Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

The politics of lipstick

Socialist Organiser no. 270, 15 May 1986 · scan p. 10 · about 772 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

to bring the wolves out reviews a new book about the politics of lipstick and make-up THE CAPITALIST crisis and economic recession has resulted in attacks on workers' rights, wages and conditions. To bolster Falling profits, the bosses try to make the cost of labour cheaper. Women workers are specially vulnerable.

The bosses" ideological campaign seeks to reinforce the view of women as part-time workers. temporary workers, marginal workers - as the 'second' wage earner of a family.

Women's wages have always been lower than men's. This campaign seeks to lower them even further, as part of the generalised attack on working people's wages.

The campaign seeks to desroy women's confidence as workers. It aims to roll back gains made by women in the 60s and '70s, such as abortion rights and affirmative action, and aims to make women identify themselves first as women rather than as workers.

The glorification of the family and especially of the role of mother within the family plays on women's guilt about working at all (even for economic necessity) rather than staying at ome with the kids.

In the 1950s, a similarly reacnonary campaign by the ruling class aimed to roll back social gains by women who had entered the workforce during World War 2. The ruling class tried to propagate the idea of a "feminine mystique' Pathfinder Press has just published a book, "Cosmetics, Fashion and the Exploitation of Women", , by Joseph Hansen and Evelyn Reed, with an introduction by Mary-Alice Waters, which is a record of a debate within the US socialist movement in the early '50s on the whole issue of cosmetics, fashion and working women.

The debate reflects the concern of many working women about their use of cosmetics, and shows how many were influenced by the reactionary propaganda surrounding women's proper role"

The book is a collection of letters and articles. Some originally appeared in the paper 'The Militant', but the response was so great that the debate spilled over into the discussion bulletin of the Socialist Workers Party, which was then a Trotskyist organisation.

Joseph Hansen started it all by writing a short article about the hucksterism of cosmetic companies who prey on women's insecurities to sell their products.

This article prompted a variety of responses. Hansen was accused of ridiculing working women who merely wanted some beauty and loveliness in their lives.

Another claimed that women's striving for beauty was progressive, since they were rebelling against attempts to deny them part of their rights as human beings.

Several defended the use of cosmetics under capitalism as an economic necessity. Since job competition was keen, younger, healthy-looking, attractive women would be chosen over older, less favoured women. Many used cosmetics as a means of looking younger and fresher — that is, more capable of hard work.

For those unable to find work, marriage was a way to find some kind of financial security. Cosmetics were part of the strategy of getting and keeping a husband.

The debate triggered off other issues, particularly different views about the historical origins of women's oppression. Exchanges between Marjorie McGowan and Evelyn Reed illustrate two points of view.

The book is very readable — letters and articles are fairly short, and often lively, humorous or angry.

The debate still has relevance. Advertising for cosmetics today is different from the 1950s, but only in emphasis, not in essentals. Today's cosmetics are advertised as 'natural', 'wholesome , non-toxic, non-chemical, additive-free - that is, hardly cosmetics at all, in fact.

Women still buy cosmetics and still try to fit the latest (socially determined) ideal of béauty by dieting, fashion and up. Many feel guilty and ambivalent about it.

Evelyn Reed argues that under capitalism women are compelled to use cosmetics and fashion, and that while capitalism prevails some token recognition should be given to this Workers often have to accept undesirable working conditions forced on them by the bosses, but they do so reluctantly, often struggling against such meas ures. Similarly, working women may have to accept that they must use cosmetics and fashion in capitalist society, but they should do so in a spirit of opposition to the efforts of the ruling class to impose its standards of beauty on them, rather than in adaptation to those standards. red a new rest. a ripe young red in MAX Factor's Lolor netic Wrer Habur HereaLa cou Swam ptit Jeron apracnue to dm aremai 82 e w rodi, disewinat ted thut tomr tte soer - i in a tanne senation. U.10 pear tax Bringing the pigs out?

----- pull-quotes -----

Cosmetics, Al F:Fashions. tand the Exploitation Women

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 270

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →