Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Morris strike

Socialist Organiser no. 267, 17 April 1986 · scan p. 11 · about 1,585 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 11

McCalman The people appointed by the Scottish Secretary of State, Malcolm Rifkind, to the Committee of Inquiry into Scottish teachers' pay can only intensify teachers' fears as to its outcome.

The five members include an anti-strike headteacher, a retiring official from Lothian | Regional Council, notorious for its antiteacher attitudes, a retired chairman of Boots the Chemists and a member of the board of directors of William Low and Son, a company which insists on selling South African produce.

Clearly teachers must be on their guard. The best way to prepare is by maintaining the present curriculum development boycott and work to contract, paying the monthly levy and preparing for renewed strike action in the event of the inquiry's recommendations proving unacceptable.

These are the official policies of the main Scottish teachers' union, the EIS and we must ensure that they are enforced.

Twice over the past two years there were opportunities for the EIS, which commands the support of 80% of Scottish teachers, to move away from the demand for an Independent Pay Review and go for a straight claim.

In April 1985 supporters of Campaign for a Fighting Union (CAFU) moved at Council for a 15% interim claim and were defeated. In February of this year we arged for a 30% two year deal and secured the votes of a third of Council members.

But the majority of the leadership and membership were not to be deflected from the Review position.

Rifkind, anxious to avoid disruption of the SCE exams and eager to recoup Tory fortunes in Scotland, cleverly took the initiative after two years disruption in the schools and announced a Committee of Inquiry. The terms of the Inquiry were, however, clearly loaded with specific reference in the remit to teachers' contracts of employment and to cash limits on any recommendations.

When these terms were announced on Thursday 6 March the majority of the National Executive of the EIS appeared to reject them as unacceptable. Yet within 24 hours they unanimously voted to give evidence to the Inquiry.

What had happened in the course of that Friday to change their position? The reason given was that Rifkind had clarified his position to negotiators and removed misgivings, especially on the cash limits isue. Actually, when seen in cold print, his "concessions" amount to very little.

What did sway the Executive was the barrage of "congratulations" on "the teachers' victory" in the media and from trade union and Labour leaders, such as Donald Dewar.

On top of this was the consideration that a wages offer would obviously soon follow acceptance of participation in the Inquiry Scottish teachers had campaigned for two years and foregone an inciease for 1985/6. Would they have been willing to have gone into a third year of campaigning without an increase for 1986/7 That was a course which the Executive was not willing to risk taking.

Certainly rejection of the Inquiry and the subsequent offer of almost 15% (7% from April 1985, 2% from January 1986 and 5% from April 1986) would have presented the union with immense difficulties in carrying the membership with them. Yet it was the course that they should have taken, arguing hard for non-participation in the Inquiry on the grounds of its loaded terms of reference.

Norman Bissell, a leading figure in the EIS in Lanarkshire broke ranks and argued for a "No vote in the pay ballot. Three other epresentative of the CAPU supporters, decided to tol- erious left on the Executive CArU supporters, decided to tollow the logic of their vote for participation in the Inquiry and supSeriously, of course, few will lament the departure of this wretched trash from the trade C1,51 Rick Matthews (IFL). ported a "Yes' recommendation in the ballot. Other CAFU supporters disagreed and campaigned for a negative result.

By then, however, the leadership had created a momentum for acceptance and there was an 89% vote, despite the fact that the settlement goes against the EIS policy of putting more money on the basic scales.

At the Special Council meeting of 21 March those on the left arguing to pull out of the Inquiry were overwhelmingly defeated.

Jimmy Ross, writing in Socialist Worker of 22 March, blames the decision to participate in the Inquiry on an undue emphasis upon winning public support for the campaign, at the expense of more strike action. That is certainly a fair criticism of the campaign.

Yet there are obviously differences between workers in an industry who are trying to bring the management to heel by halting production and teachers whose actions can only hurt the election, in May, of a fighting SE consumers". , pupils and parents, and whose strategy must involve applying sufficient pressure on the government to secure a settlement. Certainly more discussion is needed on the left as to the implications of these differences for future industrial action for teacherS.

The other main strand of Jimmy's analysis is to claim that the vote of the three CAFU supporters on the Executive was brought about by "the strategy of many on the left of concentrating on winning positions on important committees."

Yet Jimmy is well aware that CAPU supporters have never negiected building a base at school level through holding reps' positions, organising local reps' meetings and openly campaigning for intensified strike action and on wider issues such as South Africa, the miners' strike, gender equality etc.

Over the years since 1982 we have tried to combine this with a principled and open fight for posimember with his role as a reference librarian working tions at all levels in the union.

In the meantime Jimmy and his comrades in the SWP chose to withdraw from competition for official positions in the union, arguing that a "downturn" in industrial militancy necessitated this course of action. Over the past year they have, however, reversed this course and now try to become CAFU-endorsed candidates.

This background has been drawn not in order to score points at the expense of the SWP but to set the record straight in order to make a correct assessment of the situation. The effort achieve a balance between building a militant base at schooi! factory/office level and securing positions in the official structures will remain a central dilemma for socialists in the unions and one of which we are well aware in CAFU.

Clearly there are grave dangers facing teachers throughout the UK. Rifkind will be watching the outcome of the ACAS talks as regaras England and Wales in determining the outcome in Scotland.

Pressures will be applied to the Committee of Inquiry to ensure that it comes up with an offer which, in return for extra cash, will tie teachers to compulsory, unpaid curricular development and other such changes sought by government and local authority management.

Those on the serious left who voted to go to the Inquiry did so for tactical reasons, believing that we had to catch our breath so as to fight again when the Inquiry reports. Others on the Executive, however, did so in order to permanently demobilise the campaign. They will be prepared to jump at whatever the Inquiry offers and to sell it to the membership Activists in both the EIS and the NUT will have their hands full between now and September warning and preparing teachers for the prospect of renewed strike action in the autumn.

In any case library NALGO members will be meeting again on Monday 21 tory strike in Glasgow only weeks away, the Furniture and Allied Trades (FTAT) has called an open ing to discuss how to step up port for the strike.

The dispute began un last year when an overwh majority voted in favour of in, trial action to win trade recognition and restoration 39 hour working week, with the national agreemen minimum conditions betwe employers and the union in ti furniture industry.

On Friday 24 March 29 of ti workforce clocked out after 3 hours, refusing to work the add tional 2¼ hours demanded b management. The following da all 29, including nine apprentice were sacked.

Other workers who refused t cross their picket lines were als sacked Morris has taken a hard lin in the dispute. The factory owne has refused to meet ACAS or eve the secretary of the employer federation in the furniture indus [try. Furniture has been importe from abroad and re-labelled a "Morris" in the Glasgow factor in order to maintain supplies t furniture stores.

When the City Council organ ised a civi reception for the Morr strikers, management bussed th scabs down to the City Chamber to picket the event and conducter a letter-writing campaign in th •local press. Pickets have bee physically attacked by scabs out side the factory.

The factory has been pickete throughout the last elever months. The strike has been de clared official by FTAT from th outset. And, at least in terms o financial support, the dispute ha been supported by the broade: labour movement.

But Morris is still able to con tinue with its operations. The main problems in the dispute are:

*Drivers, including TGWL members, crossing picket lines to make deliveries to Morris';

*The lack of support from workers (in the TGWU) at the second Morris factory, in Camp sie, near Lennoxtown;

*Morris' success in importing furniture and wood through the docks;

*The lack of impact of picketing on the scabs, despite the per

----- pull-quotes -----

socialist leadership for CPSA. TEDE JAMUNS

On start of the Moms fondl d

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 267

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →