-semitism and the left, part 2. by John O'Mahony

Socialist Organiser no. 266, 10 April 1986 · scan p. 4 · about 686 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 4

WRITING soon after World War 2 (in one of the essays collected in The Non-Jewish Jew') Isaac Deutscher reported that he had found rampant anti-semitism and open hostility and contempt for the Jews among British army officers guarding Jews in the displaced persons camps of Europe.

The DPs had survived Hitler and now - Britain having forbidden Jewish migration to Palestine, and the doors being closed elsewhere too - they were told that they had to stay in or return to 'their countries of origin'. For most of them that meant return to virulently anti-semitic Poland. Their wish was to get to Palestine.

Deutscher commented that it was the tragic fate of the Jews, even after the holocaust that engulfed almost six million of them, to exist still in popular consciousness as the embodiment and personification of lucre and duty money.

Not only in popular speech, where a mean or tight person may be called and not necessarily with conscious malice) a 'Jew', will you find the Jew used as a symbol of money and capital in their dirtiest functions. You will find that even in the writings of Karl Marx, who spoke often in the brutal language of 19th century national and racial stereotypes but was surely free of anything we would call racism.

Before Hitler sections of the socialist movement too identified the Jews with money and capital, and accepted Jews - rich, poor and destitute alike -as a representative and symbol of the things they were fighting against in capitalism.

A 'socialist" anti-capitalist, antisemitism was a living current in or on the fringes of most European socialist and labour movements. 'Rothschild baiting' merged with popular Christian anti-semitism, which was often, as in Central Europe, quite fierce.

For example, faced with a Christian anti-semitic crusade, the Austrian Social Democrats - whose leader yictor Adler was a Jewish atheist - ostentatiously declared that they were neither -Jewish nation.

Socialist Organiser no. 266 10 April 1986 Page 4 anti- nor philo-semitic. Prominent ent British Labour leaders supported the 1905 Aliens Act passed in Britain to keep out Russian and Polish Jews. In the published correspondence of Frederick Engels with Karl Marx's son in law Paul Lafargue you will find Latargue expressing enthusiasm for the socialist 'potential' of the quasi-fascist and anti-semitic Boulangist movement of the late 1880s and Engels reprimanding him, affectionately but sharply.

Against this once quite important current in socialism, Engels (or was it the German socialist leader August Bebel) launched the slogan: 'Antisemitism is the socialism of idiots'.

Today this sort of anti-semitism exists widely in the far left, slightly transformed - now the Jew in his guise of 'the Zionist' has come to ambolise racism and imperialism.

Zionism

"Zionism' - which though the precise meaning of the word is no longer clear must include most Jews - has entered the consciousness of large parts of the left as another word for the worst form of imperialism and racism. Our attitude to it should be little different from our attitude to fascism. The prevalent programme on the left for dealing with it is to destroy Zionism', that is, destroy Israel.

Is this accurate? Is this reasonable?

The Israeli state has committed and commits great wrongs against the Palestinian people. Israel could only come into existence at all by displacing the Palestinian Arabs and then by defeating the various Arab armies which tried to conquer and overrun the Jews of Palestine in 1948. In the course of the 1948 war vast numbers of Palestinian Arabs fled the Jewish-occupied territory or were driven out.

Israel wound up with more of Palestine than the UN had allotted as the Jewish portion, and the UN was already generous, giving the Jewish one-third of Palestine's people much more than half its resources. And in 1949 Israel joined together with the Arab state of Transjordan (now Jordan) to divide up what was left of the territory allotted by the UN to the Palestinian Arabs.

After 1948 the Israeli state systematically robbed Palestinian Arabs within Israel of their land. Israel is a regional sub-imperialism allied to US imper-

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 266

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →