Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Yes, smash Israel!

Socialist Organiser no. 271, 29 May 1986 · scan pp. 8–9 · about 1,616 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

strategy on these generalities. But to be anti-semitic.

Does the common left-wing slogan 'Smash the Zionist state' wittingly imply anti-semitism? In recent articles in Socialist Organiser John O'Mahony has argued that it does: while supporting the Palestinians against oppression, we must recognise the right of the Israeli Jews to a nation-state. Here the Labour Movement Campaign for Palestine criticises O'Mahony's argument, and Not long ago Socialist Organiser Socialiet Oroaniser initiated discussion about the attitude to be taken by socialists towards the Palestinian and Hebrew national questions. The seriousness with which that discussion was undertaken contrasts sharply with the curious methods of John O'Mahony's polemic of recent weeks.

O'Mahony's central thesis is made clear in "Anti-semitism and the left, part 2" (SO no. 266). He writes: "Zionism - which though the precise meaning of the word is no longer clear must include most Jews - has entered the consciousness of large parts of the left as another word for the worst form of imperialism and racism. Our attitude to it should be little different from our attitude to fascism. The prevalent programme on the left for dealing with it is to "destroy Zionism', that is, destroy srael."

It is curious. that O'Mahony chinks that Zionism "no longer" has any clear meaning, though he seems to think that the term "anti-semitism" has so clear a meaning that it doesn't merit the slightest attention.

Let us say straight away that we eo not think that there is any truth 3 what O'Mahony asserts. That oes not mean that there are no mistaken attitudes towards Zionsm, towards racism, imperialism, Arab nationalism and the ways of jealing with these currents in and out of the labour movement. But to educe all this to "anti-semitism" is a tidiculous perversion of the truth.

First of all the problem: it s true that on the left there is widespread tendency to mask the shortcomings, failures, even crimes of those forces engaged in a struggle with an imperialist power or the agent of an imperialist power.

Obviously this leads some leftists to oversimplify such struggles and see then in moral terms: as if the forces of unalloyed good were combatting the forces of unmitigated evil. No doubt this is as true of the Palestine-Israel conflict as of scores of others.

But while O Mahony often written on this Socialist Organiser no. 271 29 May 1986 page 8 he replies. problem - claims that the attitude taken by the left towards this conflict is "unique" , the truth of it is that the attitude taken by the left on the Palestine-Israel conflict in general and on the question of the destruction of the state of Israel in particular is completely in line with its attitude on other cases of conflicts between settler states or the states deriving from colonial settlement and the national movements of the indigenous population directed against these states. We need only mention in this connection South Africa and Ireland to prove our point. Of course the left may be wrong on these questions, it may have been wrong on Algeria -though we don't think so - but it is not making a special or "unique" case of Israel!

Thus we see no reason to attribute the left's errors - if errors they are - on the question of Israel to some "unique" cause - like antisemitism. O'Mahony's claim that the left tries to make its programme on the Hebrew national question seem not unique "by identifying Israel with South Africa" is absurd: it is the identification of Israel as a society based on recent settler colonialism that is the essential feature it shares with South Africa.

O'Mahony's point, however, illustrates that he is just as guilty of dealing with moral rather than scientific judgements as those he inveighs against. He says "Whatever similarity in political military-techniques (!) there may be between South Africa and Israel they are radically different societies. Israel was given its character by the Zionists' resolute refusal to exploit Arab labour and their drive instead who has to replace it (!). Whatever one general thinks of the left Zionist colonialists" "Jewish labour only policy, it was the opposite (!) of the mass exploitation on which the modern South Africa was built." Really, this is amazing!

Is the colonisation and the denial by a relative minority of settlers of the national rights of the indigenous majority simply a matter of "political-military techniques"? Isn't Israel's character based not so much on the replacement of Arab labour by Jewish labour, but the driving out of their homes of hundreds of thousands of people, the denial of their right to return and the imposition on the area to which they had undisputed rights of an alien rule? Is the effect - rather than the technique - of Zionist colonisation really "the opposite" of that in South Africa?

It isn't simply the same, that's true: indeed right now South Africa seems to be attempting something like an Israeli solution while Israel seems to be developing certain traits reminiscent of South Africa. But let's be clear: the point isn't that Israel is just like South Africa, but that despite their differences they share essential colonial-settler traits. O'Mahony might take issue with this: he might believe that Israel can't be classed as a colonial-settler state. But then this is the nub of the issue and not this obsessive silliness about anti-semitism.

It is possible - indeed likely -that identification of Israel with South Africa (with whom of course it has a special relationship) and identification of Zionism as a racist ideology leads some leftists to thinking that they can do away with concrete analysis and rest any strategy on these generalities. But does this invalidate the generalities? Not at all! Zionism is racist even if many of those diplomats insisting on this in the UN daily defend racism: Zionism is racist even if the way socialists should deal with Zionism is markedly different from the way they should deal with traditional British racism.

Is it true that for "large parts of th left" Zionism is "another word for the worst form of imperialism and racism"? Firstly, it is obvious that for the avowedly reformist left, Zionism is a form of socialism. For which avowedly revolutionary organisations then is it "the worst form of imperialism and racism"? For the Healyites? But O Mahony has written in the past that the Healyites aren't even part of the 'abour movement let alone the left. For Militant? Hardly. For the USFI? We don't think so and a single quote revealing its shortcomings on Iran can hardly be said to prove the case.

In any case, doesn't the USFI support the right of Israeli Jews to self-determination? That hardly makes it a candidate for the charge of anti-semitism, The SWP, perhaps? Despite some very irresponsible positions taken by SWP students, an organisation that founded the Anti-Nazi League, launching it with a call signed by socres of celebrities who no doubt support Lionısm, can hardly be accused of adopting an attitude towards Zionism "little different from our attitude to fascism" Which "large sections" does that leave bloodied by O'Mahony's sharp-edged polemic?

Surely the point is simply that those who think that the world is divided into two moral camps and whose most sophisticated analytical tool is the allegation of guilt by association - as O'Mahony does himself time and again - end up with wrong political positions.

The trouble is that O'Mahony adds to the confusion - which is not in fact as great as he points out, which is why the only texts he can analyse in detail are Gerry Healy's nonsense - by his disgraceful claim that to oppose Zionism is be anti-sémitic.

It is true that sections of the early socialist movement (especially the anarchists) saw something progressive in anti-semitism and others, including Marx, were too inclined to identify Jews with the rise of capitalism. True too that Stalinism made use of anti-semitism, particularly in its attacks on Trotsky and that the German Communist Party made concessions to anti-semitism in order to try to relate to the nationalist "voelkische" right both in the 20s and in the 30s. Ruth Fischer, shortly before she became Party leader, called on her audience to "crush the Jew-capitalists, string them up from the lamp-posts, trample them underfoot" '. This is not unimportant, but we must be wary of the conclusions we can draw from it.

Whatever its ideological shortcomings from time to time the left - which is today infinitely more sensitive to issues of racism than in the past - has an unparalleled record of fighting fascism and racısm, ıncluding anti-semitism. We ask: whose heroism in the Battle of Cable Street helped to stop the Mosleyites? Who supported the Anti Nazi League? Who are the activists in scores of anti-fascist and anti-racist committees up and down the country that, among other things, monitor and combat anti-semitism? What is O'Mahony's answer? The right, the middle of the road liberals and social-democrats?

Let's be serious: even if O'Mahony's description of the traditions of the left were accurate - and it most certainly isn't! - does it make any sense to call these fighters against anti-semitism *antisemites"? When one considers the ver large number of Jews among these fighters - most of them anti-Zionist Jews - O'Mahony's insulting designation becomes even more lurid.

But O'Mahony's mud slinging is not only insulting: it implies a rewriting of history. For if the left can be called anti-semitic for sometimes in its pre-World War 2 past Continued p.9

Scan page 9

From page 8 page endorsing or echoing anti-semitic It is not surprising that O'Mahony's slurs, illogic and fact-twisting

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 271

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →