Pink Ken changes
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-04-17Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
Socialist Organiser No. 267. Thursday April 17 1986 Page 4 It must say something about the state of the left that the drift to the right of former leftists sometimes, incidental ly, leads them to adopt bette politics thap they used to have before. Socialist Organiser has commented on this phenomenon, tor example, when their move to the right led careerists like Neil Kinnock to drop the 'identikit leftist' Little-England opposi tion to the EEC.
And now Pink Ken Living stone has changed his position on Zionism.
Remember that Livingstone used to talk about "Zionist' conspiracies to Gerry Healy's 'Newsline' (see last week's SO). Though he spoke on many WRP platforms for three years, he neve in the smallest degree dissociated himself from the antisemitic ravings of Healy's organisation.
But now all is changed. Last week Livingstone told a meeting at the National Union of Students conference in lackpool that he now realisLionism Tacism 2 C00 For during has years with Healy Livingstone was no hot eyed young rebel blinded by enthusiasm or anger into going alone with whatever pol tics' Healy dished up. He wa a calculating operator who balanced everything he did and said according to the advantages or disadvantages it would bring to his career.
His was a self-serving rela. tionship with the WRP -which provided the material basis for Labour Herald among other things - and with Ted Knight. As well as that, it served him well to mouth the consensus politic on the Middle East of the identikit left.
He differentiated himself from the protection of that consensus only at the point where Thatcher put him up against the gun and he had to choose between his career and defying the government. Then he gave into the government and openly broke with the left.
Probably he broke trom the left for the same reasons that he had mouthed its slogans and ideas in the first place.
Just as he once adopted ne career-indicated left-wing militical amlicuring, mor The ШИТЕ US ICE — 25 ПИТЕ D I - a newt, but a political chameleon! It so happens that the Labour Party centre politics Ken now accommodates to has a more sensible attitude to Zionism than the identikit left has.
So the former Red Ken valiantly strives to improve himself, in more senses than one! And he succeeds.
It was always highly improbable that Livingstone ever privately shared the posi tions he associated himself with and sometimes endorsed as part of his package deal with Healy and Knight. He is too urbane, too civilised a man to share in the stupid 'anti-Zionist' demonology or in the anti-semitism of Healy's WRP. The best thing about his administration at the GLC was its aggressive commitment to fight anti-black racism. It just happened to suit what he thought were his career interests to appear to go along with Healy.
Di course, in a serious sitingstone might ету росу- including gstone. But in his career so far he has shown him self to be the very type of thos much-discussed German and Central European politicians of the '30s and '40s who adapted themselves to antieye of the storm
Scan page 5
Socialist Organiser No. 267. Thursday April 17 1706 Page 5 the present attacks being made on the miners?
What is happening now in South Africa is that when the workers go on strike they feel that they are liable for dismissal and being chucked out of the industrial areas, dumped in the homelands to starve. They are employing better methods like sit-ins and occupations to fight the employers and the actions that are used by the capitalists against the strikers, especially the miners, are horrible. They are only interested in profits and not dealing with industrial issues properly and constructively.
Do you want to make any comment on the relationship between COSATU, SACTU and the ANC after the Lusaka meeting?
In COSATU we feel that there should be one union federation in South Africa and one union per industry so we are having talks with SACTU and the ANC, putting forward our policies to see how they feel about this. That is the relationship we are trying to build with the other forces that are part of the struggle.
Do you think there is any danger that the trade union struggle will be seen as a liability by those involved in the national liberation struggle? The UDF is a very wide grouping, embracing many sectors of the population, many of whom do not share the aims and objectives of the trade union movement.
I don't see any conflicts reallv in the future as COSATU made clear in its resolutions that we want to be an independent organisation but because we are part and parcel of the liberation struggle we have to work together with the progressive organisations fight for the liberation of the people. We made it clear that we would work with political organisations like UDF and even the ANC. if it comes to the crunch. We will work with any organisation that is ighting for the liberation of the oppressed masses in South Africa. In the unions some are members of the UDF, some are members of other political organisations don't see any conflict. You were talking before about community organisations. Is it the case that these organisations can be transformed into military organisations or do new organisations have to be set up altogether in the course of the struggle?
There is a civic organisation in Alexandra but it is having some problems because the youth especially felt that if it didn't deliver the goods it won't fulfill the expectations of the people of Alexandra. So they thought that they needed another organisation that would embrace all organisations in the township. We don't say: you are UDF, or you are AZAPO and that you should not be in this organisation. I wouldn't say new organisations have been set up all over, but certainly in Alexandra. We said that the civic is there and all the organisations are t want to get to build an ation that i sively, both no organisa that are in si Several mon that Islamic was very in Indian and tion there a some grip ov No comm You've meni breaking or with sit-ins, ent the m found ways sit-ins. What going to be developing struggle to ei The sit-in year with N union memb successful. L the two pla been sleepin for about tv company ap order to e succeeded. E ment was tr miss them t to occupy t mines this because of t and oxyge This isn't su the other fi tives have t other factori Are these the township Yes, they trial areas. So they are seized and h here. We don't rid of them but umbrella organiss organising maspeople who are in Ition and others ich organisations. iths back I heard : Jundamentalism wolved with the Muslim populand it was getting er them. lent, not sure. rioned the battles it in the mines etc. At the momanagement have to break those • do you think is the next step in new methods of nsure victory? s started late last 1AWU and other ers and it proved Jp to this year at ints, strikers had g in the factories vo weeks and the plied for a court vict them. This sut when manageireatening to dishey then decided the plant. In the is very difficult the lack of water n underground. ich a problem in actories. Alternao be planned in es. factories outside IS? are in the indusnot open to being eld by the workers.
No. They are far from the townships.
Could you explain the views of MAWU and COSATU on the nationalisation issue?
We believe that if you talk of nationalisation it should be linked to a particular system, i.e. under a certain control, maybe majority control -worker control of the means of production. Nationalisation under the same system is not going to be beneficial to the workers. It will benefit the bosses instead. There is a resolution from COSATU ment called the Freedom Charter which is a basic document, which is answering the basic needs of our liberation struggle. But we should have something that is going further than the basic answers given by the Freedom CharThe Freedom Charter talks about nationalisation but we should go further and talk about how and under whose control.
One of the problems, it seems to me, of the plans of the ANC if you read their plans on the economy is that the scope, pace and extent of nationalisation seems to be dependent on some agreement between a democratic government and the rest of the world to some extent. It implies an attitude to the multi-nationals and so on, What are the expectations of COSATU from a democratic government? Would you wait or would you seize the opportunity to put the industries in Uprising in Alexandra township workers hands?
We believe that the capitalists have got no claim to the wealth that is created by the workers in South Africa - all the wealth inside South Africa and outside, because sometimes you find that the multi-nationals who exploit us send the money outside the country. So they owe us a lot! The tactories, mines, etc., belong to the people of South Africa and if we take over then there is no need for negotiations: the people should take over thewhole thing.
And you expect the new government to endorse those actions by the workers?
Yes! Any government that is interested in people's needs should fight for that if it is committed to socialism. COSATU has a fairly advanced idea of its political objectives. In what way do you see its political identity developing? It has been asked, do you think it will form a party on the basis of fighting for those political objectices.
It is our belief in COSATU that forming a party would be divisive and that what should be done is that workers should form a programme which will answer the socialist feelings of the people. But one of your expectations and it zs a Jeature or COSATU, is extreme democracy throughout your organisation. Would you not expect a political party claiming to be socialist to be the same? Would you like to see the ANC develop into such a democratic organisation that ASE ARE TIBRA COSTM it gave extensive workers" it gave extensive workers control of that party? Do you control of that party? Do you think that likely? think that likely?
Yes, we would like to see Yes, we would like to see that because the ANC is our that because the ANC is our organisation in South Africa. organisation in South Africa. It has made tremendous It has made tremendous strides fighting the liberation strides fighting the liberation struggle and we therefore struggle and we therefore feel that workers should play a leading role on the struggles that are waged by the ANC, and through the programme they can formulate.
COSATU fought very strongly when it was set up for the concept of non-racial trade unionism. How does that conflict with multi-racialism?
As workers we should put forward our believes and discuss things like non-racialism. After the congress our executive met with the ANC to discuss the resolutions that we made in order that we be closer together in this for the liberation movement. With such a programme we have to discuss with all the progressive organisations so that the programme does not conflict progressive organisations. with the feelings of the other How much of the experiences of the working classes of other countries have been studied as a guide to action in That is widely discussed and that is why we are sending people to build solidarity because we would like to learn from other struggles and get the experience of what is happening in other countries. We believe we can't win our struggle without getting friends and help from other organised forces. In South Africa the capitalist class is fighting against the working class and using apartheid as a whip to suppress the people. We need all forces to come together to confront the common enemy.
How do you envisage the defeat of apartheid? Do you believe there will be a period of reconciliation between some democratic capitalism or do you think the role that the workers will play in that will take it further than just allowing any reformed or restabilised capitalism to set It will be a problem because you can't reform capitalism. It must be kicked out, removed, and a new social system introduced that is going to benefit the masses. Once you reform capitalism then you are going to have problems because America and Britain are going to benefit from that situation. At the end of the day you will have black fighting against black.
kers 1000 members of MAWU have been on strike against British Tyre and Rubber (BTR) Sarmcol in Howich since May 1985. The company - which owns, among others, Dunlops and Pretty Polly - sacked the workers who were on strike for union recognition.
Scan page 6
In a discussion paper for Socialist Organiser's AGM at the end of this month, Martin Thomas looks at the chaos of world capitalism today and the labour movement's search for an answer. The second part next week will cover the prospects for a Labour government and the state of the Labour ¡TENEMOS QUETU Socialist Party government which is pushing through ruthless job cut and trade union left.
SOURCECIS revolulions... storm swiftly from success to success On the other hand, proletarian revolutions. criticise themselves constantly, interrupt themselves continually in their own course, come back to the apparently accomplished in order to begın it afresh, deride with unmerciful thoroughness the inadequacies, weaknesses and paltriness of their first attempts, seem to thrown down their adversary only in order that he may draw new strength from the earth and rise again; more gigantic, before them, recoil ever and anon from the indefinite prodigiousness of their own aims, until a situation has been created which makes all turning back impossible (Marx)
The world's strongest labour movements, those of the advanced capitalist countries, are in retreat. In Britain, TUC membership declined 18% from its 1979 peak to mid1985. Trade union membership in the US went down 14% in 1980-4 despite a 5% increase in jobs. Other labour movements have suffered worse in Spain and France, where the main union federation, the CGT, has lost a full third of its members.
Ideologically too we have been set back. There is no clear evidence of a shift of mass opinion to the right (though racist ideas have certainly gained some ground - in France especially). Left-wing parties have more or less held their own in electoral terms through the 1980s: the EEC elections of 1984 gave the left 13 more seats than those of 1979.
The Tories' current troubles are more in line with broad international trends than was their success of 1983, when the 'Falklands Factor' had not yet worn off.
But the traditional left-wing parties, Socialist, Communist and Labour, make less and less show of anti-capitalism. In the 1930s respectable Labour leaders would talk about Enabling Acts to push through mass nationalisations; in the likewise slump-ridden 1980s, Roy Hattersley assures bankers and industrialists that he believes in "high profits" and Neil Kinnock says that re-nationalisation of what the Tories have privatised is not a ment bank is the centre of Labour's economic policy.
Spain's Socialist government has privatised, Slashed industries tormerly subsidised by the state, and removed laws from the Franco period which restrained bosses from sacking workers. France's left government embarked on full-scale austerity and job-cutting in the manner of lan MacGregor after 1983. Even Sweden's more confident Social Democrats have dabbled in privatisation.
'1945 socialism' , the mass labour movement's traditional alternative to capitalism, has collapsed. Workers are left with pure piecemeal reformism. New alternatives for transforming society will take time to emerge. But emerge they must: and in the longer term our present difficulties may be seen as a retreat which permits a better advance.
In 1945 a sort of socialism had mass support, and much even of the bourgeoisie dared not oppose it directly.
In Germany, for example, the main bourgeois party, the CDU, called for state ownership of natural resources and 'key monopoly industries' , and the elimination of large-scale capitalist enterprise.
Expanded
In France the National Council of the Resistance called for the nationalisation of 'all the great monopolised means of production worker participation in management, and comprehensive social security.
The Social-Democratic parties demanded this sort of socialism more consistently, thoroughly and sincerely: the Stalinist parties were usually less radical in immediate politics, but the USSR still gave them quasi-revolutionary credentials.
On this basis the labour movement expanded enormously. By 1947 the German Social Democracy had 875,000 members. The French and Italian CPs became the greatest political parties in their countries. In Britain between 1944 and 1948 Labour's affiliated membership rose from 2.4 million to 4.8 million, and its individual membership from 266,000 to 629,000. By 1948 Swedish Social Democracy had 636,000 members, 40% more 1984: Spanish workers fight Third World nationalist movements were also growing fast; trade union organisations were often a major part of these movements; and they proclaimed the same sort of socialism.
But this was a socialism which looked not to the self-liberation of the working class but to the improvement of workers' conditions by administrators manipulating the resources of the state. Several factors moulded it.
There was crushing, grey poverty. Working class living standards were at malnutrition level in much of continental Europe after 1945, and did not rise above the 1930s level until the mid-'50s.
There was crushing, grey poverty. Working class living standards were at malnutrition level in much of continental Europe after 1945, and did not rise above the 1930s banners of Stalin, the Webbs and JM Keynes. Keynes always made it clear that "the class war, as such, will find me on the side of the educated bourgeoisie"; but to many Labour activists the great Liberal economist's programme of "a somewhat comprehensive socialisation of investment" seemed little different from socialism.
Of course the books of Marx and Engels, Lenin and Trotsky were still available. But the Stalinist parties, for example, could combine sales of the Marxist classics with the crudest chauvinism and class collaboration. The accumulated defeats of the 1920s and '30s, the terrible experiences of the war, had set back working class culture. The living continuity of socialist thought had been to a large extent broken (and this affected even the Trotskyist minority).
An activist who joined the Marxist movement in 1895, when Engels was still alive, might still be in his or her 30s in 1914. A teenage recruit of 1917 would be an experienced activist, not yet 40 years old, in 1938. For the militants of 1938, 1917 was almost as live and recent a reference point as 1968 is for us today. Titles of papers from chat period - 'October'. ', 'Lenin's Path' — testify to a culture gap between then and now.
By 1947, 1917 was as remote as 1956 is today. The Stalinist parties had been preaching class collabora-