Labour's retreat
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-04-17Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
From page 7 n the West, women's participaion in the waged worktorce, atter declining immediately post-war, has steadily become high. Between 1951 and 1976 the proportion of married women in Britain in waged work rose from 22% to 49%. Women's employment has continued to rise in the 1980s, especially in part-time jobs.
Traditional family structures have been quite seriously eroded.
This has strengthened demands for women's equality and for sexual freedom: In a society which offers few forms of human sympathy, support and warmth outside the family, it has also helped to increase crime rates.
Not only the difficulties of the command economies, but also the Public employment* As % of workforce, 1951-81 0 % 10 20 ESS 1951 1981 government & puble corporatione -B0 +1952-82 * Organiser No. 267. Thursday April 1 fragmentation of Stalinism, has contributed to the decay of '1945 socialism' . Meanwhile social democracy made its peace with the 'mixed economy'. . In 1959 the German Social Democracy formally renounced Marx, accepted the 'social market economy' , defined itself as a 'people's' rather than a workers' party, and changed the colour of its party membership cards from red to blue. Membership of the workers parties mostly fell over the '50s and '60s, though it would rise again after 1968.
In the last few years this gradual undermining of '1945 socialism' seems to have reached the point of qualitative collapse. And in most of the advanced capitalist countries, as we have seen, the biggest shifts have been to the right.
Radicalism has been re-defined as the business of handing out bits of patronage and power to various badly-off groups. This concept of the 'enabling' state, 'empowering' people, can be made to sound like a fresh alternative to welfare statecapitalism. In fact it is deeply elitist and manipulative, and it necessarily substitutes piecemeal interest-group lobbying for reform in place of collective working class action for change.
But there are other current and possibilities besides a drift to the right. The focus on women's, black and lesbian/gay demands, even if it is used cynically, has some progressive content. The soft left's stress on a European dimension may be 20G used to beat down traditional left programmes in favour of closer accommodation to capitalism, but it also educates the movement in important realities.
In future struggles the positive tendencies, at present very subsidlary, could come to the fore in a rapid radicalisation.
And in some Third World countires the shift away from '1945 socialism' is to the left. It is a shift away from subordination to nationalism and populism, towards independent working class politics. The Brazilian Workers' Party and the non-racial trade unions in South Africa are the best examples.
As in the late 19th century the German labour movement rose on the shoulders of the English and French, and in the early 20th century the Russian on the shoulders of the German, so in the late 20th century some Third World labour movements have picked up on the best ideas of the metropolitan labour movements and gone out in front.
1945 socialism' was never our socialism, and its eclipse is not our eclipse. Marxism never advocated a national command economy, with more or less of parliamentary control, as our alternative to capitalism. Many things are essential to working class socialism which appear little or not at all in '1945 socialism'.
*The socialisation of housework and the liberation of women.
*A radical reduction working week and a great expansion of education.
*Not only workers' control in the workplaces, but the revolutionary dismantling of the present state machine and its replacement by a democracy of workers' councils, based on delegates recallable at any time, no official secrecy and no bureaucratic privileges.
*International integration, going forward from what has been achieved by capitalism rather than backwards to isolated national economies.
Public ownership is essential to our socialism, as much if not more as to '1945 socialism' - but in the sense defined by Poland's "Workers' Opposition'.
"The indispensable precondition for the liberation of the working class is for it to lay the economic foundations of its liberty, that is, the socialisation. in the framework of a system of workers' selfmanagement, of the means of production that are today statised. It is in this way that the working class will obtain the material guarantee of realising its interests, as well as the legitimate interests of the other groups in society.
*The aim of the revolutionary workers movement, flowing from the essence of the social relations against which it rebels, is not the reprivatisation of state property or giving it autonomy but to genuinely socialise it". state governments who save a lot of it to Western consumers and capitalists, who spend much more of it. It therefore boosts world demand.
However, it may not be as. simple as that. For capitalism to prosper, enormous complex chains of transactions have to mesh together exactly. A crisis can be caused by the breaking of just one sufficiently important link in the chain.
Suppose, for example, a low oil price makes Mexico and Nigeria default on their debts. That could ruin some of London's or New York's big banks. Those banks? creditors are hit in turn. International investors decide to pull their funds out of London, or New York. Panic spreads For certain there are a lot of unstable structures ready toppled by any major panic.
The relatively stable and steady expansion of the world economy up to the late '60s was based on the dollar as the medium of world trade, backed up by the huge economic power of the US. That system collapsed 1968-71 under the pressure of the huge flow of dollars out of the US, accentuated by the Vietnam war. The US stopped guaranteeing the dollar with gold and fixed exchange rates between currencies were abandoned, The hard nuts-and-bolts economic basis of the old system had faded away. The US was still by far the world's biggest economy, but it no longer had former absolute dominance. By the early 70s it had been overtaken by West Germany as a manufacturing exporter; by the early '80s by Japan. Its proBecause of pressure on space this week we have had to hold over the third instalment of John O'Mahony!! series on "The Left, Israel, and