[The US attacked Libya in the traditional style…]
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-04-24Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 3
The US attacked Libya in the traditional style of brutal, bloody, arrogant imperialism. This was a savage act of superpower aggression in which the most powerful nation on earth attempted to flatten a small weak country of 3½ million.
The attitude of socialists towards such actions is one of outright opposition and implac able hostility to the US aggressors and to their Tory accomplices. We are opposed to all forms of domination of the weak by the strong and powerful. We are opposed to all political and military actions that deny or try to deny national rights. We are opposed in all conditions to the bombing of civilians. Against Reagan's air force, marines, army, or navy we are on the side of Libya.
But for many on the left this isn't enough. They feel that Reagan's attack obliged them to give political support to the military and Islamic Libyan police state headed by Muammar Qaddafi.
Take the Workers Press section of the WRP, for example. They have had to rethink a great deal since their split with Gerry Healy. We can be sure that, unlike Healy, they don't get money from Libya. Their support for the Libyan Jamahurriya is a little more moderate in tone than Healy's grovelling. But still, they sent Qaddafi a letter expressing their solidarity, and printed on their front page (Workers' Press, 19 April). It begins: "Dear Comrade," and ends "with warmest fraternal greeings.
Revolution
They call not merely for the defence of Libya but for the defence of the "Libyan revolution" - that is of the Islamic police state leading the 'revolution' what else can it be?
Qaddafi is still viewed as a revolutionary leader, even by those who have broken Healy's mercenary ties to Qaddafi. This is the deepest "Pabloite" confusion.
Worse still, Socialist Action, whose headlong drift into mainstream Stalinism continues, published attempts to argue on a basis of positive support for the regime in Libya, arguments which are typical of the attitudes of many on the would-be Trotskyist left.
Why did Reagan attack Libya? "The real reason for Washington's continued assault on Libya" , SA explains " (is) the fact that Libya follows policies that are opposed on many issues to those of US imperialism." (SA, 18 April). And even more forthrightly: "Qaddafi also opposed imperialist domination in the Middle East and North Africa. For instance he has backed forces in Chad that are fighting the French dominated government there." Indeed, after Oaddafi's seizure of power in 1969, "the main beneficiaries were the workers, peasants and sections of the middle class' But the Libyan revolution was not a radical revolution in the style of the Sandinista revolution in Nicaragua. Qaddafi came to power via a military coup; and his regime is consciously modelled on the moderate state capitalist regime of Nasser in Egypt. It is a military regime, dominated by a small cabal at the top levels of the state, with all manner of pseudo-democratic 'popular revolutionary' paraphenalia to camouflage where real power lies.
As in Nasser's Egypt, there has been a good deal of social levelling - old ruling layers around the monarchy have been rooted out, and so on. And Libya's considerable oil wealth has enabled the regime to raise the standard of living of the average Libyan.
Bureaucrats
But to argue that the 'main beneficiaries' have been workers, peasants and sections of the middle class is ridiculous. The main beneficiaries have been the top level bueaucrats who run the Libyan state. The fortunes amassed from Libyan oil have not been mainly by workers or peasants. There is a wealthy capitalist class in Libya protected by the state, itself enlarged and enhanced from the hiterto vast income from oil exports.
This state it is true has been aggressively nationalistic in regional affairs. It is aggressively Islamic, too. Qaddafi is notorious in the West for the backing that he has given to "terrorists' of various sorts.
I'M NOT at all surprised at Reagan's attack on Libya. I'm surprised that Thatcher went so far as to give him permisBut aggressive nationalism is not necessarily 'anti-imperialism'. As Socialist Action note, his deal with King Hassan of Morocco resulted in a severe set back for the Polisario freedom fighters in the Western Sahara that Qaddafi had previously backed.
More than that. Until well into the '70s Qaddafi was considered their man by the CIA. They helped him survive and they trained the original network of operators used by Qaddafi in his international adventures. Qaddafi's 'anti-communism' was seen by the CIA as a great asset - for example in 1971 Qaddafi forced down a plane in which were fleeing the leaders of the Sudanese CP after a failed coup. He then handed the CP leaders over to Numeiri who hanged them.
And Qaddafi's support for the Palestinians has been a mixed blessing. Of course, like every Arab leader, Qaddafi is loud in his opposition to Israel. But noises in this direction are largely weapons in inter-Arab power Qaddafi now gives his financial support to factions outside the mainstream Palestinian resistance, indeed to the most chauvinistic and ultra-nationalist groups like Abu Nidal's group, notorious for its assassinations of rival Palestinian nationalists.
The method of struggle given most support by Qaddafi is that of bomb attacks on civilians, like the recent attack in Berlin. There is nothing 'anti-imperialist' in such action. The narrow-minded nationalism that cannot distinguish between US imperialism and US citizens at airports, discoteques and so on, is reactionary chauvinism - in many cases it is also Islamic cultural and religious chauvinism.
I think that the commitment from Labour to get rid of nuclear bases has got to be underlined, and that we have got to have hard and fast guarantees that, come the Labour government, they will go.
We'll have to watch Kinnock - watch the new Labour administration - and if there is any attempt to duck or bob or swerve, then we've got to come down on his head like a ton of bricks.
I think the printworkers have got to be careful. Having committed themselves and got this far, they want to go Ilat out tor victory.
Commitment from miners to printworkers is there without question. It needs to be mobilised into solid support by getting miners down on the picket lines. I'm sure that if the call comes out many miners will willingly go there.
We've heard Peter Heathfield and Arthur Scargill urge miners with their banners to be down on the picket lines.
On 1 May we're in the courts on several issues. One of them is the National Reference Tribunal ruling on recognition of the NUM in Notts. I'm not putting any faith in the courts, but I'm hoping that the whole issue is going to get raised at that level.
diary My own tribunal on my sacking is, I'm told, sometime in the middle of June, and we're hoping that is going to raise the issue about branch officials being allowed to carry out branch duties in the Nottinghamshire coalfield.
Once we take those steps, then I think we're really going to nail the UDM for once and for all. chauvinism rather than imperialism.
Qaddafi's purpose has been to manipulate internal disputes in the Palestinian Resistance for his own ends: that is for the interests of the Libyan regime, rather than the interests of th Palestinian people.
Qaddafi's helpful suggestion to the PLO fighters trapped in the Israeli siege of Beirut in 1982 was typical: he called upon them all to commit suicide in an anti-imperialist gesture.
Chad Libya's activity in Chad, which SA refer to, was not to "fight French imperialism". It was to seize territory for Libya. The reality behind the 'anti-imperialist' rhetoric was the aggrandisement of the Libyan state.
Libya is not a genuinely progressive force internationally. More than that and worse for those socialists with a hankering to see Libya in a yood light, it is extremely undemocratic internally: a military police state. There are no independent trade unions, no free workers' organisations; indeed there is no right to assembly or freedom of speech outside of the so-called 'people's organisations. Qaddafi is brutal in his repression of political opponents - and not all of these are merely monarchists.
Qaddafi is a maverick irritant to US policy in the region, but he is hardly a serious threat.
The underlying reasons for the US attack lie elsewhere. At the same time as Reagan is mounting assaults on Libya, he is having difficulty winning support for his aggressive policy in Central America. Whipping up hostility to Qaddafi can help build support for a wider, jingoistic militarism towards 'troublesome" "pro-Soviet' regimes in the Third World.
Nationalistic support for a heavy policy towards Qaddafi can pave the way for a heavier policy towards Nicaragua.
Palestine
Indeed, even representatives of the American ruling class have objected that Reagan is so motivated by internal political considerations - i.e. getting his way in Congress in future - that he has sacrificed long term US interests in the Middle East.. This view is shared by pro-US British paliticians like Denis Healey.
Palestine does lie at the root of the problem in an important sense. Terroristic attacks by Palestinian groups will probably continue until real progress is made towards fulfilling Palestinian demands for their own state. The heart of the problem of this terrorism is the monstrous injustice that has been done to the Palestinian people.
Socialists should fight imperialism - and we should defend Libya from imperialist attack.
But we should also tell the truth about the world as it really is. The knee-jerk 'antiimperialism' of Socialist Action and others like them in fact leads them to tell lies - in the first place probably to themselves - about Qaddafi, and to give political credit where none is due.
*For the defence of Libya against Reagan and Thatcher - Yes!
*For Qaddafi's police-state, Islamic-chauvinist regime - No!
One other thing: we ought to comment on the Queen's Birthday. I'm absolutely sick and tired of it.
Throughout the problems that we've been having, people have been pointing the finger at Thatcher, but they want to remember that every time that the police go steaming in, and every act that hatcher has done, has been done in the name of the Crown.
Elizabeth Windsor is just as much responsible for the activities that have affected working-class lives as Margaret Thatcher is. 60 years is a nice birthday when you're in that position, but many working-class people dread the thought of approaching 60 because of the fact that they're not going to be able to maintain any sort of decent standard of living. That underlines the vast gulf between the classes in this country.
Socialist Organiser N0.268 24 April 1986