And Anti-semitism
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-04-10Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 5
Israeli chauvinism once rejected, the Middle East reality allows of only two possible or imaginable solutions to the Jewish-Arab conflict in Palestine.
Either drive the Jews out; or accept that a Jewish nation has, despite the understandable Arab resistance, come into existence, and must be accepted as having rights, in the first place the right to exist as a nation in Palestine.
The programme of driving out the lews means continuing to try to do what much of the Arab feudalists, bourgeoisie, petty bourgeoisie and working class have been united in trying to do for at least five decades. The latter option must mean compromise over the disputed territory, recompense for the Palestinian Arabs, and a comprehensive peace in which Israel's | right to exist with agreed borders (not necessarily the present ones) is not challenged militarily.
Third
At a later stage in the peaceful development of the region the inte gration of the Jewish state into a Middle East federation would be posed. Exclusivism would break down as the barriers between the formerly warring nations have partly broken down in Europe over the last four decades.
it seems to me to be no part of a socialist solution to national conflicts like that of the Jews and Arabs in Palestine to advocate the destruction of one of the warring nations. The socialist programme in such a situation is for compromise, compensation, reconciliation, But isn't there a third alternative -the secular democratic state? No, there isn't, because - as we shall see - it is unrealisable in reality and the slogan functions in politics as a propaganda auxiliary for the 'drive out the Jews"
position.
Of course the idea of solving the terrible national conflict by simply enfolding, intermeshing and merging, as equal citizens, the hostile nations munda fau tha dionitod Polectin.
ian territory is an attractive one, and all the more seductive because there is no other solution that even appears to do justice to both sides. IC left about what must inevitably follow from and is implied in the proposal to destroy the Jewish state and deprive the Palestinian Jews of national rights. Under the influence of this opiate, the most horrendous things are then proposed to be done to the Jews of Palestine - things no socialist would advocate or tolerate for any comparable grouping.
It is surrender and dissolve, or resist and deserve to be forcibly dissolved.
So the secular democratic state is not an alternative to driving the Jews out; it is treacherously barbed facet of that programme to drive the Jews out or reduce them to a vastly depleted territorial minority.
What might possibly be an attractive idea, and is certainly in the minds of many of its advocates a respectworthy ideal, has to be judged by now it fits into the whole picture, and by what function it performs in the mechanics and ideological swordplay of Middle East politics.
We have seen what role it does play. In the circumstances it could play no other role. Those who seek to avoid the real choice and try to settle for the unrealisable ideal wind up nevertheless tied to the war chariot of Arab chauvinism.
They flee from the real choices into a fantasy, and wind up nevertheless having a choice imposed on them by the logic of circumstances.
All the 'secular democratic state* evasion does it act as camouflage for the chauvinist position and, for the left, introduce a deep measure of mystification, confusion and sometimes hysteria.
Part 3 on page 8.
Socialist Organiser no. 266, 10 Apru 1980 rage a