More on Chernobyl
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-05-29Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
cabbage and one cauliflower power policy and the Wales were tested, though grass Labour Party conference samples showed several times voted to phase out nuclear the level of radioactivity at power by a two-thirds majorwhich cattle should be with- ity, despite please by drawn from pasture. Kinnock National available: Send s.a.e. and an Protection extra 12p stamp to PO Box Board and yet no-one seemed 823 London SE15 4NA.
Soeialist Orgániser nó. 271 29 M 1986 page 10 In our four-page special on the Chernobyl disaster last issue* , we tried to answer three questions in particular: What happened? What effect would there be on people? Could it happen again elsewhere (e.g. in Britain)?
In addition, radioactivity, nuclear power and the effects of radiation were explained. The political repercussions were also examined.
Since then, some more gaps in the story have been blocked WHY DID IT HAPPEN?
It was known that the accident started with a surge in power from 7% to 50% of normal at 0123 on Saturday 26 April (Soviet European Time). The sudden overheatng gave rise to all the other effects (hydrogen explosion, graphite fire, cloud of fallout, etc).
But what caused the initial power surge? It now seems to have been the result of an operator altering the position of the control rods which keep the chain reaction under control.
And why did the operator move the rods? It seems to have been either "experimental research work" or our old friend "human error" Both nave been referred to by Russian officials.
Experts UK nuclear experts were quick to say that our procedures would prevent a Chernobyl-type accident. However, there can be no doubt that "experimental research work" is carried out here. Furthermore, our reactors are also run by humans, who may err on occasion.
At Three Mile Island, a mall mechanical failure nearly gave rise to a meltdown due to the refusal of operators to believe their own instruments, WESTERN REACTORS AS UNSAFE AS CHERNOBYL?
After all the assertions that the RMBK-1000 would not have been licensed in the West, experts have admitted that the RMBK at Chernobyl ctually matched up to WestScienc ern safety standards.
Despite claims that it lacked secontary containment walls, it is clear now that not only did it have such walls but that they were stronger than those in at least ten US reactors. The concrete floor at Chernobyl, which guards against meltdown, was also larger than in US reactors. There was also a well-protected and duplicated power system and its control instruments were actually made in the West. Indeed, it is possible that faults in these instruments may have prevented operators knowing what was going on.
HOW MANY WILL BE AFFECTED?
Our estimates of some 25 deaths in the first weeks seem in line with the known facts. Most of the 300 or so hospital cases should survive but will suffer very high rates of cancer and deformed offspring. The bone marrow transplants in the serious ill cases are unlikely to save more than a couple, unfortunately, as fatal damage is likely to have been caused to the digestive system by the levels of radiation which kill bone marrow.
It must be emphasised that the intensive care given to these relatively few patients has taxed Russian medical resources. The chaos resulting from even one atom bomb can scarce be imagined.
The 7000 inhabitants of Pripyat (a kilometre from the fire) have received less than 50 rads, according to Russian sources. This is not enough radiation to cause immediate illness, but they will suffer much higher cancer and deformed offspring.
The 100,000 people of the town of Chernobyl (15 km away) should have received less radiation still but, owing to the delay in evacuating them, will have been exposed more than necessary.
Russian authorities are therefore preparing to monitor over 100,000 people for the rest of their lives, as some health effects can take decades to show:
HOW WELL WERE PROTECTED?
Our government's response should make us extremely worried in case a similar accident occurs here, At the conference of the Institute of Professional Civil Servants, government scientists revealed that the government had taken ten days to release figures showing severe contamination in parts of Scotland. The exact areas were not revealed!
Precautions
The Scottish Office said that no special precautions were necessary. However, a universities-funded research centre advised people not to drink milk for two weeks.
Farmers also found it difficult to get advice and IPCS delegates stressed the need for a coherent system of radiation monitoring.
This was underlined in last week's New Scientist which revealed that British vegetables were passed safe for human consumption on the basis of less than fifty samples nationwide. Incredibly, in Scotland, worst affected by fall-out, no vegetables were sampled.
In Cumbria. just one This level is set by the government-run Radiological to have farmers. ulture, lenied 1 sibility the job of warning The Ministry of AgriFisheries and Food hat it was its responFailure The government's failure to warn against drinking milk may result in 150 extra thyroid cancers, according to John Urquhart, a statician at Newcastle University. His analysis of the 1957 Windscale fire revealed the forgotten role of radioactive polonium in the fall-out. His estimate is about five times that of the NRPB, but it should be remembered that it was the NRPB that "forgot" about the polonium from Windscale, TORY STRATEGY FOR RADIATION PROTECTION Like other "luxuries", , such as the NHS and science research, the NRPB has been starved of cash. Its extra work monitoring the Chernobyl fall-out has to be paid for out of its existing cash allocation and its expected deficit of f½ million this year will have to be made up by staff cuts or by taking on commercial work.
The government has also decided to close Letcombe Laboratory, near Cambridge. Its job was to monitor fallout in rural areas!
Another body investigating the effects of radiation pollution is the Institute of Terrestrial Ecology. While Sellafield scientists get £1 million a day, the ITE gets only £50,000 a year, LABOUR NUCLEAR POWER POLICY Kinnock and Cunningham are coming under increasing pressure to follow Labour Party policy. The firefighters, cine technicians and communications workers unions have all adopted anti-nuclear *Chernobyl Special still going to the veteran "Trotbasher" Kate Losinska. However, only three other NEC seats went to the Broad Left, with another three going to Broad Left 84. Although the Broad Left now have total control over the Section Executive in DHSS (the union's largest section), its influence in other sectors is not as strong.
One of the major decisions taken by Conference was to pass a rule change allowing CPSA to set up a political fund: members will be balloted on the issue at a later date. Both the right wing and Broad Left 84 rejected the idea of tying this ballot directly to the principle of Labour Party affiliation, though a motion was carried instructing the NEC to follow up a positive vote on the political fund "by campaigning for the union's reaffiliation to the Labour Party?
Another disappointment occured with the efforts made by the Socialist Caucus (a hard left grouping that includes SO supporters) to extend union democracy. We submitted motions calling for the union's senior full-time However in 1984 an open, democratic, campaigning Broad Left was formed, intent on opening up the SCPS. The Broad Left campaigned for individual workplace ballot for the executive and for election addresses so the members could see where candidates stood, and for the election of full time officials.
The old secret left' run by the CP opposed the proposals on the grounds that it would hand the union over to the right wing.
At the SCPS Conference (12-16 May) the Broad Left successfully argued that individual balloting should also apply to the president and vice-presidents, Election addresses are also going to be introduced for the first time. Unfortunately full timers will still be appointed rather than elected.
But one thing is now clear. If the left' in SCPS want to retain their positions in the hierarchy they are going to have to start campaigning and not ducking the issues. The open Broad Left will campaign on hard, socialist policies in the elections in the Autumn.
industrial action. The ballot returned a two-to-one major-