Israel isn't S. Africa
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-05-29Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Reader request 5 Nov 2026 (the Sunderland Poly and UJS articles): transcribed from the scan; the machine reading had run in other pieces on the page (the p. 9 continuation of Yes, smash Israel!, now given after that article, and a Summer School advertisement). No by-line is printed on p. 9; it answers the Yes, smash Israel! writers in the first person. "much large black population", "forcible destroying" and "LMCP" as printed.
Proofed text: read against the scan word by word; spelling, punctuation and wording are as printed.
Scan page 9
OH WHAT a monstrous deal of splutter and bumpf to so small a part of solid matter! So many angry words, and so few of the key points I made on anti-semitism taken up!
No, I did not 'reduce' what the writers describe as 'mistaken attitudes towards Zionism...' to 'anti-semitism' — i.e. say these things arose as an expression of the traditional anti-semitisms. I said that the attitude to Israel dominant in most of the far left is unique in that it proposes to destroy not only a 'state' but the Israeli Jewish nation, and that on that level 'anti-Zionism' is inevitably anti-semitic — firstly and primarily towards the Israeli Jews, and secondly, by derivation, towards the big majority of Jews throughout the world who solidarise with Israel. This may include attempts to treat Zionist Jews (as distinct from other, non-Jewish, Zionists) as if they are fascists — for example banning their student associations, as was done recently at Sunderland Poly.
The writers insist that "the attitude taken by the left on the Palestine-Israel conflict... is completely in line with its attitude on other cases of conflicts between settler states or states deriving from colonial settlement and the national movements of the indigenous population directed against those states". As other examples they mention South Africa, Northern Ireland, and pre-independence Algeria, which had a large white population.
The comrades 'scientifically' satisfy themselves that all these, especially Israel and South Africa, are similar 'settler states', and then read off mechanically a common political programme: smash the settler state.
But — isn't it obvious? — even if the 'settler state' tag fits Northern Ireland, South Africa, and Israel, these societies are so vastly different that the tag alone is inadequately concrete to base any political conclusions on. What differentiates them is more important than the common name-tag.
It is preposterous to equate Northern Ireland's Protestant community with the South African whites. One is a replication of British society — though with some peculiarities — the other is a vastly privileged white caste ruling over a much large black population who are super-exploited, disenfranchised, repressed helots.
And in Israel there is not a ruling Jewish caste exploiting Arab helots, there is a comprehensive Jewish society organised in a Jewish nation state. This is not the same sort of society as South Africa's or colonial Algeria's!
'Smash the settler state' in South Africa or colonial Algeria means: abolish the monopoly of power and the caste privileges of the white minority; let the majority rule.
Overrun
But what does 'smash the settler state' mean for Israel? It is a state which is extremely democratic for its Jewish majority. Its army is pretty close to being a citizen army. For an external force to 'smash the state' is not a matter of destroying a repressive apparatus, or defeating it in war, but of overrunning Israel and forcible destroying the Jewish nation. It could only be done by slaughter, expropriation and terror — and, pretty much for certain, the driving out of large parts of the population.
Do the crimes of the Israeli occupying forces in the West Bank and elsewhere make this poetic justice? If so, say so! The comparison with South Africa and with Algeria — where the settlers were mostly driven out — implies that programme, but I'm not sure that the writers understand that that is what they are saying.
People who play around the edge of a question, juggling with abstract labels, often do so because they need to avoid the real issues. In politics, comrades, the truth is always concrete.
The comrades' attempt to prove that it is not true that large parts of the left think of 'Zionism' 'as another word for the worst form of imperialism and racism' is junior debating society stuff.
Sure, I've written that the Healyites are not part of the labour movement — but the Healyite text which I analysed appeared on the same page as an endorsement from Ken Livingstone of the Healyites against their 'Zionist' persecution, and Livingstone did not repudiate the editorial when specifically invited to do so. Labour Herald, the Healyite Labour Party paper, was for a long time highly respectable on sections of the left.
Of course the SWP is anti-racist and opposed to anti-semitism. I never said otherwise.
Most telling of all is the case of the USFI. Yes, the USFI believes in self-determination for the Jews of Palestine. But what do their people in Britain say and do about it? They are silent about it. It is common to find members of theirs utterly unaware that their organisation has held this position for many years.
Do the comrades seriously want to deny that the most common attitude on the hard (and much even of the soft) left now is intense hostility to Israel, support for the Palestinians, and support for the 'secular, democratic state'? That, even though it often lacks coherence and consistency, the left attitude often goes far beyond the criticisms of Israel which SO shares, and in fact supports the replacement of any Jewish state with something else?
It is true that Israeli apologists attempt to morally blackjack critics of Israel into silence with cries of 'anti-semitism'. Criticism of Israel or of Zionism is equated with anti-semitism. This of course is contemptible.
There is, however, a level at which 'anti-Zionism' is indeed anti-semitic — the level at which 'anti-Zionism' becomes support for the destruction of the existing Jewish nation in Palestine.
Quite the most revealing thing in the comrades' article is their account of anti-semitism and the labour movement. They know something about the subject. Therefore I don't believe they really think it all came to an end with the Second World War.
They know, for example, about the tide of thinly disguised anti-semitism in the USSR and Eastern Europe — and the Western CPs — after 1948. The reason the learned comrades prefer much more remote examples, of course, is that this, the most sustained and murderous anti-semitic campaign in any body claiming to be part of the labour movement, was conducted under the banner of 'anti-Zionism'.
Most of the stuff on why and how the left could not be anti-semitic is bumpf, answering charges I never made, and missing the point that I did make: that the widespread left-wing commitment to the destruction of the Jewish state is inescapably anti-semitic, however sincere the same left is in its condemnation of Nazism, Christian anti-semitism, etc. etc.
The writers trip themselves up, too. How could left-wing movements have been anti-semitic when they contained Jewish militants, they ask. They themselves give us at least part of the answer. Earlier they mention the German communist leader Ruth Fischer denouncing 'Jew-capitalists'. Yes. But, comrades, unless my memory is playing tricks, Ruth Fischer — who was an honest communist who lived to learn from her mistakes — was a Jew!
The argument about Zionism and Nazism is irrelevant. I am not concerned to defend Zionism's record, and nothing I say about Israel now depends on doing that.
It is also obscene. For what is the point of going on about the many episodes of Zionist would-be real-politikers who made the best deals they could with various anti-semites, from Turkish dignitaries at the beginning to Nazis 50 years later?
The point for some 'anti-Zionists', like Tony Greenstein, a prominent member of the LMCP, is to try to smear the Zionists with some of the responsibility for the crimes of the Nazis — for the holocaust of six million Jews.
Double-edged
Wrongheaded, shortsighted, stupid, criminal as were many of the activities of the Zionist leaders who thought they could find some common ground with anti-semites because both agreed on the separating-out of the Jews, it is obscene to attribute to them a part of the responsibility for the holocaust.
It is a childish attempt to escape from the powerful retrospective logic the holocaust imparts to the Zionist case by saying to the Zionist: you caused or helped cause Hitler — you collaborated!
And it is double-edged and very dangerous for pro-Palestinians to attempt to condemn the people of Israel now because of the deals which some of their grandfathers and fathers made or attempted to make with the all-powerful monster which destroyed so many helpless millions of them. For the leaders of the Palestinians collaborated with the Nazis too. Their chief political leader, the Mufti of Jerusalem, actively worked for the Nazi cause from Berlin. There is no good reason to doubt that had the Nazis got to Palestine — and they almost decided to try in 1940-1 — then Palestine would have become a slaughterhouse for the Jews and the Mufti's Palestinian Arab followers would have been actively on the side of the Nazis, just as the Zionist Haganah collaborated with the British to brutally put down the Syrian-Palestine Arab revolt in 1936 — but with the difference that the Nazis would have killed every last Jew in Palestine.
Nationalist
Of course this ancient Palestinian collaboration with the Nazis can have no effect on our attitude to the oppressed Palestinians today. But neither can all the historical footnotes about the Zionists in the 1930s have any effect on our attitude to the rights of the Palestinian Jews. Our attitudes must come from the rights and wrongs of the conflict, and from the possible solutions.
Time and again the comrades' argument comes down to moral exasperation. And the lesson is that if you stop at moral protest, then you only distance yourself from 'Zionism' but remain on the same nationalist plane. You do not rise to the level of working-class, internationalist politics.