Yes, smash Israel! (continued)
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-05-29Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
The p. 9 part ("From page 8") of Yes, smash Israel!, which the machine split had cut off after one line. Transcribed from the scan (5 Nov 2026). "revolutionarities" and "occured" as printed; a few letters that did not print are restored from context.
Proofed text: read against the scan word by word; spelling, punctuation and wording are as printed.
Scan page 9
endorsing or echoing anti-semitic ideas, in however small measure, cannot Zionism itself be called anti-semitic with even greater justice? Here we have a movement which has no real history of fighting anti-semitism, though it has a long history of doing deals with anti-semites. Here we have an outlook held by community leaders who spend their time pouring abuse on anti-fascists (retailing claims similar to those now being rehearsed by O'Mahony) when they organise to combat anti-semitism. Here we have an ideology which has at its core the idea that fighting anti-semitism is useless because anti-semitism is essentially justified.
Indeed, while it is true that prominent British Labour leaders — to their shame — supported the 1905 Aliens Act (something which had more to do with their reformism and nationalism than with anti-semitism), what O'Mahony fails to mention is that Balfour and the anti-semites of the British Brothers League who lobbied for the Act were given unequivocal support by the Zionists organised in the English Zionist Federation in the 1900 and 1906 general elections. David Hope-Kydd, who described the Jewish immigrants as the "scum of the European nations" was supported by the Zionists in the Whitechapel constituency. Similarly the French anti-semites and later Mussolini and even certain Nazis before 1941 actually praised Zionism and saw it as an ideological movement similar to their own.
We don't cite this to prove that Zionism is simply the same as anti-semitism — though both drink in part from the same poisoned pools — rather to show that O'Mahony's account is not only absurd in its conclusions but partisan to the point of mendacity.
Anti-Zionist socialists are in the habit of explaining both in the face of slurs from Zionists and as part of their struggle against anti-semitism, that anti-Zionism and anti-semitism are not the same. We patiently explain, for instance, that Zionism was for half its history a minority trend among Jews, indeed one seen by millions of Jews as a treasonous current, always willing to do the bidding of anti-semites. We point out — and O'Mahony makes the point too — that certain ultra-orthodox Jews are vigorous opponents of Zionism and that orthodox Jews of all trends were opposed to Zionism up to 1948.
But O'Mahony knows better. To want to see the destruction of the state of Israel — not the only but certainly a widely-held aim of anti-Zionists — is, he says, "implicitly anti-semitic". Sometimes he seems to be resting his argument on the fact that today the vast majority of Jews support the existence of the state of Israel — which is like claiming that support for Algerian independence was a product of a racist view of the French and sometimes on the spurious claim (dealt with above) that the left's programme for Israel is "unique" when all along it is of a piece with other attitudes towards colonial settler states.
It is not surprising that O'Mahony's slurs, illogic and fact-twisting influence his analysis of the slogan of the "secular, democratic state". For someone supposedly interested in the living political struggle, one would have thought that he might mention that this slogan was adopted by the PLO as the result of a struggle against those elements who wanted simply to throw the Jews into the sea.
The fact that some elements who would be happy to return to the old position currently claim to support the "secular, democratic state" slogan has nothing to do with the matter. The fact that one of the world's most conservative powers calls itself the "Soviet" Union doesn't invalidate the significance of the soviet idea for revolutionarities.
Conquest
Central to O'Mahony's argument is his estimate of the Arab or pro-Arab forces: "The road to the secular democratic state lies inescapably through war and full-scale conquest of the Jews — after which the victorious armies (of Iraq, Syria, Iran?) will gallantly establish and protect the democratic rights of the Jews as individuals (rights their own citizens do not have now) in a Palestinian Arab state." Truly a remarkable statement. Has it not occured to O'Mahony that one of the most important aspects of the "secular, democratic state' slogan is the criticism it implies of the lack of democratic rights prevailing in the Arab states, in Iran, etc? And since when do revolutionary socialists give up their strategic conceptions simply because the balance of forces for their fulfilment is not present?
One might as well ask what on earth the propagation of the idea of a socialist Britain could possibly mean when the vast majority of those calling themselves socialists are led by one Neil Kinnock. Even if you don't agree with the slogan of the "secular, democratic state", comrade, you should see that it is an attempt to create a democratic, non-confessional society in contradistinction to all others in the region (including Israel).
As far as the supposed "utopianism" of the "secular, democratic state slogan" is concerned, we insist that it is no more utopian than the slogan of a socialist united Ireland. Nor, more to the point, is it more "utopian" than O'Mahony's own solution: two states in the area currently held by Israel with the right of secession for Arab areas inside the pre-1967 boundaries. What "ism" should one ascribe to O'Mahony's inability to see any possible progressive developments within the Arab camp (that would realise the slogan of the "secular, democratic state"), while holding firmly to a solution which implies a fundamental transformation of Israeli Jewish consciousness? If O'Mahony stood in the Zionist tradition, we would just say it was typical left Zionist arrogance.
\* This article has been very slightly abbreviated for reasons of space.