The idiots' answer to Zionism
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-04-17Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 2 →
Reader request 5 Nov 2026 (the Sunderland Poly and UJS articles): transcribed from the scan; the machine reading had run in other pieces on the page (the end of Paul Whetton's diary and a Get organised box). "world zionist conspiracy" and "Zionist jews" as printed.
Proofed text: read against the scan word by word; spelling, punctuation and wording are as printed.
Scan page 2
During and following the debate on Soviet Jewry at NUS conference there was a lot of nasty Jew-baiting.
The President of Lancs Poly, Derek King (a Labour PPC), took a speech against the motions, (although he wanted them passed) using phrases like 'Jew lobby power' and asking why the UJS had the nerve to present the debate when their "kindred semites" oppressed the Palestinians.
The SWP got to their feet to clap this anti-semitic garbage!
Asking an SWP member why he thought it was right to bring Israel into the discussion, he replied 'It was the only time Jews were being discussed'.
SSiN denounced King which provoked the SWP to bring out a bulletin objecting to our use of "insulting phrases" like "left-wing anti-semitism".
This showed, they said, we were tied to the 'coat-tails' of the Kinnockite National Executive.
SSiN was at fault, but not in the way claimed by the SWP. In opposing the anti-semitic speech, SSiN supporters declared their opposition to Zionism: but this was irrelevant. Anti-semitism is anti-semitism, whatever you think of the Middle East conflict.
But in their desperate attempt to relate to SSiN's periphery the SWP have disgraced themselves.
By what reasoning is it right for socialists or even serious liberals to be silent about blatant anti-semitism like this? When it comes from the left? Would anyone argue that we should keep quiet about anti-black racism — from the Labour Party for instance.
It only makes sense if the SWP believe that all Jews, throughout the world, are responsible for Israel's oppression of the Palestinians. And even then it is still ridiculous because we still would defend even reactionaries from racism. Anti-semitism is the idiots' answer to Zionism.
It only makes sense if you believe that every Jew is a member of a 'guilty race' and must take the blame for oppression of the Palestinians by the Israeli state.
That linking together of all Jews is only one step away from the argument that all Jews are participants in a world zionist conspiracy.
But the SWP are not logical. They have, fortunately, retreated from their previous position of support for the banning of college Jewish Societies: now they oppose such bans. But since their basic argument has not changed, it is not clear why.
If, as the SWP say, all organised racists should be deprived of the right to speak and participate in politics and if 'Zionism equals racism', then since most members of UJS are 'organised Zionists', they should be banned according to the strict logic of the SWP's argument.
To get themselves out of this the SWP say that oppressed groups should not be "no platformed". But if they are organised racists, why not? Are the SWP excusing the "racism of Zionism" just because of anti-semitism? It wouldn't seem likely given that they are prepared to denounce SSiN for defending Zionist jews from "left wing anti-semitism". It wouldn't seem very likely either given how hard the SWP think they are. Nor do the SWP have any intention of treating Jewish Zionists sensitively; rather than argue and try to convince them that their position on the Middle East is wrong, the SWP want to 'confront' the Zionists. Not only is this absurd, it is explicitly aimed at Jews. The SWP and its co-thinkers on this question do not seek to 'confront' non-Jewish pro-Zionists in the same way.
The SWP are in a complete mess about Jews, Zionism, racism and the policy of 'no platform'.
Elaine Heffernan (SWP, NUS National Executive) ran to the Steering Committee to ask for protection when 20 UJS members went to their Tony Cliff meeting. In her own mind, it seems, Jews above anything else are Zionists, Zionists are racists, racists beat people up. So there you go.
The issue was further complicated by a Steering Committee ban on stickers saying 'Racism, Zionism, Apartheid, Fascism'. This was undemocratic as they were banned without reference to conference. SSiN supporters opposed this ban and tried to get it overturned from the floor of the conference.