Long may she re
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-04-24Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 2 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 2
A loyal address on the occasion of Her Majesty's 60th Birthday, issued jointly by Socialist Organiser, Marxism Today and the Tribune.
It is widely assumed that socialists are automatically opposed to the monarchy and in favour of a Republic. In view of the current celebrations of Her Majesty the Queen's 60th birthday, and the forthcoming wedding of Prince Andrew to Sarah Ferguson, we would like to take issue with the left wing "common wisdom' The monarchy in fact is an entirely incidental feature of the British state. The call for the abolition of the monarchy rests on the assumption that the replacement of the Queen, or a future King, by a President, would make the slightest bit of difference to the working class in Britain and internationally. This is a demonstrably false assumption. Can anyone seriously suggest that President Reagan is preferable to the Queen? Would any of our 'socialist' Republicans like to argue that President Mitterrand in France has served the French workers better than Queen Elizabeth has served workers in Britain? Or President Gorbachev perhaps, another of the miserable born - again upstarts who strangle workers' the movement in Stalinist the states?
It must be clear even to the crassest text book "Trotskyist' that each and every President that you care to mention the world over is very considerably worse than the British monarchy.
To call for the abolition of the monarchy is thus to sow the most grotesque illusions in the 'Republican' bourgeoisie, On the contrary, socialists should be the staunchest defenders of the monarchy.
The ruling class in Britain has proved able to manipulate the monarchy for its own ends ever since William of Orange in 1688. Ever since then, the Crown has been subiect to the control of the bourgeoisie. But this is entirely the result of historically conditioned class forces.
It would be form of fatalism that the labour Socialist Organiser no. 268 24 April 198 the worst to believe movement
gm
could not alter this balance of class forces and so wrest the monarchy from the control of the bourgeoisie.
Indeed we have a duty to do so. One of the ruling class's greatest strengths and the product of its historical kidnap of the Crown - is that it is able to portray the Left as the enemies of the Queen. The extent to which the ruling class can do this is a disaster for the Left.
We need to contest that terrain with the bourgeoisie and prove to the working class that it is we and not the bourgeoisie, who are the real monarchists, Doom For socialists to stand in opposition to the monarchy is to doom us to irrelevance; and to destroy any hope of ever seeing socialism in Britain. But we should not merely give support to the monarchy out of opportunist tactical considerations. Nor should we abandon our commitment to the Crown after capitalism has been overthrown. Indeed, the Queen, or a future King, will be an invaluable ally of any post-revolutionary government. Look at the benefits Ken Livingstone got from inviting the Queen to open the Thames Barrier. Not only will the preservation of the monarchy help secure the popularity of the workers' government: there are sound economic considerations too.
A common argumentof the Republican left is that the monarchy is waste of money. But is it? In reality, the Queen and the rest of her family attract literally millions of pounds to these islands in the tourist trade. The economic advantages, which are in fact incalculable, far outweight the costs.
Surely a socialist Britain will need to continue attracting rich foreigners to Britain to spend their money here? And surely, our Queen in one of our maior attractions on this score.
In place of crude, kneejerk Republicanism, therefore, the Left needs a far more radical strategy. Rather than 'abolish the monarchy'