Trotsky's daughter
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-05-29Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
Bryan Edmunds reviews 'Zina', now on general release.
The main body of this film which is superbly photographed, interchanging from monochrome to colour -centres on the relationship between Zina, undergoing psychoanalysis with a doctor, a Professor Konselt, in Berlin and flashbacks to Prinkipo with her father, Trotsky and her stepmother, Natalia.
Zina is in a situation of much stress and great physical danger with no escape or release. She sees the world around her descending into barbarism.
Fascism
Fascism is a gros ving menace on the streets daughter of such a great (and Jewish) man as Trotsky would be a prime target for them.
However, the danger does not stop there for her. The Communist Parties, already heavily Stalinised, and taking their ideological orders from the Kremlin, see the small group of left oppositionists, Trotskyists, as a group to be attacked and destroyed.
Dividing
Instead of acting to unite workers - communists, socialists, anarchists, Trotskyists, in a united front to fight their common enemy, the Nazis, (as urgently advocated by Trotsky) the Communist Party ends up attacking and dividing its potential class allies.
Zina is in isolation. True she has a small band of Trotskyists to turn to in Berlin, including Lyova, Trotsky's son and her half-brother. facing dangers and besides they have momentarily escapes and releases in the form of personal relationships, something not open to her.
But these comrades are also Zina seems to be all alone caught between an exterior world gone mad and her thoughts of the past, thoughts of her father, the great revolutionary leader and his rejection' of her when she was a child (he left her and her mother in exile in Siberia in 1903 to escape from Russia).
In this situation of powerlessness to influence the forces of class conflict growing around her, in favour of the working class, she resolves her dilemma and escapes from a sick world by taking poison in 1933.
Justice
It is difficult to do this film justice in a few words. There are many aspects that I have not touched pon, the symbolism in the film, for instances, the references to Antigone in Zina's mind, Trotsky's speeches on Churchill, Fascism, , history, socialist realism, etc.
I do have just two small criticisms. The main doubt in my mind about the correctness of the film is the ending. Did the Professor really hand over tapes to a Russian soldier and did she really keep the tapes intact for the future after being told that they concerned the daughter of Trotsky.
Weak
Secondly there is a short scene where Zina witnesses a Communist worker being attacked by Nazis they seemed very weak to me!
Finally, in the credits tribute is paid to the Isaac Deutscher triology on Trotsky's life, The Prophet Armed, The Prophet Unarmed and The Prophet Outcast. If this film has made any impact on those who do not know much about the background to the film, these would be well worth reading.
Zina is an impressive film.
nfe:
CPSA Alistair Graham made certain that his last CPSA conference as general secretary would be remembered by using his "Introduction of the Annual Report" on the morning of 14 May to launch a vitriolic attack on the Militant Tendency, who have a sizeable presence in the union.
Calling for a coalition between the right and the soft left to act together against Militant, Graham threatened to produce a report for the Labour Party on Militant's activities within CPSA - including naming individual supporters in order to set them up for expulsion.
In the national elections; the right wing retained control of the CPSA's Executive Committee, with Marion Chambers capturing the post of president by a margin of 3,000 votes. The Broad Left candidate. Kevin Roddy, came second.
The Broad Left succeeded in taking one of the two Vice-President posts: the other officers to be elected annually, rather than once every 5 years as at present. However, neither Militant, Broad Lett "84 nor the right wing will presently support this demand, and so the motions fell heavily.
Despite the pasage of some worthy motions in support of the printworkers, against the Tory "Public Order Bill" and against the Union of Democratic Mineworkers, the 1986 CPSA conference was largely one in which we had to fight to stand still.
Change is on the way in the Society of Civil and Public Servants (SCPS) - the second largest civil service union behind the CPSA, and the union which covers the executive and manager grades in the civil service.
For years the 'left' operated in SCPS behind closed doors, keeping the rank and file well away from decision making and keeping quiet on most issues so as not to upset their traditionally moderate membership.
----- pull-quotes -----
SC PS meet