Science Special.....Science Special.....Science Special.... Sciel Safety sacrificed for privilege
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-05-15Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
(whole body) MA PANA TE DERALA reactor building at Three - recoVeR shovebicod bernobyt charthoea, bleeding froses, al-beds iowags deannerased mouth, lung eys, loss-of Note: two hussians nave died hair. within 2 weeks from radiation. 250-499 LD 50 - the Nausea, vomiting, diarrhoea, Atrophy oglance LdK24 Lamonet-to kill half of loss of hair, blessies from thyroice) hurre exposed - is mooth, nose, stomach, bowels, to 5 weeks (linked to degree of 400-1501 kidneys, genitals and under skin loss or white biood cells). surDestructies oL here-arow, tissue, eve, blood and nerve ing titor 1-week-was 200 Reeovery far tweaveek+, then severe interes rehour) you gainwowe. Unborn-children tis-resover more-pi killed. normal nealth in s months. per hour) healthe with great 10S0 No effect excout in a-few sensi- Short-lived reduction of white 0-10 None Premature ageing, some-risk c FACED with a damaged -reactor pouring out clouds of radiation, the Russian and Ukrainian authorities showed inefficiency bordering on cynicism. The result is that t only have those fighting e fire had their lives put at risk, but also thousands of nearby inhabitants.
From the start of the Chernobyl project, safety standards were sacrificed to ureaucratic prestige. This mas made clear in a letter to a Kiev newspaper six weeks before the accident from Lyubov Kovalevska, apparenta senior manager at the ant.
She complained that, in the ace to make Chernobyl the argest nuclear facility in e world, Russian ministries arbitrarily advanced the mpletion date by one year.
the same time, lack of ailding materials and subtandard materials created rustration and despair mongst the highly-skilled rockers, taking standards elow those acceptable for such plants.
When the accident happenit took Ukrainian authorimore than two days to form Moscow of the scale of he disaster, by which time the horus of protest from the rest f Europe was reaching a cresendo.
It was 36 hours before the wn of Pripyat, about a kilometre from the plant, was vacuated. Evacuation of hernobyl town, 15 km from he plant, did not commence or 6 days and took about 5 days to complete. For four of ose days, the wind blew radiation straight at the town.
The Russian authorities did othing to alleviate wideread public and medical morance about radiation dangers. No recommendaions on eating and drinking ere made, even for children nd pregnant women. No guidance for the treatment of radiation illnesses was issued.
Kiev, several people were hospitlised after taking iodine in the mistaken belief that it was an antidote to radiation. Iodine is in fact a poison whose main use is as an antiseptic for grazes.
No doubt this is due to a wish to avoid any panic which might loosen the grip of the authorities on the people. Another reason is the wish to avoid fanning the flames of opposition in the Baltic republics. Here, plans to build new nuclear reactors are already widely unpopular.
Russian secretiveness over Chernobyl has provided both Tory and Labour speakers with an opportunity for smug criticism. In the Commons last week, former Environment Secretary Patrick Jenkin referred to the "remarkable" contrast between the openness of the British nuclear industry and the reticence of the Soviet authorities.
Absurd
George Robertson, Labour Foreign Affairs spokesperson condemned Soviet secrecy as "absurd and outrageous", saying that the lesson for Britain and Russia is that secrecy and civil nuclear power do not go together.
There were exceptions to the general hypocrisy. Tam Dalyell asked what was the purpose of lecturing the Soviet leaders when 'in 1957, when there was a graphite fire at Windscale, the Prime Minister decided not even to tell the Irish." (One correspondent to the Guardian asked if he were the only one who felt better informed about the fire at Chernobyl than the one at Windscale.)
On 2 May, Tony Benn, speaking in Chesterfield, stated that Britain had had some very serious incidents that had luckily not reached Chernobyl proportions. He called for a campaign to phase out nuclear power.
Next day, he released excerpts from his 1969 diary When, as Minister of Technology, he had first become aware of the pressure to keep silent on issues of nuclear safety.
Hearing about problems of corrosion in Magnox reactors, he had visited Bradwell on 31 December. He wrote: "1 am very glad I went because it indicated the real nature of the problem, which is not seen by the CEGB so much as a safety problem as a problem that might affect the economics of the station." After describing how the corrosion could result in overheating of the core with deaths as far away as London, he wrote that the CEGB had decided to restore the operating temperature from 360°C to 380° C to increase the output of power. This was to get round fears of a strike and of cold weather but would double the rate of corrosion.
Benn described this policy as "taking a calculated risk so as not to dislocate industry"
As Energy Secretary in 1976 Benn introduced measures to ensure that reports on nuclear accidents were made public. From 1976 to 1982, some 300 were reported. Tory John Moore relaxed these requirements and since 1982 there have been just 15 reports.
This led Liberal MP for Yeovil, Paddy Ashdown, to complain in the Guardian recently that he had had to ask 3 Parliamentary questions to get an admission that a radioactive release from Hinckley Point had occurred when the CEGB had originally denied it. He also criticised the Government's failure to release the 20-year safety reports on the Magnox reactors.
Absurd
Another absurd piece of secrecy was the refusal to admit that British plutonium had been exported to the USA to make bombs. This was finally admitted long after the US Government had confirmed DOSEMN AME HEALIN EFFEM Over 5000 (close to Nausea and vomiting convul it.
Most embarassing in Chernobyl week was the revalation by the Observer that the CEGB had concealed an explosion in a new piece of equipment which released a small amount of radiation. The Oberver's informant said: "Only by immense good fortune was a large release of reactor gas avoided. How did a piece ot nuclear equipment that had been subject to all the CEB's current design evaluation and independent analysis end up failing so spectacularly?"
British criticism of the Soviet nuclear industry have also raised issues of safety. Sadly, the critics have merely revealed their own ignorance.
Thus Energy Secretary Peter Walker claimed:
(1) Russian reactors did not have "total containment" and would not be permitted in Britain. In fact, none of the Magnox reactors have containment domes.
(2) Rusian reactors were too close to population centres. In fact Britain has such a dense population that a similar accident would cause a higher number of casualties.
(3) That there had never been "emergencies involving significant radiological hazards to the public at any civil nuclear installation" in Britain. This 1s technically true because the Windscale fire of 1957 which caused at least 30 deaths from cancer, took place while it was a military installation.
The US government has been backward on occasions in warning people of danger from nuclear activities such as.when a cloud of fallout engulfed the Rougelap Atoll in 1954. This caused acute radiation sickness and many cancers and mutations.
US reactors do not always have adequate containment, either. Five government reactors producing plutonium for bombs lack steel or concrete walls, Death of nearly 100% in up to desirees_and Abnormalities ol-ensition. vivors nave distiouring scar ymph nodes and spleen De disorders, andmaignant crease oLiviadeed cells. tuespurs.
poor health or who develop a R00-9--620601 -ESPAD.
Sh you temporarily very prone to intecton. necovery or normal caneer-etc. Stori lie fore to 3.Va2ts.
blood cella-Sane nik of cancer, genetic ettects, and prePOITT fertility ofersales for-emse cancer, genetic