[Cort Afterford Sea Flensburg a Copenhagen LITHUANIAN 3PAU…]
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-05-29Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 7
Cort Afterford Sea Flensburg a Copenhagen LITHUANIAN 3PAU Smolensk, REE
K S.S.R. Vitebs 'S END 51 The sterdam ВЕЛЫМ balalay BYELORUSSIAN & Br'ansk Sarati Gdańsk' or'ol
English Chan. AMAS this Carnis Sseim La Horre Hero Balle re MPOL KKOV
Frankfu Kie Sumy?
Nazaire? re. Stuttgart Zitor S.S. R. Bajepropet: cvsk Vodochranilisce La Rochelles Munich Gorgever WrO vograd Rostov Bordeau AN atisla COLD. y Rog. anov tr Biscay Geneve WIT HUNGARY Oradea one Krasnodar starm Ebro Nimes TUNN Hanse Krad Mures" Ou Venice Szeged, ROMA N Моге. • Maikop, Livorno CASANO Danube Ruse CK S JS.S.R. Cipr STortosa Barcelona CORSICA Singer % Perugia driatic BULSARIA Varna BL Coruh cia BALEARIC SLANDS + Sea Tirali Istanbut Zonguldak (Fr.) Rome Softa Burgas msun cartagena CAPON Cagliari Tyrrhenian Kerkira Aegean Sea Eskigenien MINOR • MALLORCA SARDINIA Naples Tarante ALBANI Cavalr ARka Van L (It.) onob& Thessalem Siva GON Algiers Palermg: SICILY. Messina Tasi SPARTIVENTO Sea osenza Larisa.
The Ukraine (in red) is the largest country in Europe and the largest oppressed nation in the world Anes Yuriy Shukhevych has yielded. I tnis really had happened, it would in no way diminish the incredible example of human resistance that he has given. But everything indicates that his recantation is another falsification by the KGB - an institution which has specialised in such things, changing its name various times in its history without changing its essence.
To back up its revelation, the Soviet periodical published a photocopy of excerpts from the letter it claimed to have received from Shukhevych. Under Gorbachov, the bureaucrats remain as incompetent as they were in the days of his teacher, Stalin. They did not know that in the West there was a copy of a real letter from Shukhevych, written in his own hand in April 1984, when he was already blind, to the chairman of the Presidium of the Supreme Soviet of Ukraine.
The two specimens of handwriting were submitted for analysis to Katharina Stulmann-Kortin, an expert in graphology and the psychology of handwriting in Munich. Her conclusion was the following:
"The graphic nature of both handwritings is essentially different. Taking into account, in particular, the sharp difference the shape of many letters, one can conclude with a probability close to 100% that the authors of the two handwritings are not identical" (10).
Visti z Ukrayniny's revelation has not been published by the press that circulates in the USSR. Both Shukhevych and his relatives living in the USSR report that they have not the slightest idea of what is contained in the article by Savchuk. Shukhevych is still serving his internal exile (in a home for invalids), while it would ne expected that he would be released after recanting.
On two occasions, in July 1984 and in January 1985, the US president, Ronald Reagan, declared his solidarity with Yuriy Shukhevych, describing him as a Ukrainian patriot and a symbol of the fight for freedom.
VAKIA lent Udine •Clu Vesuvio Reagan and his predecessors have of course been well known as ardent defenders of human rights and freedom, but only as regards 'Communist' regimes, not in the areas dominated by US imperialism. They have supported even the bloodiest dictatorships, whenever the dictator has been *their son of a bitch' ', in an expression made famous by one of Reagan's predecessors. They have supported such dictators up to the last minutes, up till they threatened to provoke popular revolutions, as in the case of Somoza in Nicaragua and more recently Duvalier in Haiti and Marcos in the Philippines.
They have expressed sympathy' for Polish Solidarnosc while at the same time supporting the Turkish military dictatorship which, like the Jaruzelski regime, has suppressed tradeunion freedoms, as well as other elementary rights.
They have claimed to be 'friends' of the Ukrainian revolutionary nationalists, while at the same time being implacable enemies of revolutionary nationalists on their own territory, such as Pedro Albizu Campos, a fighter for Puerto Rican independence, or Malcolm X, a radical leader of the Black liberation movement.
If the rulers in the White House express concern today about the fate of Yuriy Shukhevych, it will be worth asking what their attitude was to the armed struggle of the Ukrainian liberation movement led by Roman Shukhevych.
The US government was well informed about the existence and situation of this movement in the postwar years. It had in its possession many reports by the American intelligence services, some of which have been declassified and can be studied today in the US National Archives.
In one of them, dated March 1948, the following is said, for example:
*The real significance of the Ukrainian nationalist bands lies... in the fact that they have already been able to operate for more than two years against the established governments
Seal Cepayar
Brio UKRAIN of both Poland and the USSR. This could have happened only with the support of at least a part of the local population.
These bands have had no normal sourceds of supply and have depended on what they could seize from their adversaries and what was obtained from civilian sympathisers. Their continued survival suggests that the local population furnished them at least with food despite near-famine conditions in 1946 and it is eviden that only people who strongly hate the Soviet way of life would have supported what many of them undoubtedly realise is a lost cause" (11).
Popular The popular support for the liberation movement was so great that in 1947 the Polish army, in a largescale operation called Action Vistula, displaced the entire Ukrainian peasanttry from Poland's eastern territories 5. order to exterminate the UPA guerilla forces.
Nonetheless, the US government did not lift a finger to keep this cause from being lost.
In an attempt to break the isolation of the Ukrainian liberation movement from the outside world and get help from abroad, various units of the UPA came out of Poland through Czechoslovakia to the West. Once their mission of 'armed propaganda' was accomplished, they were to try to return to Ukraine.
A former UPA commander who participated in one of these breakouts to the West made the following commentary:
"Do you think they (the Americans) had no intelligence on the scope of our struggle? But they were not interested in the fate of our people. They did not send a single bullet to the UPA.
"Suddenly, in 1949 and 1950, they declared their readiness to help us. They offered planes and pilots to take our insurgences back to the country, LA dropping them in the Stryi and Ternopil regions. On that occasion, they did not hesitate to overfly the borders, nor did Moscow raise a protest against these flights.
"So, our well-known veteran commander Hromenko and many others went back, and immediately fell victim to ambushes... In collaboration... with Soviet agents such as (Kim) Philby, the Americans helped Moscow destroy our revolutionary movement. Dozens of our fighters boarded these planes to go to their graves" (12).
In the framework of its sharp rivalry with the CIA, the British Intelligence Service organised similar flights, with the same result - the NKVD troops were waiting at the drop points.
These air operations were in progress when (in the spring of 1951) a Ukrainian Marxist living in exile in the United States, Vsevolod Holubnychy, informed his comrades of the Ukrainian revolutionary left in West Europe:
"The State Department's policy... is openly anti-Ukrainian. I have quite precise information on the attitudes in this regard.
"They see the UPA as a bluff that will lead to nothing. They recognise that the UPA exists, but they think that it has no perspectives, that it is very weak, that it does not have the support of the people, and in general that its activities are of a semibandit character"
These opinions that the US government came out with contradict, as we have already seen, the confidential information it got from its intelligence services.
"On the other hand", Holubnychy continued, "they are afraid of the Ukrainian underground. They are treating Poltava's letter to the Voice of America as ultrasecret material and therefore not publishing it anywhere. (But we will "help' them a bit, because in a coming issue of Labor Action [13] more significant excerpts from this letter will be published). The ultrasecrecy they are keeping is owing to casts directed at listeners in the USSR.
*The Soviet masses hate the Bolshevik 'socialism'. But that does not mean that the Soviet peoples are longing for capitalism which was destroyed on the territory of the present USSR back in 1917-1920. They are in their absolute majority clearly against the restoration of capitalism. This is the result of the revolution of 1917-1920...
*We, the participants in the liberation struggle in Ukraine, who are inside the Soviet Union and have connections with the broad masses, know only too well that they have no admiration for capitalism - neither the old European kind nor the modern American kind" (15).
In another document, in analysing the possibility of the/outbreak of the Third World War, Poltava pointed out that the United States and Britain, together with the entire Western bloc would act in such a war as enemies of the liberation of the peoples and Imperialism As regards the USSR, they would try to restore private property and rebuild a 'White' Great Russian imperialism. 'The Ukrainian people, and, we hope, also the other oppressed non-Russian peoples of the USSR, will in this situation see such a war as a new war by world imperialism, during which the national and social aspirations of the Soviet peoples can be achieved only if they are won by these peoples themselves, relying on their own strength" (16).
It is clear that the rulers in the White House had no political interest in aiding the UPA. They knew that the interests that they represented were incompatible with the interests expressed by the Ukrainian liberation movement.] But something more determined the attitude of the US government. An independent Ukraine that would carry out the political programme of the UPA was as terrifying a perspective for the White House as it was for the Kremlin.
This was all the mote so because the Ukraine, which is the biggest country in Europe in area and one of the largest in population, would inevitably play a great role in the life of the continent, and could destabilise all the 'geopolitical moulds' and the spheres of domination established in the Yalta accords.
It was one thing to open up the fronts of the 'Cold War'. It was something else again to permit a 'historyless' but powerful people to take advantage of this, to take its destiny in its own hands and, by exercising an attraction on the masses of other countries, begin to dictate its own rules.
Poltava wrote, and this was well known in 1950 in US ruling circles:
*To achieve our objectives, we have taken the road that involves unleashing a people's revolution for national and social revolution, both in Ukraine and among all the other peoples of the USSR. We call on all the oppressed Soviet peoples and on the toiling masses of all nationalities in the USSR to unite with us in the fight to overthrow the Bolshevik regime' At the same time, Poltava defined the international dimensions of the Ukrainian national revolution as follows: We are fighting "for full realisation of the idea of building free national states of all the peoples of the world by overthrowing every kind of imperialism" and "for the victory of the idea of building a classless society among all peoples" (17).
Continued
Scan page 8
'DENY YOUR AND YOU GO centre The Cold Wat" was combined with a Holy Alliance, at least tacitly. The Kremlin mercilessly exterminated the Ukrainian liberation movement and Jffered "irrefutable proofs' to the world of its 'fascist character' • The White House from time to time sang the praises of the Ukrainian freedom fighters, but refused any material aid, while the Voice of America and other stations broadcasting to the Soviet bloc maintained a total silence about their programme.
One American socialist observed at che time: "Responsible and intelligent caputalıst policy, in today' s world, tinds it dangerous to play with the fire of revolution behind the Iron Curtain" (18).
Today, Reagan has protested against the fate reserved for a Ukrainian who is being pressed to deny his father. But the US president is continuing to maintain silence about the programme that the father of this Jkrainian and the movement he led rought for.
This suits perfectly the Kremlin rulers who have striven for decades to erase from the people's memory the programme of the UPA, which called on the masses to fight to the death to overthrow the power of the Stalinist magnates and against restoration of the power of the capitalists. And the Kremlin has done this with such perseverance that it cannot even be known if Yuriy Shukhevych at any time in his life ever had the opportunity to get to know this programme.
We should not be surprised it some day Reagan, or his successor, declares in front of the TV cameras to the entire 'Free World' that he swears by the ideas for which Yuriy Shukhevych's father fell. He can afford that luxury. Only a few people still know what these ideas were.
I read recently that Reagan has declared himself a supporter of Solidarnosc's programme. How could he say that he is a supporter of a programme that calls for building a Self-Governed Republic based on social ownership of the means of production and on workers' self-management?
Chicanos
Why not? If American workers and unionists do not know much more about it than American Blacks and Chicanos know about the programme of the Ukrainian Insurgent Army?
We should realise the kind of world we are living in. The Kremlin satraps lay claim to the tradition of the Russian revolution and declare their support for the Third World liberation movements. The man who led the victorious revolution against American imperialism in Cuba goes to Moscow to proclaim there sun w The which ians, house that you can't th a finger" sun in question is the USSR, other revolutionis s, the Ukrainexcoriated as a giant prison of nations.
Polish
Some leaders of the Polish revolucion, crushed by the totalitarian bureaucracy, have sent the chiefs of US imperialism, which exploits the workers and oppresses the peoples of a good part of the planet, expressions of gratitude for the latters' intransigent defence of democracy. We have to recognise the devastating consequences all of that has for the consciousness of the workers and peoples enemy they face.
You could get the impression that we have set one foot in the Orwellian world in which 'freedom is siavery and ignorance is power' . But we should not give way to impressions. We should assume our responsibilities.
In the West, the activists of socialist, radical and alternative currents that oppose both capitalism and bureaucratic despotism - or as some of them prefer to say, private and corporate capitalism on the one hand and state capitalism on the other - have to assume the tasks of building real solidarity with the victims of the Stalinist totalitarian regimes. Only such fighters can really solidarise with the superhuman resistance of a man such as Yuriy Shukhevych, throwing into the faces of his Stalinist torturers and his imperialist 'defenders' at the same time the political ideas of Roman Shukhevych and his comrades who fell 35 years ago.
It is only those who are fighting for a democratic and international socialism, who aspire to build a self-managed and classless society, who can win such solidarity from growing sections of the workers' movement, the peace movement and other social movements in the West, as well as from the national liberation movements in the Third World. Only they can sustain a strong ideological struggle against currents that are using Reagan and company's "solidarity with individuals such as Yuriy Shukhevych or with social movements such as Solidarnose as pretexts to turn their back on these individuals and movements and wash their hands of the crimes of Stalinism.
The East In the East, forces are beg arise ready to take on a sir where they are and to act with those who are assuming task in the West.
I. Visti z Ukrayiny (Kiev) no.2 2. Ukhrayins'ki Samostiinyk 3. Vpered (Munich) 13).
ng to task unity same 8, 1985. (Munich) 4. I.Kuszeliwec (ed.), Ukraina 1956. 1968, Instytut Literacki, Paris 1969, 5. Ibid, p.207. 6. Ibid, p.209 7. The Ukrainian Herald issue 6: Dissent in Ukraine, An Underground Journal from Soviet Ukraine, Smoloskyp Publishers, Baltimore-Paris-Tor onto 1977, pp.165-168. 8. Koszeliwec, op.cit., p.206, 9. Herald of Repression in Ukraine 10. USSR News Brief - Human Rights (Munich) no. 15/16, 1985. 11. Nature and Extent of Disaffection in the Ukraine, Department of State, OIR Report no.4228-R, The National Archives of the United States. 12. Y.Borets'-Chumak, Reid bez zbroyi, Ukrainian Publishers, London 13. Labor Action was the weekly newspaper of the Independent Socialist League, a North American left-wing party. Excerpts from Poltava's letter mentioned above were published in its May 21, 1951, issue. 14. V.Holubnychy, Zvit ch.2 (April 16, 1951), in his archives deposed at the University of Alberta, Canada. 15. P.Poltava, Zbirnyk pıdplinykh Pysan' , Ukrayins kyi Samostlinyk, Munich 1959, pp.213-214. 16. Ibid, p.236, 17. Ibid, pp.128, 130 18. H.Draper, 'Washington New Russian Revolution', L June 11, 1951
----- pull-quotes -----
throughout the world, in whatever camp they live, whatever immediate