Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Connolly and the Easterrising

Socialist Organiser no. 270, 15 May 1986 · scan p. 9 · about 1,817 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

"IF YOU are itching for a rifle, itching to fight, have a country of your own. Better to fight for your own coun try than for the robber

empire... Our curse is our belief in our weakness. We are not weak, we are strong. Make up your mind to strike before the opportunity goes", , James ConnoIly told a rally in Dublin in the opening months of the First World War.

From then onwards, Connolly began the preparations which were to culminate in the Easter Rising of 1916, in conjunction with the Irish Republican Brotherhood (IRB), the continuation of the Fenians of the previous century.

From the end of the 19th century, an Irish national movement had been re-forming. It included youth organisations (Fianna Eireann), cultural associations (Gaelic League and Gaelic Athletic Association), and, after 1913, a Republican militia (the Irish Volunteers), which, after the split with John Redmond, leader of the Irish parliamentary party, who supported the British war effort, was largely under the control of the IRB.

In August 1914, the IRB Supreme Council had decided to organise an insurrection before the end of the war. The following month a joint meeting took place between its leadership and Connolly and William O'Brien of the Irish Citizen Army.

Connolly made the running in arguing for an immediate insurrection.

Throughout 1915 preparations for armed insurrection continued. Guns for the Irish Citizen Army (ICA) were smuggled in from Liverpool. Speaking at the May Day rally in Dublin, Connolly appealed for recruits to the Irish Citizen Army.

In August a miniature rifle range was set up at Liberty Hall. This was the headquarters of the Irish Transport and General Workers Union, and the ICA was based there. From October onwards, ICA discipline was tightened up, and the number and variety of its military exercises continued. Arms, ammunition and medical supplies continued to be stockpiled in Liberty Hall, where the ICA kept a round-the-clock armed guard.

Agitation

Hand in hand with Connolly's military preparations went his constant political agitation: against collaboration with the British war effort; against the threat of extending the military callup to Ireland; in support of strikes and wage demands to let the rich men pay' for the imperialist war; in support of improved public housing in Dublin; and in support of the Women's Franchise League, founded in January 1916.

The same month, Connolly became a member of the Military Council of the IRB, which carried out the final preparations for the rising, fixed for Easter Sunday, 23 April 1916. The plan was for simultaneous risings throughout Ireland, initiated by the seizure of Dublin Castle and followed by risings in the provinces to prevent troops and police advancing into the city.

But, as the scheduled date of the insurrection approached, the plans began to run into trouble.

A German ship carrying arms and ammunition for the uprising had to be scuttled by its crew to prevent capture by the authoris Dublin, Easter 1916 Second part of Stan Crooke's article on the uprising for Irish independence which took place at Easter 1916, and the part played in it by the great socialist leader James Connolly cies. And the instructions ordering 'three days' mobilisation" for Irish Volunteers beginning on Easter Sunday — which were the signal for the uprising - were countermanded with only hours to go by Irish Volunteers commander Eoin MacNeill. MacNeill was not in Croutes the IRB and had not been told that the 'manoeuvres' were a cover for an uprising.

The Military Council of the IRB met on the morning of Easter Sunday. The veteran Fenian Thomas Clarke, who had spent over 15 years in British prisons for his part in the dynamite campaign of the 1880s, argued for carrying out the original plan and relying on the Volunteers to rise spontaneously in response to the initial insurrectionary act in Dublin. After discussion, the Military Council decided to postpone the start of the rising until noon of the next day, Easter Monday, 24 April.

On Haster Monday they seized key buildings in Dublin and prepared to hold the centre of the city against the British Army. The insurgents' headquarters was set up at the General Post Office in O'Connell Street.

Immediately after that building was seized, Patrick Pearse stood outside the main door and read to the incomprehending crowd of spectators the Declaration of an Irish Republic. Pearse was president of the Provisional Government, James Connolly in charge of military affairs in Dublin.

In less than a week the Easter Rising had been crushed. Outside Dublin there was only minor activity, confined to Galway and Wexford. And in Dublin itself only some 1200 took part in the insurrection, mostly members of the Irish Volunteers.

From Tuesday morning onwards, British troop reinforcements began to arrive. On Wednesday the gunboat 'Helga' sailed up the Liffey and began to bombard Dublin, striking first and foremost at the Irish TGWU headquarters, now long vacated by the ICA. The bombardment of Dublin continued through Thursday and Friday, with entire blocks of shops and offices being razed to the ground.

Unconditional

On the Saturday, 29 April, Patrick Pearse and the now badly wounded Connolly agreed to unconditional surrender 'in order to prevent the further slaughter of unarmed people and in the hope of saving the lives of our followers"

In the six days of fighting, nearly 500 people had been killed, half of them civilians. Some 2500 had been injured. Relief had to be given to 100,000 people, a third of Dublin's population. In the weeks following the Rising, over 2000 suspected Republicans were arrested, and most of them interned in prison camps in Britain, usually without a trial.

Ninety participants in the Rising were tried and sentenced to death. Fifteen of the death sentences, including those of all signatories to the Proclamation of the Republic, were carried out before the British government decided that further executions might be counterproductive and lead to a backlash against its rule.

At the outbreak of war, Connolly had looked forward to a Rising which would "set the torch to a European conflagration that will not burn out until the last throne and the last capitalist bond and debenture will be shrivelled on the funeral pyre of the last warlord"

Lenin commented that "they [the Irish] have risen prematurely, when the European revolt of the proletariat has not yet matured" . But the Easter Rising failed to do what Connolly hoped for other reasons, too. The weaknesses and limitations of the Irish labour movement after 1916, which allowed the political stage to be vacated for the benefit of Arthur Griffith's Sinn Fein party, cannot be separated from Connolly's own political imprecision.

Connolly had failed to demarcate socialism clearly from nationalism. Compare Jim Larkin's statement of 1915, *I am not for the Kaiser any more than I am for George of England. I am for the working class of every country" , with the banner which Connolly had draped outside Liberty. Hall: "We serve neither King nor Kaiser — but Ireland".

Connolly's famous declaration in 1916 - "The cause of labour is the cause of Ireland, the cause of Ireland is the cause of labour" — leads into a vision of a future independent Ireland coloured by an Irish nationalist populism. "Labour seeks that an Ireland free should be the sole mistress of her own destiny, supreme owner of all material things within and upon her soil... , wrote Connolly: but which class would be 'mistress'? Connolly blurred over the question by assuming that Ireland could be independent (or 'really' independent) only under a workfailure to clarify struggle against Irish nationalism his continuing religious liefs and Catholic mysticism from his period in America the beginning of the cent through to his polemics of 190 against Father Kane. into Easter Rising itself.

Connolly was anti-sect his attitude to the Irish Prot tants of north-east Ulster, did not belong to an Irish natic alist tradition, but Connolly basic orientation in his writing was towards memanu Irish working class of Cathol origin. How else to understand the comment of the Scots-born Connolly, who spent only 13 of his 48 years of life in Ireland: '"They will never understand why I am here [in the Rising]. They will all forget that I am an Irishman"?

And while Connolly was free of the sectarian leanings of some of his would-be followers today. he underestimated the determination of the Ulster Loyalists to prevent their forcible incorporation into united and independent Ireland. "Were the forces of the Crown withdrawn entirely, the Unionists could or would put no force into the field that the Home Rulers of all sections combined could not protect themselves against with a moderate amount of ease"

Connolly's accommodation to nationalism, along with his ambiguities and vacillations on a series of other questions, were so many different aspects of a more basic problem: a failure to see the necessity of clear-cut ideological struggle, and of building a revolutionary party capable of waging such ideological struggle. He belonged to the pre-Lenin generation off Marxism.

Despite Connolly's work in the Irish Socialist Republican Party and the Socialist Party of Ireland, and his support in 1912 for the Irish TUC establishing its own political party, Connolly consistently leaned too much towards syndicalism [socialism based exclusively on trade union action] to be able to see the centrality of the question of the revolutionary party.

If Connolly's limited appreciation of the questions of ideological struggle and revolutionary party led to political accommodation in the run-up to the Easter Rising, in the aftermath it meant that no organised political force existed to carry on the positive aspects of Connolly's struggle. The field was left open to those prepared to make their peac with capitalism.

Haze

To strive for insurrection against British imperialism, in the midst of the imperialist war, was Connolly's first duty as a revolutionary. But, in the maelstrom of events, Connolly was weaken. ed by his ideological haziness. He pushed forward towards armed uprising indifferent, not blind, to the fundamental problems of ideological struggle and a revolutionary party.

Connolly's ideological haziness has made him easy meat for latter-day Stalinist commen tators. But an serious appreciation of the Easter Rising, or of its leader, demands rather more than a disingenous attempt te glorify it as a forerunner of the Popular Fronts of the 1930s The Easter Rising, even tak ing into account its political limitations born of Irist nationalism, remains a heroi chapter in the history of socialis struggle in Ireland. As Patric Pearse put it shortly before hi execution:

*We seem to have lost, bu we have not lost. To refuse t fight would have heen lose, to fight is to win. We hav kept faith with the past an handed on a tradition to th future"

Socialist Organiser no. 270

----- pull-quotes -----

ers' government.!! Inseparable from C Connolly's

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 270

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →