Unfair to Pink Ken
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-04-24Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
have totally abolished the penalty when the state of New South Wales joined the rest of the country in aboliAccording to a report in Workers Press, Jean Van Heigenoort, Trotsky's principal secretary for most of the 1930s, has been murdered in France. Apparently, he was shot by his wife who then turned the gun on herself. He was 76.
For seven years Van Heigenoort shared Trotsky's personal fate, joining him first in the early "30s when he was in exile on the Turkish tions". . Three people were shot after being convicted holding "dance and sex parties".
island of Prinkipo.
In the early '40s, based in New York, Van Heigenoort was an important leader of the Trotskyist movement under the nom de guerre "Logan"
In the mid '40s he moved away from what was to become mainstream Trotskyism - led by Cannon, Pablo, and Mandel. Among other things he insisted against them that the USSR's postahead in the opinion polls. Many of the voters may even think it a positive war expansion into Eastern Europe, Iran (until 1946), and North Korea was imper ialism. He wrote about the emergence of "bureaucratic imperialism" . But he soon abandoned revolutionary politics and spent the last three decades in France as a professor of philosophy. In the "70s he brought out a book containing his memorie!
of Trotsky. Vietnamese or Cambodians and been tried and hanged as a war criminal? Think what a loss to international statesmanship, to diplomacy, to the higher academia that would have been!
But we do things better nowadays. Perhaps because we have the UN. Not only ( the UN give Waldheim a jot it still preserves a seat for P Pot, the Cambodian Hitler, another candidate for the hangman's rope in the bad old days.
If I were an Austrian Kurt would get my vote, that's for sure.
Henry Kissinger Capital punishment for Labour's left and the critics of Pink Ken? *The left hasn't been marginalised, it's marginalised itself. The left could have been the driving force, but in the after. math of '83 they're looking for traitors and betrayals, someone to blame.
They've revelled in being unacceptable and repellant. If I went on telly now and said Kinnock's a scab and Healey should be deselected, everyone in London Labour Briefing would give me a big kiss, and it would no doubt knock two or three points ofi our standing in the polls. Can you imagine what Lenin or Mao would have done with those sort of self-indulgent creatures? Killed them. And whilst I'm opposed to capital punishment I can see why."
Ken Livingstone, in an interview in City Limits 3 April 1986 We love you too, Ken. Last week's SO (no. 267) carried an article on Red Ken Livingstone that I feel went a bit over the top. The author of the article Pink Ken changes' in the 'Graffiti' column compared him to Konrad Adenauer 'who made a good career as the Catholic mahor of Cologn under the Nazis and lived to be Germany's post war liberal democratic' Chancellor'.
The basis for this charge is Livingstone's opportunism on the issue of Zionism: he will do what he has to to further his career.
I certainly have no sympathy for Livingstone. And I applaud SO's break with the anti-imperialism of idiots -the crude, latently, potentially and sometimes actually anti-semitic logic to much of what has passed as anti-Zionism. People like Livingstone, who have indulged in 'world Zionist conspiracy' arguments, deserve to have their faces rubbed in the dirt.
But however crass, careeris, he is not a Nazi nor a ist, and oftensive Livingstone Nazi collaborator.
Such charges are very serious and should never be made lightly. The imagery of the Second World War does much to obscure issues, and the endless desire of socialists to call their opponents 'Nazis' is deeply unhealthy. It is to substitute name calling for political argument.
Edward Ellis, Deptford ReplyEdward has simply hold of the wrong end of the stick here. The graffiti piece didn't say Livingstone is a 'Nazi" , or an anti-semite. It said, precisely the opposite -that he is not an anti-semite and that he was not deluded into sincerely believing the anti-semite ravings of Gerry Healy, which he associated himself with and publicly endorsed. That's the point! He went along with it because he thought it was to his advantage to do so. He was the man who "didn't notice" the "normal philistine citizen" with no convictions of his own who says what is expected of him (as when he chattily told Healy's Newsline yes, the BBC's allegations that the WRP gets Libyan money does look like a Zionist job on the WRP') and who tolerates anything from those people he expects benefit or favour from. And who can switch his line as casually as he changes his shirt when he things that it's to his advantage.
Konrad Adenauer was no Nazi. He was one of a vast number who tolerated and went along with the Hitler regime when it was in his interest to do so - and then became a new-fledged postwar democrat when it was in his interest to do that. The point is that such people made the crimes of the Nazis possible either by their collaboration or by their passivity. Of course the Konrad Adenauers risked getting shot or jailed. What did Livingstone risk?
Scan page 5
Thatcher and Fitzgerald sign the deal. Photo: Derek Spiers, Report. The Six County Protestant revolt against the Anglo-Irish Agreement increasingly tends to become revolt against British rule itself. The Logic of this revolt points inescapably towares the separation of "Protestant Ulster" from Britain - that is towards some sort of independence for Northern Ireland, or part of it.
The lega Protestant paramilitary organisation, The UDA, advocates an independent Northern Ireland to be achieved by way of negotiation. (So did Tony Benn in article in the Guardian in 1983). How serious a prospect is an independent Northern Ireland?
In this excerpt from a forthcoming pamphlet on Northern Ireland after the Anglo-Irish Agreement John O'Mahony discusses the politics and economics of an independent Northern Ireland and discusses what likelihood there is of an Orange attempt to win independence.
John Hume and others warned in the House of Commons debate that the logical end of the road down which the Unionists' refusal to accept Parliament's endorsement of the Hillsborough agreement propels them 1s a Unilateral Declaratin of Independence or anyway some form of an independent Northern Ireland. But reports based on the experience of election Canvassers in the referendum' suggest that only a small minority of Protestants support an independent Northern Ireland. Most are thoroughly alarmed by the idea. An opinion poll published in February showed only 18% of Northern opponents of Hillsborough supporting independent Northern Ireland.
The present Six Counties entity would split apart if it Were independent' An independent Protestant state of north-east Ulster could