Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

[The first part of this discussion paper for…]

Socialist Organiser no. 268, 24 April 1986 · scan p. 6 · about 819 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 6

The first part of this discussion paper for SO's AGM appeared last week. It looked at i same time, however, we (and the chaos of world capitalism and the labour movement's search for an answer.

This week Martin Thomas discusses the prospects for a Labour government in Britain and the state of the left. The last Labour government, 19749, started off with some quite significant concessions to the working class and a big wages surge. In summer 1975 it put the gears into reverse and imposed wage controls. In early 1976 these were followed by public spending cuts, enforced as part of an agreement with the International Monetary Fund. Dennis Healey as Chancellor pioneered monetarism.

According to Labour's present leaders, the mistake was not the crackdown in 1975-6 but the concessions in 1974-5. They want to start the next Labour government off from the point that Wilson and Healey reached in summer 1975 -or that Mitterrand reached in early 1983. Roy Hattersley condemns the "old days when we were weakminded" and reinforces the point by bemoaning the "over-ambitious" initial policy of France's left government after 1981.

France's experience tells us the probable consequences of such an approach: demoralisation in the working class, increased unemployment and poverty, recruits for the extreme right and for racism. The policy of being 'moderate' to win the next general election at all costs may well not win the election (why vote for a second-rate SDP when you can vote for the real thing?) -but in any case it will pave the way for a disaster for the labour movement at the next turn. It is utterly and ruinously short-sighted.

These facts mean that the Marxist left has two unavoidable duties.

*Labour's leaders see that their traditional policy of '1945 socialism' has collapsed - and opt instead for capitalism with accompanying music by Billy Bragg. We must explain the working class socialist alternative. We must try to make the broader left lift its vision beyond immediate campaigns, and to tackle the job of debating and advocating a new system of society.

*We must try to prepare workers for the inevitably necessary fight against a Kinnock/Hattersley government, so that this fight can be carried through successtully and without demoralisation.

The current low level of confidence among workers, and the strong feeling that nothing much matters Except getting rid of the Tories, will make it difficult to get these arguments heard beyond a minority. That minority is very important. At that minority, so far as we influence it) must try to relate to the broader majority of workers.

We must work for a Labour (and against any coalition). We must fight to make the Labour leaders keep their remaining progressive promises.

For the present, whether we like it or not, politics is largely parliamentary politics; and if working Class people give up on politics, demoralised, then the Tories will 'have their way and things will get worse and worse.

A Labour government is subject to the pressure of organised working class opinion through the Labour Party and trade unions. Out of a fight to get a Labour government, together with the debate and discussion within the labour movement about Labour policies, can come a working class movement confident enough to change society. Out of demoralisation can come nothing.

nnock triumnha what would Photo: Andrew Wiard, Report. over-ambitious expansion had to be reversed. [All that 'over-ambitious expansion. ever did was to slow down the increase in French unemployment to a slower rise than other countries..J "And we must learn from the past experience of this country... Under the next Labour government there will be no dash for growth. There will be a cautious but sustained boost to the whole economy"

Hattersley spelled it out further to the London Business School (Financial Times, 31.1.86). "Mr Hattersley was at pains to reassure the City - and warn the unions -that Labour would not allow its. plans for reflating the economy and reducing unemployment to trigger a fresh burst of inflation.

* * a will only proceed as quicki as the inflation constraints allow" he said"

If higher profits are the lynchpin of the whole policy, then what about wages? They will have to be kept down. Hattersley denies any intention of an incomes policy enforced by law, but insists on an incomes policy of some sort. "The figure of money wages is the first part of the national economic assessment... There has got to be a norm". . (Guardian, 18.6.85).

Forum

Neil Kinnock has put it like this: "Pay bargaining would take place in the 'central forum' of the economy, though this would not rule out additional workplace bargaining ... He insisted that any such new deal would have to take closer account of market forces than previous Labour-union agreements. we are going to some extent to have to plan with the market, rather thai against the market."

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 268

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →