Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Our debt to Connolly

Socialist Organiser no. 271, 29 May 1986 · scan p. 4 · Sean Matgamna · about 1,181 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 4

AS STAN Crooke rightly says (SO 270) James Connolly belonged to 'the pre-Lenin generatior of Marxism'. This meant that he lived before the great renaissance of revolutionary Marxism inspired by the Russian Revolution of 1917 and organised and spread by the new Communist The work of Lenin's and Trotsky's Comintern included clarification of the conception of the revolutionary working-class party and a series of sharp and partly new developments of the Marxist theory of the national question and its relation to working-class socialism.

Connolly lived and died in the period before this renaissance. His theorising and battling were part of the international socialist ferment that preceded and produced it. And his activity was confined almost entirely to politically backward or peripheral labour movements, in Britain, Ireland, and the USA, It is easy enough to find fault with him after his cause was defeated. But I think we also owe a debt of loyalty to people like Connolly — we must at least place and understand them in their own historical context. The last word we have of what Connolly thought he was doing in 1916 is what he said to another socialist as he left Liberty Hall on Easter Monday, the day of the Rising: "We are going out to be slaughtered. The odds against us are a thousand to one, but in the event of victory hold on to your rifles, as those with whom we are fighting may stop before our goal is reached"

Sunk

These were not the words of sumeone who had abandoned socialism for nationalism, Or sunk his socialism in the nationIrish Citizen Army nuteide lihorto Hall on the just struggle of the great majority of the Irish people against their national oppression. In doing so he made a step forward from the political common stock of his generation of Marxists — who generally had little interest in the revolts of oppressed nations - and placed himself entirely in the tradition of Marx and Engels after the 1860s.

I think Connolly's understanding of the character and depth of the 'Catholic'/'Protestant' division in Ireland was inadequate. On the other hand, no-one has ever written with more biting i hatred of Catholic-Nationalist bigotry than did Connolly in his writings against the Ancient Order of Hibernians and the old Home Rule party.

And, of course, we only see the Protestant/ Catholic question as it is today, after 70 years of bourgeois nationalist and bourgeois Unionist domination of Ireland, during which the divisions have been trenched deeper by the existence of two sectarian Irish states.

In 1914 Connolly himself said that he would prefer continued Irish-British Union to this form of partitioned Home Rule.

It was not inevitable that Ireland would develop as it has done in the 70 years since Connolly's death. Other courses of development — those Connolly set out to fight for in 1916may have been possible.

The problem with some of Stan Crooke's criticisms of James Connolly is that he seems almost to see it as an aberration for Connolly to be concerned with the national question at all. I too think James Connolly made concessions to nationalism, but he was surely right to try to root Irish revolutionary working-class socialism in the traditions of plebeian revolutionary nationalism in Ireland. He was right to try to compete with the bourgeois and petty bourgeois nationalists for the leadership of the Irish nationalist mass movement.

That he was, so to speak, politically gobbled up by the bourgeois natjonalists after 1916 and "ThT 1771 made into one of their plasterof-Paris saints, proves only that he lost, not that he was wrong tomake the attempt.

The early Communist International gave much thought to this problem, and even its immensely clear ideas, based on far wider experience and discussion than Connolly ever had access to, could not prevent the Chinese Communist Party making errors similar to Connolly's, and of catastrophic proportions, in the 1920s.

It is not fair or historically appropriate to seize on the use made by nationalist populists now and for decades past of formulations of Connolly's such as: "The cause of labour is the cause of Ireland. The cause of Ireland is the cause of labour"

Connolly did not use such slogans in their populist meaning: for him they asserted the claim of the young Irish working class to lead the rural poor. It was entirely consistent with international socialism for the Irish working class to champion and take the lead in the just democratic demand of the Irish masses for national independence.

Pandered

If the demand was just -and it surely was - then there was nothing necessarily chauvinist or narrowly nationalist in the Irish labour movement fighting for it.

That some of Connolly's agitational articles in 1915-16 pandered to mere nationalism -and they did — does not invalidate that, nor invalidate Connolly, who should be taken as a whole.

It was the Stalinists who gave the poisonous, and presently dominant, nationalist/populist interpretation to slogans such as *The cause of Ireland..' , with their "two-stage revolution' arguments that "full' national independence was the first stage' of the Irish revolution, which had to be completed before there could be any talk of socialism. It was Stalinism that infected the later eneration of Republicans not TrmY Connolly.

There is an implicit - and sometimes explicit - assumption in some of the criticisms of Connolly now being produced, that he should have chosen to struggle for the unity of the Irish working class by choosing Unionism and socialism within the old UK, having no truck with Irish separatism. But that would have meant that Connolly turned his back on the democratic demands fought for by the big majority of the Irish people for many, many decades (at least), and tried to get the Irish labour movement to do the same.

No Irish labour movement could have been built with such politics. Only sterile Unionist sects could have been built in most of Ireland with such politics. On that road there was possible solution to the Unionist/Nationalist division -only the self-isolation of the socialists and the strengthening of the bourgeois and petty-bourgeois nationalists. And thus the division would have been deepened, not avoided, had the Irish socialists chosen unionism instead of separation.

It is true of course that, had Irish socilaists like James Connolly proposed to the Irish Unionist minority reconciliation between the two communities by way of some form of internal autonomy for the Irish minority, then there might have been a chance that socialists standing in the nationalist tradition could have won over a section of the Northern Protestant working class.

But Connolly's failure to do this does not diminish the justice of the national concerns he fought and died for.

The tragic evolution of Ireland since Connolly does not invalidate Connolly's concern for Irish national liberation — it underlines the tragedy that it was realised (partly) under the leadership of the Catholic nationalist bourgeoisie and not under the leadership of a labour movement armed with Connolly's ideas and attempting to unify the Irish working people.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 271

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →