The Tasks Facing the Left
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-04-24Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
Continued from page 7
manifesto, soon left-wing policies came under attack.
In 1980 the left's offensive within the Labour Party went side-by-side with trade union militancy against the Tory government the
steel strike, TUC days of action. Then the steelworkers were led to defeat and decimation of their jobs, and the TUC decided on a policy of retreat. The rapid growth of unemployment to 3 or 4 million intimidated workers.
These industrial developments obviously affected the Labour left. But it was not all cut-and-dried. Big industrial struggles continued, like the NHS strike of 1982. And industrial militancy is influenced by the extent to which workers perceive a clear political alternative to the Tories. So the slipping-back of the Labour left was not just an effect of the industrial downturn, but partly a cause and partly an autonamous process.
Teachers Today the teachers' dispute testifies to the continuing reserves of strength in the trade union movement and union organisation are almost intact. Even in the private sector the unions have managed to keep wages generally ahead of inflation.
Broad Lefts Trade union Broad Lefts are doing fairly well. The CPSA Broad Left has successfully resisted a soft left breakaway. The _ Socialist Teachers' Alliance did well at the Easter NUT conference. In the small NUR Broad Left, a move by our comrades to develop local groups and bulletins has brought very promising results.
And in the National Union of Students, the Trotskyist lett, Socialist Students in NOLS, had resounding successes at the Easter conference.
The Labour left has slipped backwards since 1982 not so much through outside circumstances beyond its control as through its own inadequacies.
Its initial success was based on an alliance with the trade union leaders which was bound to be temporary. The union leaders voted Socialist Organiser no. 268 24 April 1986 Page 8 Tric Heffer walks out of Labour Part hoto: Stefano Cagnoni, Report. or democratic reform in the abour Party because they were ngered by Callaghan's attempt to mpose wage controls on them gainst their will in 1978-9. But the vay they ran their own organisaions showed they had no real comnitment to labour democracy.
Extend
The left needed to organise in he unions, extend the struggle rom Labour Party democracy to rade union democracy, and build a irmer alliance with the rank and ile. It didn't.
conference Readers will no doubt have been impressed with the lethal ingenuity of the so-called "smart bomb" , used to kill and maim sundry Libyan civilians. It was the supposed accuracy of these weapons which led the F-llls to be launched from British sites.
Only F-llls can drop these laser-guided bombs which work in the following way:
Just before the attack run, a laser is lowered from the belly of the aircraft. An infrared camera provides a clear image of the ground below to the Weapons Systems Officer (WSO or "Wizzo"). He locates the target as it approaches, points the laser beam at it and locks the system.
Computer The bomb is released by computer. Its own computer controls its flight by moving its rear fins according to the instructions of a device which homes in on the spot of laser light on the larget.
This spot is kept steady on the target by a remarkable swivel mechanism in the laser, even as the aircraft climbs away in a tight turn to avoid the blast of the bomb, conA 85 after Kinnock attacks Liverpo Local government became a major school in reformism for the Labour left. Lacking coherent strategy and organisation, they did not take the power' when they got council positions: 'the power' took them. Their fiascos contributed in a major way to the downturn in industrial militancy. If in March 1985 the miners could have been confident that the council leaders spouting about confrontation with the Tories would actually do it, then the miners' strike would surely have continued, reinforced by a powerful second front.
taining nearly explosive.
What lets down the whole high-technology show somewhat is that the whole thing depends on the "Wizzo". And he has only a few seconds, possibly under hostile fire, to identify the target, by sight, on a video screen, using his memory of his briefings.
No doubt the smart bomb is accurate enough under test conditions but only a dumb president would expect a similar performance in action.
With the Spring issue of the Women's Health Information Centre (WHIC) Newsletter comes warning that the majority of WHIC's funding has gone with the demise of the GLC.
This Newsletter concentrates on two cancers which mainly or only affect women - breast cancer and cervical WHIC Newsletters usually consist of information gathered from the medical world, explanations of health problems and issues, articles publicising women's and other health groups and book This tonne of high issue examines generBehind it all, the post-1979 Labour left lacked politics. It has never tackled the leadership on the central issue: what to do about capitalism and the working class.
The left has fought hard battles over party reform, nuclear disarmament, women's rights, support for the miners - and rightly so. But over the last few years the old Alternative Economic Strategy - a last gasp of '1945 socialism' - has been expiring. No-one supports it any longer except perhaps the Morning Star. The Labour leaders have their alternative. And the Labour left says nothing.
al practitioners'| policies on referring patients for cervical smears (the easy way to cut cancer deaths); publicises such groups as the Manchester Breast Cancer Group.
Science BACUP (for cancer patients and those close to them) and the Mastectomy Association; and reviews books such as "Cancer In Britain: The Politics of Prevention" (reviewed in SO last year) and "The Cancer Journals" , an account (and more) of the experience
The publication of, and the debate around, Andrew Glyn's Million Jobs A Year' pamphlet, have been a step forward. But they underline the problem. Glyn's programme is no more than warmed-up 1945 socialism nationalist,
reformist, bureaucratic. But almost all the groups of the hard left have rallied to it uncritically.
The excellent activity of many local Labour Parties during the miners' strike indicates that, despite all this, the Labour left is not dead. It is discouraged and dispersed, and obviously quite a lot of individuals have moved irrevocably to the right; but new events could rally and reassemble it quite quickly.
For the present we are faced with a witch-hunt and no vigorous response from the left. How far will the witch-hunt go? More intelligent Kinnockites, like Larry Whitty, want a brisk, briet and limited purge at national level, backed up by piecemeal local action. Having once engaged on a witch-hunt, however, they are at the mercy of the media. After each expulsion the media can point to some other group of Militant supporters, or people 'as bad as Militant' , and demand further action. The Labour leaders dare not refuse for fear of seeming 'weak.
Rally Media pressure can drive the Labour leaders to go further than they would wish. However, the media have other interests beside the Labour Party (Tory crises Royal Weddings, lan Botham and so on), and the Labour leaders must know that a really large-scale witchhunt could devastate their party organisation and their electoral chances. Militant's use of the courts, bad though it is in the long term and in principle, looks like slowing down and limiting the witch-hunt in the short term. So a piecemeal witch-hunt is still more likely than a comprehensive purge - though there will probably be a lot of piecemeal action.
We must try to rally the broadest left forces against the witchhunt. But the main job in the next period will be to educate and organise the most determined forces of the left round genuine working class socialism.
of breast cancer and mastectomy by black lesbian feminist Audre Lorde.
A useful section deals with the campaign by NALGO to introduce and improve cancer screening in the workplace and in the NHS generally.
WHIC I also publishes a series of "Women's Health And - " broadsheets on such topics as Alcohol, Disability, Cervical Cancer, Infertility, Mental Illness, Unemployment, Food, Smoking, Work and Stress, and In The one on cervical cancer explains the reason for smear tests, the terms used in such tests, how other tests are performed, how to decide on treatment if cancer is present (including the details of such treatment) and what to expect in the follow-up period.
These broadsheets are available at 15p plus 13p p&p from WHIC at 52 Featherstone St., London EC1, tel: 01-251 6580). WHIC needs funds to continue its work. Subscriptions are £7 (individuals), £2 (low waged), £10 (organisations) - includes Newsletter. Donations are, of course, welcome.
Scan page 9
The Easter rising ary nationalists and socialists took up arms in Dublin against the Britis Empire. They hoped to spark a war for Irish were striking the first blow in a Europe-wide revolution. Stan Crooke golden curtain of shimmering sunshine, clothing buildings in its filmy cloth of gold, and velling then naked ugliness in beauty, or adding a richer appearance to their classic grace and strength...
"A semi-lazy but curious concentration of attention was fixed on an approaching body of marching men *The curiosity displayed in the proceedings gave place now to bewildered astonishment as the ring of falling glass echoed from the direction of the Post Office. Astonishment was followed by stupefaction as faint echoes of rifle shots penetrated from a distance to where the people were gathered together, and all things were forgotten as the news spread from mouth to mouth that the Volunteers and the Citizen Army were taking Dublin, that a Provisional Government had been established, and an Irish Republic proclaimed."
Such is the description by Sean 'Casey - then Honorary Secretary of the Irish Citizen Army, later playwright and Stalinist - of the start of the Easter Rising in Dublin on Easter Monday (24 April) 1916.
The insurgents were led out by James Connolly to certain military defeat. "We are going to out be slaughtered," he told his successor as leader of the Irish Transport and General Workers Union, William O'Brien, as he left the Citizen Army's headquarters at Liberty Hall to begin the Rising. "Is there no chance of success?" asked O'Brien. "None whatsoever," replied Connolly.
Correct
Connolly was equally convinced that few would understand the Easter Rising. "They (the socialists) will never understand why I am here. They will all forget I am an Irishman," he told his daughter, propped up in bed awaiting his execution after the defeat of the uprising.
He was quickly proved correct in his estimation of the "socialists" "The rising was foredoomed to failure, and in my opinion was a crime against ters people" wrote left wing Labour MP George Lansbury. An editorial in the Independent Labour Party's paper explained: "We do not approve of the revolt of the Sinn Feiners. We do not approve of any armed revolt, as we do not approve of the revolt of the Sinn Feiners. We do not approve of any armed revolt, as we do not approve of any form of militarism and war."
The British TUC (September 1916) passed over the uprising in silence, save for one delegate's reference to the shooting of the non-combattant Francis Sheehy Skeffington and the Parliamentary report at the Labour Farty conferenre gary the calamitous the uprising as break in Ireland."
Amongst the minority who refused to join in this chorus of condemnation were Lenin ("whoever calls such an uprising a "putsch" is either a hardened reactionary, or a doctrinaire hopelessly incapable of picturing a social revolution as a living thing") and, in this country, Sylvia Pankhurst ("their rebellion was but a stage in the long struggle for Irish independence").
That the leaders of the labour movement in this country should have refused to support the Easter The Dublin Post Office after the uprising Rising is hardly surprising. In the preceding years they had likewise failed to give adequate support to the Irish working class and its leaders such as Connolly and Larkin in the struggles which mapped out the road to the Easter Rising.
In the opening years of the century conservative craft unionism was pushed to the sidelines by the emergence of a new trade unionism steeped in militancy and combativity. This was epitomised by the Irish Transport and General Workers Union, established by James Larkin after the leadership of the British-based National Union of Dock Labourers had turned its back on the Dublin dockers and carters' strikes of 1908.
Syndicalist
In 1911 Connolly, returning from America where he had been heavily influenced by the syndicalist ideas of de Leon and the concept of "One Big Union", , became Belfast organiser of the ITGWU.
By mid-1913 the union had organised a majority of Dublin's unskilled workers, and unionisation of the 'general labourers' was beginning to spread throughout Ireland. As Lenin wrote: "A new spirit has been around in the Irish workers' unions. The unskilled workers have introduced unparalleled animation into the trade unions. Even the women have begun to organise - a thing hitherto unknown in Catholic Ireland This country, bearing a double and triple national yoke, was beginning to turn into a land with an organised army of the proletariat."
The employers struck back in the Dublin Lock-Out of August 1913. By the following month 25,000 workers had been locked out in Dublin in an organised attempt to break the ITGWU: reemployment of those locked out was conditional upon signing a pledge not to join the ITGWU.
After eight months of bitter and physical conflict the workers were starved back to work, betrayed by the British trade union leaders who had refused to carry out solidarity blacking and to organise a levy of the TUC's membership to provide financial support for the Dublin workers.
Lenin, over-optimistically, wrote "The Dublin events mark a turning point in the history of the labour movement and of socialism in Ireland. Murphy (leader of the Dublin lock-out) threatened to destroy the Irish trade unions. He has only succeeded in destroying the last remnants of the nationalist Irish bourgeoisie over the proletariat in Ireland. He has helped to steel the working class movement in Ireland, to make it independent, free of nationalist prejudices and revolutionary"
Citizen But the lock-out did mark a major step forward for the Irish working class in the formation of the Irish Citizen Army, the first armed workers' militia of the twentieth century, and the force which, along with the Irish nationalist Irish Volunteers launched the Easter Rising.
The constitution of the Citizen Army declared that "its principal objects shall be: a) to arm and train all Irishmen capable of bearing arms to enforce and defend its first principle (that the ownership of Ireland, moral and material is vested of right in the people of Ireland); b) to sink all differences of birth, privilege and creed under the common name of the Irish people"
The final clause of the constitution stressed that, "every enrolled member must be, it possible, a member of a trades union recognised by the Irish Trades Union Congress".
Class In March 1914, a month after the ending of the Dublin lock-out, Larkin and Connolly reconstituted the Irish Citizen Army. The Irish Volunteers were armed, as too were the Ulster Volunteers, with the full support of British Tories and British Army Officers. The labour movement could not afford to remain unarmed. It needed its own militia to fight for its class interests.
"An armed organisation of the Irish working class is a phenomenon in Ireland. Hitherto the workers of Ireland have fought as part of the armies led by their masters... Now with arms in their hands, they propose to steer their own course, to carve their own future. Neither Home Rule, nor the lack of Home Rule will make them lay down their arms."
But from March 1914 onwards it was not Home Rule for Ireland which the British government was proposing, but partition of the country. Connolly - from October of the same year onwards the leading working class militant in Ireland after Larkin's departure for America - condemned the proposal in the strongest of terms. The prospect of partition sapped Connolly's optimism of earlier years.
*In their movement (of socialism) the North and South will again clasp hands, again will be demonstrated, as in 1798, that the pressure of a common exploitation can make enthusiastic rebels out of a Protestant working class, earnest champions of civil and religious liberty out of Catholics, and out of both a United Social Democracy, he had written in 1910. Three years later he wrote: "But with the advent of Home Rule, nay even with the promise of Home Rule. the old relation of Protestant and Catholic begins to melt and dissolve, and with their dissolution will come a new change in the relation of either faith to politics The writer looks forward with confidence to the future, believing that the tale these Notes from Ireland will have to tell will be a hopeful one, even if the hope is nurtured amid storm and stress."
From March 1914 onwards, Connolly's writings were streaked with a pessimism born of the fear of the consequences of partition upon the working class and its organisations. Partition would "set back the wheels of progress, would destroy the oncoming unity of the Irish labour movement and paralyse all advanced movements while it endured"
All hopes of uniting workers irrespective of religion or old political battle cries would be shattered. All old sectarian jealousies would be kept up, workers would be kept fighting workers, and progress would be impossible. "It still remains to be seen whether the working class agitation cannot succeed in frightening these vampires from the feast they are promising themselves upon the corpse of a dismembered Ireland."
Five months after the emergence of the plans for partition, further impetus along the road to the Easter Rising was provided by the outbreak of the First World War. While the leaders of the parties of labour across Europe reduced themselves to being recruiting sergeants for the war effort of "their" country, Connolly, along with other revolutionary leaders such as Lenin, Luxemburg and Liebknecht denounced the imperialist war.
Transformation
Connolly looked to the transformation of the imperialist war into a civil war. The workers he wrote in 1915, "should have refused to march against their brothers across the frontiers" . If such a refusal led to civil war, then "each socialist who fell in such a civil war would have fallen knowing that he was battling for the cause he had worked for in days of peace"
Foreshadowing the events of 1916, Connolly wrote on the outbreak of war: Even an unsuccessful attempt at socialist revolution by force of arms. would be less disastrous to the socialist cause than the act of socialists allowing themselves to be used in the slaughter of their brothers." And shortly before the government's banning of the "Irish Worker" at the close of 1914, he wrote: "The Irish working class sees no abandonment of the principles of the labour movement in the fight against this war in their fierce resolve to do no fighting except be it in their own country."
Recalling Larkin's adage that England's difficulty was Ireland's opportunity, Connolly saw the war as the time to strike at British rule in Ireland. Writing in the "Workers' Republic" - which replaced the banned "The Worker" in February 1915, and throughout the rest of the year ran a series of back-page articles on insurrections - Connolly warned that once the war was over England would have at its disposal an army of over a million men, more than two soldiers for every adult male in Ireland.
As the time of the insurrection approached, the contents of the "Workers' Republic" became increasingly explicit: "Our opportunity has arrived, if we have but the will and the courage to use it," explained an article in the issue of January 22 1916, while the editorial of the following week's paper asked, "We have planted the seed in the hope that when many of us are much older, it will ripen into action. For the moment and hour of that ripening, that fruitful blessed day of days, we are ready. Will it find you ready too?"
Socialist Organiser no,268
Scan page 10
oppression of the working class has not always existed, since the prol-
----- pull-quotes -----
ment. These are especially large in the public sector, where employ-
How eagar's bombs Art
reland 1916 70 years ago revolution-
independence; some of the socialists hoped they
tells the story. (Part 1). "From the blue skies was falling a