Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

The story of an outcast

Socialist Organiser no. 270, 15 May 1986 · scan pp. 10–11 · about 1,988 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

Vagabonde' he fi •effect 99 PEY drine Bonnaire in ganiser no 270 15 May 1986 Page 10 "Vagabonde" has a mys— tery at its centre - why has Mona turned her back on society to face an uncertain future on the road? The film doesn't spell things out, we have to draw our own conclusions.

Mona is a drifter, hitch= hiking her way aimlessly round southern France in winter. She's aware that she's an oddity. The drivers who give her lifts, the people she meets are all curious to know why a young attractive girl is on the road, alone and unprotected.

Body The film opens with the dis covery of her dead body; frozen in a field. From there, the film backtracks over the last few months of her life. People she's met face the camera directly and "bear witness" about her.

Since Mona herself is an enigma, the attitudes to wards her of the people she central part ple Belinda Weaver reviews "Vagabonde', , a film by Agnes Varda reveals them to us.

Mona confides to a university professor who gives her a lift that since people ask questions, she makes up answers. We can't be sure of anything she tells us.

The response of most of the men is salacious - the idea of a young woman travelling alone excites them. They see her as someone they can make sexual use of — temporarily. They don't respect her.

One man lets her earn a few francs, but then sends her packing. He doesn't trust women on the road - "They only want to loaf and chase men"

The response of women is more varied. She evokes guilt and unease in the university professor who remains haunted by her memory. A peasant woman enyies Mona her freedom Yolande, who cares for an elderly woman, at first befriends, then turns against, Mona. She finds Mona too unsettling once she has allowed her into her home.

Mona is a self-appointed vutcast from society. She rejects all the "feminine" graces expected by society - she's surly, dirty and undomesticated. There is no attempt to ingratiate herself with people. She seeks lifts, money, cigarettes and food all with the same sullen and defensive air.

Female vagrants are rarer than male. They evoke stronger responses because they challenge people's views of what is acceptable behaviour for a woman.

By staying dirty, by casually sleeping with and leaving men, by doing as she pleases, Mona is distancing herselt from "acceptable" behaviour.

Stark The film is somewhat stark and sombre. Starting it with her death weights the flashback of despair.

Because the story is unfolded in an episodic, deliberately "undramatic" way, it abours a bite sighty self-conscious "witness' scenes also slow the pace.

Mona is uncompromising. She's not prepared to risk her freedom with anybody or anything. As a goatherd tells her; freedom can destroy, because the loneliness it brings is destructive. Mona's lonely death from cold and exposure is the end of her freedom.

Rejection

Mona's intransigence is perfectly conveyed by the young actress, Sandrine Bonnaire. She doesn't seek sympathy from people she meets, she doesn't have any expectations, she's ready for rejection.

The goatherd also says of her, "By proving she's useless she helps a society she rejects" •Society dismisses. tramps and vagrants as freaks rather than face up to why they take to the lives they

Scan page 11

THE MINERS' strike in Belgium shows a remarkable change. For many years they have had two unions in the pits - the Christian union and the Socialist union. The fact that there are only five pits left in Belgium and the government wants to shut all tive has brought the two unions together.

There is now a feeling of solidarity which has never existed in the Belgian pits before. The young miners out there are demanding exactly the same as what we demanded - that is, jobs, pits, and mining communities to be Basingstoke UCW, personal capacity)

THE ORIGINS of the curre postal dispute in Leeds lie in the so-called business efficiency package agreed at the UCW annual conference last In this, postal workers were forced into productivity schemes whether local branches agreed or not.

Part of the package was agreement to look at new methods of work, but no agreement was given to the implementation of these methods.

The Post Office, however have now completed the long-running study in Leeds, and have taken management action to implement the results. The implications for Leeds are job losses and a reduction in overtime.

With the present national By a British miner who recently visited Belgium saved wholesale slaughter, It's also interesting to know that Belgium has a large nuclear programme. They talk a lot about the China syndrome, but what fear is the French syndrome.

The French have no oil. They have shut almost all the coal mines. And now the authorities just shrug their shoulders and say "we've no option. We have to go nuclear' That could happen in Belpay offer standing at 42%,, this will mean a drastic cut in wages, forcing people to look for outside work, The Post Office will achieve casualisation of staff and a weakening of the union's position.

Nationally, the implications are that if the Post Office gets away with implementing the new working practices at Leeds, they will speedily try to introduce them at other offices up and down the country.

Leeds branch are at present operating an overtime han and have ballotted in favour of taking industrial action, although as yet an all-out strike has not been called.

The UCW executive council are trying to keep the dispute low-key and to stop it spreading to other offices This may prove impossible if the Post Office attempts to divert work away from Leeds and other UCW branches take sympathetic action.

The UCW executive coun cil have, however, authorised branches to take collections on behalf of the Leeds membership.

The Post Office have responded by employing about 400 casuals to do the work normally performed on overgium, and in this country.

The determination of the Belgian miners to save their pits is something that has to be seen to be believed. They are solid; and if they have to go to other workers, then they are quite prepared to do that.

They learned tremendous lessons from the miners' strike in Britain, and the first one is that they need unity themselves, and having got unity they must secure the support of other workers.

The two prime reasons why the British miners lost our strike were that we did time. It is essential that the dispute is won. The government's strategy is clear: more work for less pay, casualisation, and privatisation. ON WEDNESDAY May, three to four hundred people protested at the proposed closure of the Royal Samaritan Hospital in the south side of Glasgow, a closure which would be disastrous to the health and well-being of women in the West of Scotland.

The demonstration, called by NUPE and supported by health service workers from the Victoria Infirmary and Stobhill and Gartnaval hospitals plus supporters from various community organisations and Labour Party members, sought to show the unelected Greater Glasgow Health Board that they cannot implement further cutbacks in the already chronically understaffed and under-financed Health Service.

The Samaritan is particularly important in that it is a gil not have total unity, due to the Notts miners, and we dic not get the promised support of the big battalions. If the Belgian miners can get those two ingredients, then they are well on the way to winning their battle.

When we visited Belgium we went on the picket lines over there as a gesture of solidarity. I was impressed by their youth. They have a different situation over there. 25 years in the pits, and you're out on a full pension. They were absolutely amazed when I told them that I had had 31 years in the pits.

women's hospital, the only such hospital in the West of Scotland which deals exclusively with the health concerns and problems of women in a women's environment.

NUPE has already made a good start by calling this demonstration. The campaign must be continued and escalated if the Health Board is to be forced to withdraw its plans.

The campaign must include broad sections of the women's and labour movements who will be affected by the cut of this vital service, especially the Labour Party Womens Sections, Women's Aid and all the Health Service unions.

The Greater Glasgow Health Board cannot be allowed to get away with this attack on women's health. The campaign can and must be won and the hospital saved but only through a vigorous, co-ordinated campaign encompassing the Glasgow labour •and women's movements.

There is also a tremendous internationalist spirit. You have the French-speakers, the Flemish-speakers, the Turks the Italians - and we found one guy from Manchester who worked in a pit in Belgium.

The police didn't want to know. They kept well away.

There was no police presence on the picket line at the pit.

But as soon as there was any attempt to go to any other sector of industry, the police came in heavy. We with that.

Colchester and a general increase in NF and BM activity. Anti-Fascist Action has responded with a spray out and leafletting with local YS members.

Already some lecturers in Milson's department have refused to teach him. Currently the union is engaged in talks with the Chancellor.

If the University authorities refuse to take the necessary steps, then it is clear that we have to mobilise students in direct mass action, to achieve our aim. This week SSiN supporters have decided to build for an emergency general meeting of the student union at which it will be demanded that the Executive has to take on much of the work load and get the campaign properly off the ground. Proper posters and stickers need making, every student needs leaflet explaining what's going on. The campus unions need approaching to try for a joint campaign.

It will be argued that 24-hour occupation is needed this week to act as a focal point for the campaign and to show the Chanceilor that the union is serious. And the University will have to be told that grad uation ceremonies will not pass peacefully with these two organised racists still arounc Furthermore. a rent strike job cuts STRIKING seamen blockade ferry terminals and dies down all cross-channel saili from Portsmouth recently protest at cutbacks in m levels.

National Union of Seam crew members occupied thei ships in solidarity with striker Felixstowe who in a similar dispute over eat manning for the new-type lar ferries.

But ferry operators Towns Thoresen struck back most immediately by taking leg al action against the striker They claim the Portsmouth occu pation constitutes seconda picketing.

A court injunction declari the strike illegal has now bee imposed on the crew of one ship, Free Enterprise 5, tied up since the cancellation of its sailing to Cherbourg.

A second vessel at an adjac ent berth was occupied on 2 May as crew members joined the strike - creating holiday chaos and extending the ports' logjam.

All scheduled passenger and freight services are now at a complete standstill.

NUS must now build on this revolt of the rank and file and escalate the dispute via port joint trade union committees. Only it this next step is taken can marine workers' jobs be defended.

THE THREE hundred worker at Silentnight bed factory sacked last July are to hold march and rally in Keighley i Yorkshire on Saturday 17 May 500 workers were sacked b Silentnight boss Tom Clark after six weeks on strike fo higher wages. The worker spent six months asking fo

----- pull-quotes -----

Leeds (Branch secretary,

thought we had got it bad here, but nothing on a par

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 270

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →