Where to from Here?
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-04-24Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 7
Broadwater Farm, Tottenham. Photo: Andrew Moore. Kinnockite Labour government be like?
It looks as if a Kinnock/Hattersley government's main move "against the market" would be not anything anti-capitalist but wage control. "We stand and we face the fact squarely that it goes with the job of government to have deliberate policies for earnings and spending.
"We are not therefore in this movement faced by the question whether the Labour government will have such a policy. It goes with Government, no more, no less"
If the Kinnock/Hattersley programme were really based on expanding the public sector - as it seems to be at first sight - then of course renationalisation of what the Tories have privatised would be crucial. But since private expansion for profit is in fact their chief aim (with public spending only as a secondary stimulus) it is entirely logical that Kinnock relegates renationalisation to a distant future.
"A future Labour Government .. would be able to take these (privatised) companies back into public ownership only 'ultimately", after first introducing policies to improve the economy and reduce unemployment. " "Any programme to renationalise state assets which had been privatised 'cannot take priority, when we will have a nation requiring emergency attention.. "(Financial Times, 16.12.85 and 30.12.85).
Other aspects of the Labour leaders' plans are tailored to fit their central economic policy. Neil Kinnock has said nothing much about Labour's policy of unilateral nuclear disarmament, except to hint at a meeting in Vienna in October 1985 that perhaps a freeze on nuclear weapons would be a better 'first step'. He has stayed silent while Dennis Healey argues that Polaris should not in fact be scrapped immediately. The one thing about the Labour leaders military policy which is entirely clear is their insistence that any money saved by cutting nuclear weapons would be fully balance by increased spending on conver tional armaments.
Frills
Radicalism is left to the trimmings and frills. The GLC's Greate London Enterprise Board, for example, is heavily boosted as a radical initiative which would fit into a future Labour government's economic policy. In vain do the GLC leaders themselves point out that small-scale financial aid to small and medium local enterprises - whatever its merits - is no cornerstone for a national jobs policy.
And in October 1985 Roy Hattersley tried to give a retreat from nationalisation a radical edge by talking of other 'forms of social ownership' - in fact, employee shareownership. "He stressed that the central state monopoly was the right form of social ownership only for public utilities" (Financial. Times 17.10.85).
The Financial Times headlined its editorial appropriately "Labour turns to capital". "Mr Roy Hatters ley... finally scrambled aboard a fast-moving bus, the front seats of which are already occupied by Mrs Margaret Thatcher... and Dr. David Owen... wider share-ownership... The sight of all three main parties gathering behind the banner of wider share ownership... is a sign that the political and economic differences of the parties are perhaps not quite as great as is sometimes pretended." The Labour and trade union left is at a low ebb. There is no denying the evidence.
*Kinnock and Hattersley have been able to push their pro-capitalist economic policy with very little protest.
*The miners have suffered great job losses since their strike. The printworkers are hard pressed in their struggle with Murdoch (and the other Fleet Street bosses). The print union leaders are fighting not to win but to lose gracefully.
*The Labour leaders are pushing through their witch-hunt against Militant with much less protest than in 1983. Formerly left-wing unions like NUPE have been swung behind the witch-hunt.
*Important union elections in the TGWU and AUEW have been won by the right wing.
*Strike figures are low. Apart from the miners' strike there were about 2.5 million striker-days in 1985 - fewer even than in 1976.
*Labour local authorities have abandoned even gestures of defiance against the government.
How permanent are the setbacks? What counter-tendencies are there within the general trend? What can we do to promote them?
The Tories are not all that strong. They have begun to raise profit rates quite significantly, but their economic success (for capitalism) is very limited. They are torn internally: the Westland and British Leyland affairs indicate some serious tensions within their ranks over a US alignment versus an EEC alignment. (British capitalism has a unique middle position.. Increasingly integrated into EEC trade, it still has much more US-owned business on its territory than any other European country, and it has much more invested in the US than the others).
There. is working class demoralisation after the miners' defeat, but no great shift of mass opinion to the right. The unions' tremendous victories in the political fund ballots testify to that. Many workers radicalised and educated by the miners' strike may be demoralised and discouraged now. They are not necessarily de-radicalised and deeducated.
Lose ground
But the Labour left began to lose ground as long ago as 1982.
The modern Labour left dates from the early 1970s. Then it moved in the shadow of the big industrial struggles against the Tories. But the 1973 Labour conference was more left wing than for very many yeals. voted for sweeping nationalisations. The struggle for mandatory re-selection of MPs and other democratic reforms began.
at stunned and passive as the 1974-9 Labour govthe Labour left did not stream out of the party as it had done after 1966. It gathered its forces and fought within the party. The 1978 Labour Party conference the government's incomes policy.
After the general election victory in 1979, the Labour left quickly went onto the offensive under the slogan 'Never again!' The next Labour government should be accountable not to the bosses, the but to the labour movement.
In 1980 the broadest-ever alliance of the Labour left was formed (on our initiative) in the Rank and File Mobilising Committee. There were four main elements: the people round Tony Benn: the Campaign for Labour Party Democracy; the current of semi-revolutionary leftists who were beginning to gain prominence in Labour local government; and us.
In 1980-1 this alliance won important victories: mandatory reselection, and election of the Labour leadership by the party as a wrote. Labour was also committed unequivocally to unilateral nuclear disarmament The momentum was broken by the Bishops Stortford agreement between the top trade union and Labour leaders in early 1982. Part: constitutional reform was halted, and has since been subject to repeated (and partly successful)" attemots to gut it. The party was swung into a against Militant. as late as 1983 the felt obliged to publish a fairly left-wing election Continued page 8