Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Trotsky on the Jewish Question

Socialist Organiser no. 266, 10 April 1986 · scan p. 8 · about 2,326 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

Zionist movement that created Israel. Close to the very end of his life he warned that Palestine could turn out to be a giant ghetto in which the Jews. who had fled there might be trapped and massacred. Yet it is plain from the writings in a smail collection published by Pathfinder Press. 'Leon Trotsky and the Jewish Question' that the experience of anti-semitism in the 20th century. not only in Nazi Germany and Poland but also in the USSR under Stalin, had radically changed Trotsky's views.

At the end of his life he believed that the persecution of the Jews, and the effect of that persecution on the consciousness of the Jewish people. lad made the creation of some sort of Jewish state an inescapable necessity. He did not support the Palestine programme of the Zionists, or anyway not as conceived by them. But his Tain of thought is clear - he was for a Jewish state nonetheless.

In a January 1937 interview with journalists of the Jewish Telegraphic Agency and Der Weg, a Jewish paper published in Mexico. Trotsky explained: "During my youth I rather leaned toward the prognosis that the Jews of different countries would be assimilated and that the Jewish question would thus disappear in a quasi-automatic fashion.

The historical development of the last quarter of a century has not confirmed this perspective. Decaying capitalism has everywhere swung over to an exacerbated nationalism, one part of which is anti-Semitism. The Jewish question has loomed largest in the most highly developed capitalist coun try of Europe, in Germany.

On the other hand the Jews of different countries have created their press and developed the Yiddish language an instrument adapted to modern culture. One must therefore reckon with the fact that the Jewish nation will maintain itself for an entire epoch to come.

Now the nation cannot normally exist without a common territory. Zionism springs from this very idea. But the facts demonstrate us that Zionism incapable of resolving the Jewish quest conflict between the and Arabs in Palestine acquires a more and more tragic and more and more menacing character.

I do not at all believe that the Jewish question can be resolved within the framework of rotting capitalism and under the control of British imperialism.

And how, you ask me, can socialism solve this question? On this point I can but offer hypotheses.

Once socialism has become master of our planet or at least of its most important sections, it will have unimaginable resources in all domains. Human history has witnessed the epoch of great migrations on the basis of barbarism. Socialism will open the possibility of great migrations on the basis of the most developed technique and culture.

It goes without saying that what is here involved not compulsory displacements, that is, the creation of new ghettoes for certain nationalities, but displacements freely consented to, or rather demanded by certain nationalities or parts of nationalities.

The dispersed Jews who would want to be reassembled in the same community will find a sufficiently extensive and rich spot under the sun.

Socialist Organiser 266 10 April 1986 The same possibility will be opened tor the Arabs, as for all other scattered nations.

National topography will become a part of the planned economy. This is the grand historical perspective that I envisage. To work for international socialism means also to work for the solution of the Jewish question"

He went on in that interview to discuss anti-semitism in the USSR. which had been used against the Trotskyists within the degenerating Boishevik Party as early as the mid '20s. That experience must surely have been a big factor in the development of Trotsky's thinking on the Jewish question.

Eour years earlier, in 1932-3, Trotsky had discussed the 'Jewish problem' With "Class Struggle' , an American publication. He was asked:

*What is your attitude to Palestine as a possible Jewish homeland' and about a land for the Jews generally? Don't you believe that the anti-Semitism of German fascism compels a different approach to the Jewish question on the part of Communists?"

Trotsky replied:

"Both the fascist state in Germany, as well as the Arabian-Jewish struggle, bring forth new and very clear verifi cations of the principle that the Jewish question cannot be solved within the framework of capitalism.

I do not know whether Jewry will be built up again as a nation. However, there can be no doubt that the material conditions for the existence of Jewry as an independent nation could be brought about only by the proletarian revolution. There is no such thing on our planet as the idea that one has more claim to land than another.

The establishment of a territorial base for Jewry in Palestine or any other country is conceivable only with the migrations of large human masses. Only a triumphant socialism can take upon itself such tasks. It can beforeseen that it may take place either on the basis of a mutual understanding, or with the aid of a kind of international proletarian tribunal which should take up this question and solve it.

The blind alley in which German Jewry finds itself as well as the blind alley in which Zionism finds itself is inseparably bound up with the blind alley of world capitalism, as a whole. Only when the Jewish workers clearly see this interrelationship will they be forewarned against pessimism and despair"

Tragic

The tragic conflict between Arabs and Jews in Palestine would not be adjudicated by a proletarian tribunal but by the United Nations set up by the victors of World War 2 - those who had not gone out of their way to save the Jews, who had refused all but a trickle of Jews the right to enter (the USA) or ran anti-semitic regimes (the USSR) - who were, above all, concerned to secure their own in Palestine.

in the same interview Trotsky showed how far he was from the 'antiimperialism of idiots' when he answered this question.

"The official Communist Party characterised, without question, the Jewish-Arab events in 1929 in Palestine as the revolutionary uprising of the oppressed Arabian masses. What is your opinion of this policy?"

Trotsky replied: "Unfortunately, I am not thoroughly familiar with the facts to venture a definite opinion. I am now studying the question. Then it will be easier to see in what proportion and in what degree there were present those elements such as national liberationists (anti-imperialists) and reactionme that all these elements were there".

In an article on anti-Semitism in Stalin's USSR (22 February 1937) Trotsky developed his reappraisal ot the Jewish question in the light of early 20th century experience. He speaks of a future socialist version of the Zionist "methods of solving the Jewish question" methods "which under decaying capitalism have a utopian and reactionary character"

Shrug

Trotsky had commented on the evidence of USSR anti-semitism which appeared in the official USSR press and this had provoked the wrath of various 'Friends of the Soviet Union'. Trotsky responded:

"Some would-be "pundits' have even accused me of "suddenly' raising the "Jewish question' and of intending to create some kind of ghetto for the Jews. I can only shrug my shoulders in pity.

I have lived my whole life outside of Jewish circles. I have always worked in the Russian workers' movement. My native tongue is Russian. Unfortunately, I have not even learned to read Jewish. The Jewish question therefore has never occupied the centre of my attention.

But that does not mean that I have the right to be blind to the Jewish problem which exists and demands solution.

"The Friends of the USSR' are satisfied with the creation of Birobidjan [the largely fictitious autonomous Jewish republic within the USSR]. I will not stop at this point to consider whether it was built on a sound foundation, and what type of regime exists there. (Birobidjan cannot help reflecting all the vices of bureaucratic despotism).

But not a single progressive, thinking individual will object to the USSR designating a special territory for those of its citizens who feel themselves to be Jews, who use the Jewish language in preference to all other and who wish to live as a compact mass.

is this or is this not a ghetto? During the period of Soviet democracy, of completely voluntary migrations, there could be no talk about ghettoes. But the Jewish question, by the very manner in which settlements of Jews occurred, assumes an international aspect.

Are we not correct in saying that a world socialist federation would have to make possible the creation of a "Birobidjan' for those Jews who wish to have their own autonomous republic as the arena for their own culture?

It may be presumed that a socialist democracy will not resort to compulsory assimilation. It may very well be that within two or three generations the boundaries of an independent Jewish republic, as of many other national regions, will be erased. I have neither time nor desire to meditate on this. Our descendants will know better than we what to do.

[have in mind a transitional historical period when the Jewish question, as such, is still acute and demands adequate measures from a world federation of workers' states. The very same methods of solving the Jewish question which under decaying capitalism have a utopian and reactionary character (Zionism), will, under the regime of a socialist federation, take on a real and salutary meaning.

This is what I wanted to point out. How could any Marxist, or even any consistent democrat, object to this?"

Trotsky was against the Zionist project, which elsewhere he refers to as a 'tragic mirage'. He calls Birobidjan 'a bureaucratic farce'. He saw the ArabJewish conflict in Palestine 'assuming tragic proportions When he says (1932-3) *There is no such thing on our planet as the idea that one has more claim to land than another" , in the context it seems to be directed against Zionist claims. But it has application to the Arabs too.

Of course it is impossible to know in detail what Trotsky would have said once the Jewish state was established in 1948. It is plain however that there would have been no place in his thought for the anti-Zionist demonology and international conspiracy theories that dominate the left today.

Scope

Trotsky recognises the breadth and scope of the historical forces activating and threatening the Jews. He recognises that the reasonable expectation he and others had had about the assimilation of the Jewish people, and the programme on the question that they had adopted and fought for, had already been defeated by the developments of He seems to assert - speaking very loosely according to the strict Leninist/ Marxist definition of what a nation is that a Jewish nation of sorts had been created since his youth, on the cate or the secuiar aemocranc state or else' policy. "I have in mind transitional historical period when the Jewish question, as such, is still acute and demands adequate measures jron a world federation of workers statesThe Jewish people need and are entitled to such a measure because it is no longer reasonable to look to assimilation as the solution or to have anything other than supportive sympathy for Jews who cannot believe in assimilation. Trotsky finishes that article:/ "How could any Marxist, or even any consistent democrat, object to that?"

The objection, of course, is based un the fate of the Palestinian Arabs condemnation of the driving-out in 1947-8 the SATANS does not resoive anything about our attitude to the Jewish state that actualexists. For it does now exist. Most of the Jews within its borders were born There considerable proportion of their parents too. The question is what programme we now propose for Palestinian-Jewish/PalestinianArab relations, Trotsky was right that the pressure from and from the antisemites was too great to allow Zionism to be any solution to the mortal threat facing the Jews in the 1930s. The Zionist project did not and could not save the nearly six million Jews who were slaughtered in Nazi-controlled Europe. If the Nazis had got to Palestine either temporarily as outright victors Polestine would have beer second, smaller-scale Poland for the Jews. Only the socialist revolution could have averted the holocaust.

Defeated

But the revolutionary workers were defeated time after time throughout the 1930s- in Germany, Austria, France, Spain. The socialist revolution did not happen - not in time to save Europe's massacred Jews, to save the 20 million people who died in the USSR, or to prevent Germany being pulverised and partitioned and having 10 million of its people driven out of East Prussia. Not in time to stop the atom-bombing of Japan, or the expanof Stalinist totalitarianism into an area of Eastern Europe with a population of 90 million...

And history did not stop. The Zionist project continued and carved out for itself the state of Israel in tragic conflict with the Palestinian Arabs.

The reactionary-utopian' solution to the Jewish question received an immense boost from the events of the world war. The need which Trotsky reluctantly came to realise for a Jewish national territory as part of the solution to the Jewish question was now felt by the overwhelming majority of Jews. And it was made reality not in benign socialist world, after the world workers' revolution, but in world dominated by imperialism and Stalinism bv wav of bitter communa and national conflict and within the framework of a Zionist-Kremlin and then Zionist-imperialist alliance.

The Jewish state was established in a world where it was still dog eat dog. It was not the Palestinian Jews alone who decreed that in 1948 if they had not prevailed they would have gone under. That is how things work in a world dominated by capitalism and Stalinism.

Part 4 next week.

----- pull-quotes -----

ary Mohammedans and anti-Semitic pogromists. On the surface, it seems to

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 266

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →